Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The paper addresses the question of "kinetic"-like attributes observed on a choice of glyphs in rongorongo tablet "Mamari" (lines 9–10, side b, text C). This tablet, a medium-sized rongorongo text, as near as I can tell, has been aptly referred to by researchers and commentators as containing mixed genres. "Mamari" also has a unique place in the corpus of Easter Island inscriptions due to its "lunar calendar" fragment. The sequence in Cb9–10 elicits interest since it may shed light on the disputed nature of rongorongo script. A suggested textual parallel on side a of "Mamari" gives ground to cautious discussions on the degree of variation, paraphrasing and economy of expression, as well as to the plausible sound-mapping in the rongorongo orthography. Similarly, it is shown by comparison of earlier tracings of Thomas Barthel and Steven R. Fischer with the photographs of the actual artefact that the accuracy of the published drawn corpus still requires some amendments, and hence all further studies are supposed to pay more attention to the use of photographic material or investigation of the original. These issues are especially crucial for palaeographic and calligraphic research. Keywords: Easter IslandHapax legomena Kinetic-like Rongorongo Tablet "Mamari" Variation Acknowledgments The author wishes to thank the helpful critique of two anonymous reviewers of the manuscript. The paper has also benefited from great comments made by Paul Horley, Martyn Harris, Rafał M. Wieczorek and Richard W. Sproat. Similarly, the editorial assistance and the professional comments of Benedetta Bassetti are much worthy of mentioning and gratitude. Notes 1The technique of scriptura continua is documented in a much earlier context. J. Dahl (Citation2005, p. 3) states that proto-Elamite script uses no word-dividers, and the entries are not arranged in boxes. It should be remembered that proto-Elamite originated c.3000 BC (see Damerow, Citation2006/1999, p. 3, Figure 1). 2See also Orliac (Citation1990, p. 38) on the use and importance of Thespesia populnea in the ancient Polynesian culture. 3See e.g., Heyerdahl (Citation1965, p. 372) in regard to the artistic embellishment of the rongo-rongo characters; see also Horley (Citation2009); and Melka (Citation2009c). 4Personal communication, Paul Horley (Citation2009). 5 Hapax legomenon, or simply hapax (singleton) are types with the frequency of 1 (Baayen, Citation2001, p. 8). 6Personal communication, Rafał M. Wieczorek (2010). 7Notwithstanding, it is clear that Ca9-10 is characterised by severe syncope. 8As shown from the parallel fragments in lines Qv2 ("Small St. Petersburg" tablet) and Hr11 ("Large Santiago" tablet), sign /109t*/ results a curtailed variant of glyph /2/, contrary to the rounded glyph /109/ identified by T. Barthel. Indeed, /451.64x-2/ in Pr11 has a better chance to be a "modified glyphic statement" of /483-2/ in Cb10. The correct identification as sign /2/ is increased by the occurrence of the juxtaposition /730.6x-2/ in Br5, morphologically similar to /451.64x-2/ in Pr11. 9Such "renderings" are not be dismissed offhand, especially in view of the wild vagaries of the rongorongo scribe upon carving the tablets (Fischer, Citation1997, p. 613). 10Personal communication, Martyn Harris (2011). 11Data on additional "kinetic"-like sequences are available by contacting the author. 12Evidently, RR "writing" was done by hand, guided by the eye. Fine hand-eye co-ordination requires neither poor health, nor anxiety.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tomi S. Melka (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: