Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Two well-known scholars have collaborated once again to provide us with a brilliant multidisciplinary analysis of gender and property in Latin America, and the ways in which rural women are actively engaged in the contests over land rights. It documents the disjuncture between men’s and women’s formal equality before the law and the achievement of real gender equality in terms of their ownership and control over land and other agricultural resources. The book’s central purpose is to examine why gender inequality exists in land ownership in 12 countries. Focusing on the nature of the Latin American family, community, state, and market, it attributes this disjuncture to “male preference in inheritance, male privilege in marriage, male bias in state programs of land distribution, and gender inequality in the land market” (p. 2). Deere and León break women’s legal, political, and economic struggle to gain ownership over rural property into three historical periods. A comparative analysis of civil code reforms during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries reveals that married women’s control over property rights failed to improve significantly. Despite the parallel development of the first wave of the women’s movement, legal equality for unmarried nonwhite women did not advance very far. Policymakers during the second period, which encompassed the agrarian reforms from the 1960s through the 1980s, assumed that giving land to families would make agrarian reform programs gender neutral. In reality these programs largely excluded peasant women as direct beneficiaries because the land was assigned to the male heads of households. They attribute this gender bias to the persistence of patriarchal ideologies, which linked definitions of “agriculturalist” and “household head” to masculinity. For example, women made up a very low proportion of the beneficiaries until quite recently in the pioneering agrarian reform programs of Mexico, Bolivia, and Cuba.Over the course of the last two decades, rural women have gained greater access to land rights and ownership of land under the neoliberal agrarian reforms, aided by a loose coalition of local, national, and international women’s organizations. This “triangle of empowerment,” a concept developed by Virginia Vargas et al., is a three-pronged coordinated action by urban and rural movements, women in government, and women in formal politics, assisted by international organizations. One of the main contributions of feminist analysis, the authors contend, was to challenge the assumption that favoring the male household head benefited all members of the family as well. Their provocative argument, which asserts that women’s advocacy groups played a critical role in pressuring the state to incorporate gender-progressive measures into “counter-reforms,” merits serious consideration. In 7 of the 12 countries under investigation—Chile, Ecuador, El Salvador, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, and Peru—agrarian reform was brought to a close. These countries embraced the neoliberal model, where individual rights took precedence over collective land rights. Counter-reforms took the form of privatization, individualization of land rights, and land titling programs, designed to enhance security of land tenure and of the farmers’ welfare. In most cases, these reform efforts continued the practice built into earlier agrarian reform programs, which gave preference to male heads of household as the primary breadwinner. Chile’s pioneering neoliberal counter-reform became the model for such male-biased programs, but the Mexican case is even more egregious. The major decisions regarding the privatization of the ejido are to be made by ejido members, of which women make up only 17.5 percent. Moreover, ejido members can, by majority vote, transform family patrimony into individual male property, excluding wives from the decision-making process in the disposition of this property. Nicaragua and El Salvador are special cases as a result of the peace accords, which did address the agrarian question as well as gender issues. In Colombia, Bolivia, Brazil, and Guatemala, agrarian reform was still on the table in the 1990s, but it is largely due to the pressure of grassroots movements.A key chapter addresses the question of how gender-progressive changes actually occur within a neoliberal framework. One of the main accomplishments of the most recent legislation has been the “burial” of the concept of the male head of household as the focus of state agrarian policies. Six countries (Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Honduras, Nicaragua, and Guatemala) have revised their agrarian codes to provide for joint allocation and titling of land to couples. Three countries (Colombia, Nicaragua, and Guatemala) have given priority to female household heads in the distribution and titling of land. These steps only transpired, the authors contend, when the triangle of empowerment really functioned.The last three chapters address the threat of neoliberalism to women’s individual and collective land rights, inheritance, and land titling. It advocates the end of expropriation of land and the promotion of land titling to stimulate investment in agriculture, creation of a more efficient land market, and effective land taxation. This threat is further complicated by the tension between the demand for recognition of collective land rights of indigenous peoples and the demand for gender equity. National-level data by sex on land acquisition in four countries show that the preponderance of women in the 1990s acquired land through inheritance rather than through purchase or agrarian reform allocation. Moreover, women own smaller properties in all of the countries where data is available and are more likely than men to sell their holdings rather than to farm them.This study, which engenders land tenure and agrarian reform initiatives in Latin America better than any other work, is based upon the compilation of copious data drawn from agricultural censuses, agrarian, civil, and constitutional law, and surveys, interviews, and multiple workshops in 12 Latin America countries. No other work is so rich in documentation, which makes this study a classic on the question of gender and property. The authors do reiterate time and time again, however, that agricultural data on gender and land ownership is still singularly lacking. Only Peru and Guatemala have agricultural censuses that report the sex of the principal farmer.This clearly written, comprehensive monograph belongs in every university library. Its far-reaching analysis of gender inequality in the countryside is unsurpassed in its theoretical sophistication, as well as in its comprehensiveness. It contains a wealth of material never before assembled on gender and property in Latin America. As an activist’s manual for working towards real gender equality, it calls for joint titling, affirmative action, strengthening the inheritance rights of wives, and recognizing women’s land rights within peasant and indigenous communities.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Heather Fowler-Salamini (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: