Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ABSTRACTOver the last three decades, the field of EU judicial behaviour has spawned a sizeable body of work. While the efforts of EU judicial scholars have indubitably generated important insights about the operation of the Court of Justice and its interactions with domestic tribunals and litigants, EU judicial behaviour research suffers from substantial limitations at multiple levels. The first arises from the field's poor integration with theoretical advances that have emerged in other contexts. The second pertains to its methodological assumptions, which have yet to be updated to respond to the credibility crisis. The third relates to the existing datasets and the paucity of data on national courts' practices outside the preliminary ruling mechanism. To address these shortcomings, I suggest how the field may benefit from incorporating theoretical advances from research on judges in other contexts, a stronger emphasis on smart designs and experimental and quasi-experimental methods and the deployment of data-crawling and Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques.KEYWORDS: EU judiciaryjudicial decision makingtheories of adjudicationmethodologycausal inferenceintegration Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 Political science research on the Court of Justice has also been surveyed in Conant (Citation2007) and Krehbiel et al. (Citation2017).2 Constitutional court judges have received more attention, see Hanretty (Citation2012, Citation2013, Citation2014). One should also mention studies of Estonian and Spanish supreme court judges (Dalla Pellegrina et al., Citation2017; Hanretty, Citation2015).3 For an attempt to develop an EU law detector for Belgian domestic decisions see Dyevre (Citation2021).4 The General Court appears to follow a quasi-random case allocation mechanism, allowing for exceptions when cases are connected due to the parties or to the facts in which they originated, see Wijtvliet and Dyevre (Citation2021).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arthur Dyèvre (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: