Key result
Cocoron single-lead transmitter measures heart rate with lower error than Apple Watch 7 across activities.
Why the study?
The study aimed to investigate the usefulness of a telemetric single-lead cardiac transmitter and the Apple Watch 7 for monitoring heart rate during activity.
Does the Cocoron telemetric single-lead electrocardiograph provide more accurate heart rate measurements than the Apple Watch 7 in healthy male adults?
Cross-Sectional (n=15)
No
Does the Cocoron telemetric single-lead electrocardiograph provide more accurate heart rate measurements than the Apple Watch 7 in healthy male adults?
The Cocoron telemetric single-lead ECG provides more accurate heart rate measurements than the Apple Watch 7 during movement, suggesting better suitability for continuous monitoring in dynamic settings.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support single-lead transmitters for heart rate accuracy during activity; leaves open validation in patients and outcome impact.
Objective The study aimed to investigate the usefulness of a telemetric single-lead cardiac transmitter and the Apple Watch 7 (2021 version; Apple Inc., Cupertino, CA, USA) for monitoring heart rate during activity. Methods A total of 15 healthy male adults aged 24-39 years were included in this study. A wireless radio frequency electrocardiogram (RF-ECG) was used as a reference, and heart rate was measured simultaneously with the Cocoron telemetric single-lead electrocardiograph (Nipro, Osaka, Japan, NC-1BLE) and Apple Watch 7. The mean absolute error (MAE), mean absolute percentage error (MAPE), and intraclass correlation coefficient were calculated from the difference in heart rate between the RF-ECG-based wearable, Cocoron, and Apple Watch 7 at each measurement time point. Bland-Altman plots were generated. Results A two-way analysis of variance for the MAPE of heart rate for the Cocoron and Apple Watch 7 based on RF-ECG showed that the MAPE of the Cocoron was significantly lower than that of the Apple Watch 7 (p=0.013). This result suggests that the Cocoron provides more accurate heart rate measurements compared to the Apple Watch 7. The Bland-Altman plot revealed that the MAPE was 2.39%, 3.30%, and 3.27% for the Cocoron during supine, seated, and walking positions, respectively, and 2.26%, 3.71%, and 5.82% for the Apple Watch 7, with significantly higher values for walking compared to supine and seated. A tendency to overestimate the limits of agreement (LOA) was observed for a wider range of LOA, with the Apple Watch 7 showing a particularly large LOA upper limit of 12.02 during ambulation. This visually indicates a tendency to overestimate the heart rate during movement. This larger error is likely due to motion artifacts inherent in the wrist-based photoplethysmography (PPG) method used by the Apple Watch, which could compromise its usability in dynamic settings. Conclusions The Cocoron telemetric single-lead electrocardiograph transmitter measured heart rate with less error than the Apple Watch 7. During ambulation, the Apple Watch 7 had a larger error than the supine and seated positions, whereas the Cocoron had a smaller error. Since accurate and continuous heart rate monitoring is critical for the effective management of heart failure, these findings imply that devices with superior measurement accuracy, like the Cocoron, could improve clinical decision-making and patient outcomes. However, it is important to note that further studies involving heart failure patients are needed to confirm these implications in a clinical setting.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Imai et al. (2025) conducted a cross-sectional in Healthy adults (n=15). Cocoron telemetric single-lead cardiac transmitter vs. Apple Watch 7 was evaluated on Mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of heart rate compared to RF-ECG (p=0.013). The Cocoron telemetric single-lead cardiac transmitter measured heart rate with a significantly lower mean absolute percentage error compared to the Apple Watch 7 across various activities.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: