Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Have you ever tried to change the behavior of someone you care about? It was probably a very challenging process because behavior change is not easy and often does not happen as a result of educating people with hard facts (e.g., smoking is the leading cause of preventable death). People usually do not change their behavior unless a crisis occurs (e.g., death of a sibling at a young age) or their emotions raise, which then stimulates them to make a change. In academic programs, students are often taught how to promote the highest levels of health in people through behavior change strategies based on the transtheoretical model, which include assessing readiness for change and matching appropriate interventions to their patient's stage of change (e.g., precontemplation, contemplation; Prochaska, Prochaska, & Levesque, 2001). However, we often do not implement these same assessments and strategies when working with clinicians on changing their behaviors from practices that are steeped in tradition to those based on the best evidence. Too often, leaders will mandate a change to evidence-based practice (EBP) to clinicians who are not ready to change and in an environment and culture that does not fully support evidence-based care. As a result, both leaders and clinicians become frustrated. In order to accelerate a change to EBP, clinicians must not only have the educational and mentorship support to learn and implement the seven-step EBP process (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2011), but they must work in cultures and environments that make it easy for them to consistently deliver evidence-based care. A culture and environment (also often referred to as context; Rycroft-Malone et al., 2013) that support EBP must integrate evidence-based care into its vision, philosophy, mission, and strategic plan, which must then be visible and clearly communicated throughout the organization. Orientations for new clinicians should place an emphasis on EBP as not all clinicians who enter a healthcare system will have the same knowledge and skills in EBP due to the variation in course work and how EBP and research are taught in academic programs. Therefore, educational and skills building sessions must be provided, especially for those clinicians who do not have a strong background in evidence-based care. An expectation also should be set and communicated that all clinicians will be competent in EBP. The recently published EBP competencies for practicing registered nurses and advanced practice nurses in real-world clinical settings (Melnyk, Gallagher-Ford, & Fineout-Overholt, 2014) can assist organizations in establishing a gold standard for evidence-based care on which clinicians can be evaluated. Further, integration of these competencies into clinical ladder promotion systems can establish clarity of performance expectations and also serve as an incentive for clinicians to attain them. Another key to establishing and sustaining cultures and environments of best practice is the development of a critical mass of EBP mentors throughout a healthcare system who can work closely with direct care staff in the ongoing implementation of best practices (Melnyk, 2007). Mentors must assess clinicians’ knowledge and skills and help them to overcome barriers within the system so that EBP can be consistently delivered across the care continuum. Findings from research have supported that when EBP mentors are available to assist clinicians with evidence-based care, clinicians’ beliefs about the value of EBP and their ability to implement it rise, which results in increased implementation of evidence-based care (Levin, Fineout-Overholt, Melnyk, Barnes, & Vetter, 2011; Wallen et al., 2010). EBP mentors are typically advanced practice nurses with in-depth knowledge and skills in EBP along with expertise in individual behavior and organizational change strategies (Melnyk, 2007). These mentors must show enthusiasm for EBP, as just like stress is contagious, so is enthusiasm. They also must document the “so what” outcomes (i.e., outcomes that the current healthcare system is most focused on, including cost, complications, length of stay, and rehospitalizations; Melnyk, 2014) to document the benefits of their work. Evidence-based care flourishes in organizations that foster a spirit of inquiry in their cultures and environments where clinicians are constantly encouraged to ask questions about their practices. A solid infrastructure and resources must be provided in the organization to assist clinicians in findings answers to their questions, including access to library resources (e.g., databases for searching, full-text articles, librarians who can assist with searches). Further, organizations should provide evidence that their policies and procedures are based on the best evidence and provide clinicians with evidence-based guidelines. In addition, evidence-based councils comprised of nursing and transdisciplinary clinicians can be instrumental for enhancing EBP throughout the organization through a team-based approach. Time also must be allotted for clinicians to engage in the EBP process and this time should not be called “nonproductive” time as labeled in many hospitals across the United States. Leaders and managers have a key role in EBP in not only supporting evidence-based care and providing the infrastructure for it, but also role modeling evidence-based decisions. This is especially important given the most recent findings from a national survey conducted in the United States, which revealed that many nurses identified leaders and managers as a major barrier to implementing EBP (Melnyk, Fineout-Overholt, Gallagher-Ford, & Kaplan, 2012). Recognizing and celebrating EBP accomplishments for clinicians is another key to changing culture to one that is supportive of EBP. Recognition is especially important when clinicians are fatigued. In an era where findings from research are supporting that transdisciplinary teamwork leads to a higher quality of care and better patient outcomes (Raab, Will, Richards, & O'Mara, 2013), it is essential to foster and reward cross disciplinary evidence-based initiatives to improve care. Lastly, it must be remembered that changing culture and environment in an organization is a lengthy, often “character-building,” process that takes years as there will always be people who resist change in an organization. Those “resisters,” who are often referred to as laggards in Rogers’ Diffusions of Innovation Theory (Rogers, 2003), are usually afraid of change. Open transparent discussions with clinicians who fear change can sometimes gain their support, but intense time should not be spent trying to convince resisters to join the culture change effort. A change to an EBP culture and environment can happen more quickly in an organization by getting those clinicians who are innovators and early adopters on board with the change effort first and showing some fast successes by starting small and working on initiatives that can be more easily accomplished to demonstrate positive outcomes. I often ask clinicians the following question, “What is the smallest EBP change that you can make that will result in the largest positive improvement in our patients’ outcomes,?” because it is critical to rapidly apply the knowledge that is generated through research. Although the building of an EBP culture and environment is instrumental to stimulate and support behavior change in clinicians, persistent and consistent efforts throughout the journey will be worth it as evidenced by reductions in the lengthy research-practice time gap and ultimate improvements in healthcare quality, patient outcomes, and costs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bernadette Mazurek Melnyk (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: