Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article examines how environmental governance can criminalize community care practices, indicating a need for reform.
This article examines how contemporary environmental governance can criminalize care by reclassifying subsistence, custodial and place‐based practices as environmental crime. Rather than treating ‘green mafia’ as a specific organization, the article conceptualizes it as a recurring governance configuration in which environmental authority is consolidated through alliances among states, conservation organizations and market intermediaries, whereas everyday stewardship becomes legible as illegality. Drawing on green criminology as the synthesizing framework, and on political ecology, legal pluralism and governmentality, and care ethics as supporting interpretive lenses, the study develops a three‐layer model linking environmental value claims, legibility infrastructures and enforcement outcomes. Using comparative process tracing across India's forest governance, Amazon frontier regulation and carbon market regimes, the article reconstructs how protected‐area rules, forest permits, audits, timber documentation systems, monitoring and verification protocols, audits and carbon accounting rules translate environmental benefit claims into legal and administrative categories. The analysis shows that criminalization is most likely when three conditions converge: Environmental value is made administratively measurable, customary use lacks formal documentary recognition and enforcement agencies prioritize visible, low‐capital practices over structurally embedded drivers of degradation. The article distinguishes criminalization from broader regulation by identifying the offences, sanctions and enforcement routines through which care practices are converted into trespass, encroachment, illegal collection, unauthorized extraction, permit violations, or non‐compliance with conservation and carbon rules. The findings reveal a recurrent misalignment between ecological harm and enforcement intensity. The article argues that environmental crime should be interpreted not only as a response to harm but also as a governance technique that reallocates authority, produces green assets and facilitates accumulation. It concludes that green criminology can strengthen environmental governance by shifting analysis from legality alone to harm, proportionality and the recognition of local stewardship as governance capacity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amitabh Vikram Dwivedi (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: