Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
in world that is alive and open, and not boring. The core of that sensibility is doubt that any discourse has a privileged place, any method or theory a universal and general claim to authoritative knowledge. Wherever truth is claimed, so is power; claim to truth is a claim to power (Foucault 1978). So, micro or macro, positivist or naturalist, functionalist or conflict theorist, scientist and humanist-we all stand at last as distrusted co-equals in postmodernist universe, all of us suspected of lusting in our theorizing hearts to shape ongoing course of history. Once veil of privileged truth is lifted, feminism, Afro-American, gay, and other disparaged discourses rise to same epistemological status as dominant discourse. With monotone of power interests exposed, a multitude of voices speakssome with straightforward political and moral agendas, some still claiming innocence. The conversations at last are interesting, new, because conversants are equally legitimate before epistemological tribunal. With deconstruction of epistemic privilege comes possibility of alternative criteria for evaluating sociological production. Moral implications, practical applications, aesthetic pleasure, fun, performativity, credibility are other possible criteria for choosing one discourse rather than another. Sociology's Faustian bargain, in which humanities were granted domains of beauty and morality, domain of the truth, can now be contravened. With philosophical impunity sociologists can interrupt their own discursive spaces, reflect on their modes of production, their power interests, and explore writing/performing/teaching/sharing sociology both as a science and as a public or aesthetic or practical or morally charged discourse. It is entirely obvious that persons whose power positions have been concealed behind notions of general, universal, Archimedean truth would resist postmodernism. I even have some compassion for their plight. They have no power to gain through postmodernism-only position to lose. Why would they voluntarily give up their dominion? They might gain intellectual consistency-the application of sociological axiomatic, sociohistorical location of knowledge, to their own productionsbut consistency is easily sacrificed before altar of power. Postmodernism appeals to and benefits marginalized people who have been locally and historically denied
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laurel Richardson (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: