Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In The Death of Omnipotence and Birth of Amipotence, Thomas Oord has taken on one of the most difficult topics in philosophical theology: God's omnipotence. As the title indicates, Oord is both trying to eliminate traditional views of divine omnipotence and to replace these views with amipotence, a view of divine power more appropriate to open and relational theologies as well as to real-life experiences.In previous books, such as Pluriform Love and God Can't, Oord has brought up these issues, but in the context of a more inclusive discussion. In this book, as the title indicates, omnipotence and amipotence take center stage. The first three chapters discuss many of the difficulties with traditional views of omnipotence. The traditional views include the following claims: (1) God exerts all power; (2) God can do absolutely anything; and (3) God can control others or circumstances. Each of these three chapters discusses omnipotence from a different perspective. The fourth and final chapter explores amipotence, that is, presents what a truly loving God can, and does, do.In chapter 1, “Not Born of Scripture,” Oord demonstrates how the sixty-six books of the Protestant Bible do not really support any of the traditional views of God's omnipotence, and that any apparent support for omnipotence is the result of poor translations and/or not taking the whole of scripture into account. For example, Oord carefully shows that El Shaddai, often translated as God Almighty, is better translated as “the God of breasts or the breasted God” (12) or as a reference to the mountains as places of refuge (14).Chapter 2 shows how divine omnipotence is qualified or clarified from various philosophical perspectives. What happens in these processes of clarification is that, as the chapter title says, omnipotence dies a “Death by a Thousand Qualifications.” Some examples include: (1) God cannot do that which is mathematically or geometrically impossible; (2) God cannot do that which is logically impossible; (3) God cannot violate God's own nature, such as lying (i.e., God cannot tell a lie), and the list goes on. Also included in this chapter are discussions of power-sharing between the divine and creatures as well as the role of creaturely freedom.In chapter 3, Oord confronts the problem of evil and shows how “Evil Ends Omnipotence.” The problem of evil occurs when all three of the following claims are held to be true: (1) genuine evil (pointless pain and unnecessary suffering) occurs; (2) God loves all creation; and (3) God is omnipotent (79). These claims are discussed, especially as each factors in the development of various theodicies: free will, greater good, soul-making, and so on. As Oord notes, each of these traditional theodicies has serious difficulties, which may include denying genuine evil, defining love in a way that it is incomprehensible, or making God responsible for evil. Oord also presents elements of his own theodicy (95–133), which includes creaturely free will, divine empathy, cooperation between creatures and the divine, and much more.In the final chapter, Oord proposes replacing omnipotence with “amipotence.” Ami, from the Latin for love, and potens, from the Latin for power or influence (120). While amipotence has been referenced in some of his previous works, in this chapter Oord defines amipotence and discusses in more detail what is involved in this definition. “Amipotence is maximal divine power in the service of love” (123). Some elements of amipotence include the divine love of all of creation; God's omnipresence, which always is influencing creatures toward love; and creaturely free will.At various points, especially in chapter 3, Oord notes that when defenders of traditional views of omnipotence find themselves painted into a corner, so to speak, they invoke some form of an appeal to mystery, such as (1) God's ways are not our ways; (2) it is all part of God's plan that we cannot understand; (3) the evil happened for a reason that only God knows; or (4) God is totally other. Yet these traditionalists continue to talk, write, and defend omnipotence. I wonder if these traditionalists should consider taking the way of Thomas Aquinas who, as the story goes, went completely silent after claiming that all his words were only straw.Regarding the stubbornness of omnipotence, Oord astutely observes that hymns, creeds, liturgies, and worship in general have re-enforced traditional views of God's power (1–2, 5–6, 84–87, 115–116). This observation is important. The scholarly approach to promoting divine love and downplaying the place of divine omnipotence has only been minimally successful. Given its well-written and easy-to-read style, this book should help in the effort to replace divine omnipotence with divine love. Additionally, efforts that focus on changing hymns, liturgies, and so forth could help even more, though with thousands of years of tradition ingraining omnipotence into the fabric of Christianity and other Abrahamic religions, the task is formidable.In addition to its communicative style, Oord has provided worthwhile resources in the footnotes, both in terms of information and in terms of additional resources to consult. The Death of Omnipotence and Birth of Amipotence is a valuable addition in the ongoing effort to reduce the influence of God's so-called omnipotence and increase the recognition of divine love.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John M. Sweeney (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: