Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The review of 2010 is organized into four sections, covering the main developments in ecocritical theory: Three monographs stood out, in an exceptionally busy year, as potential waymarkers for the future direction of ecocriticism: Stacy Alaimo’s Bodily Natures, John Parham’s Green Man Hopkins and Timothy Morton’s The Ecological Thought. It is difficult to overstate the impact of the last of these, and its astoundingly dynamic and prolific author, on ecocriticism in only a few years. His virtual presence has graced almost every conference and symposium I have attended in that period, baffling and thrilling grad students with his ideas, and making almost anything else in the field seem parochial and pedestrian by comparison. Some admixture of awe, envy, excitement and annoyed confusion must be in every member of the audience. The Ecological Thought is billed as a ‘prequel’ to Morton’s redoubtable Ecology without Nature, making many of the same arguments, but in a quite different idiom: ‘The ecological thought sneaks up on you from the future, a picture of what will have had to be there, already, for “ecology without nature” to make sense’ (p. 3). While the intertextual world of the earlier book halted abruptly at la Manche, the newer one continues to draw heavily upon Levinas but supplements him with Darwin and Richard Dawkins, fulfilling Derrida’s claim that deconstruction was really a kind of ‘radical empiricism’ in the most surprising way imaginable. In place of the dishearteningly involuted prose of Ecology without Nature, we are addressed with a breezy chumminess that is alternately winning and a bit tiresome. Thus we are told early on that ‘Once you start to think the ecological thought, you can’t unthink it: it’s a sphincter—once it’s open, there’s no closing’ (p. 4). (I am not clear on the facts here; isn’t the point of a sphincter that you can close it? Answers on a postcard please.) Later on, Morton recalls a concept he introduced in Ecology without Nature: ‘Dark ecology makes the world safe for the ecological thought. The only way out is down. It is the ultimate detox’ (p. 59). Some of these aperçus make for marvellously memorable soundbites that convey genuine insights, but in other cases they betray the intelligence of their author by seducing him into basic errors and brutally reductive accounts of complex matters. So while it sounds cool to say that ‘We drive around using crushed dinosaur parts’ (p. 29), the fact is that oil comes mainly from marine micro-organisms. Repeatedly The Origin of Species is invoked, quoted or referenced so as to ratify a decidedly problematic claim, such as that ‘what we call “nature” is a “denatured”, unnatural, uncanny sequence of mutations and catastrophic events: just read Darwin’ (p. 8). That is one way of looking at it, certainly, but the same ‘nature’ can exhibit extraordinary morphological, genetic and phylogenetic conservatism. Just ask a horseshoe crab.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
G. Garrard (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: