Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
BackgroundLung cancer screening (LCS) with low-dose CT (LDCT) scan has been shown to reduce mortality from lung cancer, the deadliest cancer killer. More than one-half of incident lung cancers detected in the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) were identified after the first year of screening, which highlights the importance of annual adherence to achieve mortality benefit from LCS. Although NLST adherence across three rounds of screening was 95%, adherence in the community is lower and highly variable even within the same health system.Research QuestionWhat are patient and LCS coordinator perspectives on barriers and potential solutions to ensuring adherence to annual LCS?Study Design and MethodsIn this qualitative study, we conducted six veteran focus groups of 21 veterans who had undergone at least one LCS examination and individual interviews of eight LCS coordinators. Interviews and focus groups were transcribed and coded using qualitative content analysis. Codes were sorted into categories reflecting veteran perceptions, LCS ideas, observations, barriers, facilitators, preferences, recommendations, and LCS program issues. These codes were then analyzed and used to identify themes influencing adherence.ResultsThe following four themes were identified from qualitative analysis: (1) direct communication about the repeat annual nature of screening was a driver for patient adherence, (2) patients recommended using other modalities including text messaging and mobile applications to improve adherence, (3) LCS coordinators reported a lack of emphasis and focus on adherence because of a lack of resources, and (4) the variability in program practices for bringing patients back every year and inability to measure adherence are barriers that need to be addressed.InterpretationDirect and multimodal communication may improve patient adherence to annual LCS, and system-level changes (eg, tracking dashboard and metrics) could assist LCS coordinators in addressing and focusing on LCS program adherence. Lung cancer screening (LCS) with low-dose CT (LDCT) scan has been shown to reduce mortality from lung cancer, the deadliest cancer killer. More than one-half of incident lung cancers detected in the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) were identified after the first year of screening, which highlights the importance of annual adherence to achieve mortality benefit from LCS. Although NLST adherence across three rounds of screening was 95%, adherence in the community is lower and highly variable even within the same health system. What are patient and LCS coordinator perspectives on barriers and potential solutions to ensuring adherence to annual LCS? In this qualitative study, we conducted six veteran focus groups of 21 veterans who had undergone at least one LCS examination and individual interviews of eight LCS coordinators. Interviews and focus groups were transcribed and coded using qualitative content analysis. Codes were sorted into categories reflecting veteran perceptions, LCS ideas, observations, barriers, facilitators, preferences, recommendations, and LCS program issues. These codes were then analyzed and used to identify themes influencing adherence. The following four themes were identified from qualitative analysis: (1) direct communication about the repeat annual nature of screening was a driver for patient adherence, (2) patients recommended using other modalities including text messaging and mobile applications to improve adherence, (3) LCS coordinators reported a lack of emphasis and focus on adherence because of a lack of resources, and (4) the variability in program practices for bringing patients back every year and inability to measure adherence are barriers that need to be addressed. Direct and multimodal communication may improve patient adherence to annual LCS, and system-level changes (eg, tracking dashboard and metrics) could assist LCS coordinators in addressing and focusing on LCS program adherence. Take-home PointStudy Question: What are patient and lung cancer screening (LCS) coordinator perspectives on barriers and potential solutions to ensuring adherence to annual LCS?Results: The following four themes were identified: (1) direct communication about the repeat annual nature of screening was a driver for patient adherence, (2) patients recommended using other modalities including text messaging and mobile applications to improve adherence, (3) LCS coordinators reported a lack of emphasis and focus on adherence because of a lack of resources, and (4) the variability in program practices for bringing patients back every year and inability to measure adherence are barriers that need to be addressedInterpretation: Direct and multimodal communication may improve patient adherence to annual lung cancer screening, and system-level changes (eg, tracking dashboard and metrics) could assist LCS coordinators in addressing and focusing on LCS program adherence. Study Question: What are patient and lung cancer screening (LCS) coordinator perspectives on barriers and potential solutions to ensuring adherence to annual LCS? Results: The following four themes were identified: (1) direct communication about the repeat annual nature of screening was a driver for patient adherence, (2) patients recommended using other modalities including text messaging and mobile applications to improve adherence, (3) LCS coordinators reported a lack of emphasis and focus on adherence because of a lack of resources, and (4) the variability in program practices for bringing patients back every year and inability to measure adherence are barriers that need to be addressed Interpretation: Direct and multimodal communication may improve patient adherence to annual lung cancer screening, and system-level changes (eg, tracking dashboard and metrics) could assist LCS coordinators in addressing and focusing on LCS program adherence. Although the rate of lung cancer mortality continues to decline, it remains the leading cause of all cancer-related deaths in the United States, surpassing breast, prostate, and colorectal deaths combined.1Siegel R.L. Miller K.D. Fuchs H.E. Jemal A. Cancer statistics, 2022.CA Cancer J Clin. 2022; 72: 7-33Crossref PubMed Scopus (5247) Google Scholar Lung cancer screening (LCS) with low-dose CT (LDCT) scan detects earlier stage cancers leading to a reduction in lung cancer-related mortality based on the results of the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) and Dutch Belgium Screening Trial (NELSON).2Aberle D.R. Adams A.M. Berg C.D. et al.Reduced lung-cancer mortality with low-dose computed tomographic screening.N Engl J Med. 2011; 365: 395-409Crossref PubMed Scopus (7464) Google Scholar,3de Koning H.J. van der Aalst C.M. de Jong P.A. et al.Reduced lung-cancer mortality with volume CT screening in a randomized trial.N Engl J Med. 2020; 382: 503-513Crossref PubMed Scopus (1458) Google Scholar There was 95% patient adherence to annual follow up in the NLST over a 3-year period, which is common in randomized trials with volunteers; however, this high level of patient adherence to follow up is not often achieved in community-based screening programs and was a mere 22.3% in the first million individuals screened in the United States.4Silvestri G.A. Goldman L. Burleson J. et al.Characteristics of persons screened for lung cancer in the United States: a cohort study.Ann Intern Med. 2022; 175: 1501-1505Crossref PubMed Scopus (9) Google Scholar Notably, more than one-half of incident lung cancers detected in the NLST were identified after the first year of screening.2Aberle D.R. Adams A.M. Berg C.D. et al.Reduced lung-cancer mortality with low-dose computed tomographic screening.N Engl J Med. 2011; 365: 395-409Crossref PubMed Scopus (7464) Google Scholar Support for annual adherence is further provided from the Dutch Belgium Screening Trial (NELSON) in which screening was conducted at increasing time intervals after baseline examination. Compared with the 1-year interval, the 2.5-year interval had a higher proportion of late-stage lung cancers (17.3% vs 6.8%, P = .02), and the number of lung cancers detected between screening examinations was higher.5Yousaf-Khan U. van der Aalst C. de Jong P.A. et al.Final screening round of the NELSON lung cancer screening trial: the effect of a 2.5-year screening interval.Thorax. 2017; 72: 48-56Crossref PubMed Scopus (197) Google Scholar Therefore, annual adherence to screening is a crucial aspect that should not be overlooked because both efficacy (ie, cancer detection rate, stage, mortality reduction) and cost-efficacy of screening are negatively impacted by patient nonadherence to follow up.6Han S.S. Erdogan S.A. Toumazis I. Leung A. Plevritis S.K. Evaluating the impact of varied compliance to lung cancer screening recommendations using a microsimulation model.Cancer Causes Control. 2017; 28: 947-958Crossref PubMed Scopus (34) Google Scholar, 7Mahadevia P.J. Fleisher L.A. Frick K.D. Eng J. Goodman S.N. Powe N.R. Lung cancer screening with helical computed tomography in older adult smokers: a decision and cost-effectiveness analysis.JAMA. 2003; 289: 313-322Crossref PubMed Scopus (294) Google Scholar, 8Black W.C. Gareen I.F. Soneji S.S. et al.Cost-effectiveness of CT screening in the National Lung Screening Trial.N Engl J Med. 2014; 371: 1793-1802Crossref PubMed Scopus (397) Google Scholar To assess feasibility of implementing LCS, the Veterans Health Administration conducted a demonstration project at eight sites across the United States.9Kinsinger L.S. Anderson C. Kim J. et al.Implementation of lung cancer screening in the Veterans Health Administration.JAMA Intern Med. 2017; 177: 399-406Crossref PubMed Scopus (251) Google Scholar Although the cancer detection rate after one round of screening across the eight centers was higher than the NLST, adherence was lower at 82% at year one and 65% at year two and varied greatly (51%-93%) among sites despite the same resources.10Tanner N.T. Brasher P.B. Wojciechowski B. et al.Screening adherence in the Veterans Administration lung cancer screening demonstration project.Chest. 2020; 158: 1742-1752Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (29) Google Scholar Further analysis of individuals screened at the Veterans Health Administration found an overall adherence of 50%.11Nunez E.R. Caverly T.J. Zhang S. et al.Adherence to follow-up testing recommendations in US veterans screened for lung cancer, 2015-2019.JAMA Netw Open. 2021; 4e2116233Crossref PubMed Scopus (33) Google Scholar Given the necessity of high levels of LCS adherence to optimize screening quality, we sought to better understand barriers and facilitators of adherence in those receiving and delivering care at the Veterans Health Administration. To characterize the primary factors influencing veteran adherence to annual LCS, we drew on conventional qualitative content analysis. This qualitative research methodology uses the concept of describing a particular phenomenon when existing theory or literature is limited.12Hsieh H.F. Shannon S.E. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis.Qual Health Res. 2005; 15: 1277-1288Crossref PubMed Scopus (24084) Google Scholar Content analysis was chosen because this approach allows categories and themes to develop from data as opposed to using preconceived groupings, which permits direct evaluation of information from study participants. This qualitative study focused on both veteran and LCS coordinator perceptions of LCS adherence at various screening sites. We used a structured questionnaire to explore veteran experiences with LCS (e-Appendix 1) and encouraged moderated focus group discussion to explore facilitators and barriers to LCS adherence. Focus groups and telephone interviews were conducted between August 2019 and January 2020. A total of six focus group discussions were led by experienced personnel using open-ended questions based on standard principles of qualitative interviewing.13Seidman I. Interviewing as Qualitative Research: A Guide for Researchers in Education and the Social Sciences.5th ed. Teacher’s College Press, 2019Google Scholar Interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim removing any identifiers, and analyzed using conventional qualitative content analysis. When approaching LCS coordinator perceptions, we conducted eight telephone interviews using a structured questionnaire (e-Appendix 1). Medical University of South Carolina Office of Research Integrity Institutional Review Board approval was obtained from the Medical University of South Carolina (Pro No. 91456). A convenience sample of patients meeting US Preventive Services Task Force eligibility criteria for LCS who had undergone at least one LCS examination in the past at the Ralph H. Johnson Veterans Affairs (VA) Healthcare System (Charleston, SC) were invited to participate in the study by letter and telephone and were offered $100 compensation for participation. Twenty-one veterans agreed to participate across six focus groups, meeting the number of participants considered to achieve qualitative study thematic saturation based on previous experience.14Saunders B. Sim J. Kingstone T. et al.Saturation in qualitative research: exploring its conceptualization and operationalization.Qual Quant. 2018; 52: 1893-1907Crossref PubMed Scopus (4325) Google Scholar Additionally, saturation at this sample size conforms to recommendations for a focused objective (veteran perceptions of LCS), a relatively homogenous population (veterans who had LCS), and data adequacy (ability to provide an account that represents their experience)15Hennink M. Kaiser B.N. Sample sizes for saturation in qualitative research: a systematic review of empirical tests.Soc Sci Med. 2022; 292114523Crossref PubMed Scopus (523) Google Scholar that justifies such a sample size. VA sites conducting LCS with the use of dedicated coordinators were contacted by email and eight LCS coordinators from different facilities agreed to participate in telephone interviews. LCS coordinator roles in the screening process include verifying patient eligibility for screening, conducting personalized shared decision-making visits regarding LCS, relaying results to patients and primary care providers, initiating workup for screen-detected findings, and contacting/scheduling return imaging examinations. LCS coordinators included those who had participated in the LCSDP and others who started screening after the demonstration project, to obtain feedback regarding implementation of screening and adherence. Members of the research team reviewed both focus group and telephone interview transcripts. Subsequently, two members (J. A. and C. P.) jointly coded the transcripts for qualitative content analysis. After immersion in the transcriptions, codes were assigned to portions of the text and compared between coders for consensus, consistent with data-driven coding.16Schreier M. Qualitative Content Analysis in Practice. Sage Publications, 2012Google Scholar Codes were then grouped into categories and examined for relationships and themes related to the original question of facilitators and barriers to adherence for summary conclusions. Veteran FG and LCS coordinator interviews revealed a broad range of responses; however, several clear themes emerged after qualitative content analysis from both veteran and coordinator perspectives. Table 1 presents a sampling of representative quotes.Table 1Emerging Themes and Representative Quotes From Veterans and LCS CoordinatorsThemesRepresentative QuotesVeterans Direct communication importance of annual scan“The [veterans] need to know it is a recurring thing.” Personalized messaging“We get text messages for our appointments and if not those we get emails, why not use MyHealtheVet?” Facilitator: ease of testing“Even if I have no change on the second one, I will still come back the following year because it is painless, fast, and easy.” Barrier: fear of test results“It is not a fear of the scans, it is a fear of the results…I think it is probably a major barrier.”LCS coordinators Lack of resources to ensure adherence•“I would like to be able to send some sort of reminder out to people and say, hey, you are due for your annual scan…I would need people for that kind of thing. I need a lot of help.”•“That constant reinforcement is what promotes compliance…The issue comes to is as it grows, do we have the proper support for it.”•“I am about 6 weeks behind in initial consults just from the sheer amount of work that I have right now. You know, one person trying to do all of this. It just compounds because the more people you enroll, the more scans.” Need for uniform tracking system•“…One of the key things to adherence is one of the things I found when I started this have to have a all to use different tracking and it just it and more think it is it is to I think the why people know it is because a to It like it should be = lung cancer in a LCS = lung cancer The and from veteran discussion was clear communication is to the process of adherence. A within the of communication that emerged was the importance of emphasis on LCS as a There was in what veterans regarding the follow-up despite of the screening process at the that had been that screening was a test and that it was to for others the process was patients were about the time of screening, with some of the (eg, was to come back every and this is what I have and others who this was a time (eg, was the to come Veterans agreed that more emphasis should be on this as a recurring process (eg, need to know it is a recurring The second that emerged from the patient was the need to use other modalities to patients more the screening agreed that the use of other including text that allows veterans to appointments health and send messages to and personalized to patients as the time for annual screening could improve return patient the get text messages for our appointments and if not those we get emails, why not use Personalized could veterans an from from the Veterans Health Administration. to on the of know is a lot of literature out I get from the VA all the of it in the factors from to of the screening process that were to to however, a that fear was on the screening is not a fear of the scans, it is a fear of the This in adherence into the first that better communication regarding the of could this to follow that stage lung cancer is to for return for annual addressed the facilitators that veterans that their LCS of their was by veterans (eg, I was screened I it is a because I am a a of a previous or of cancer as The and ease of the was as a is to It was over I used to in It was Veterans to the as a to in for LCS and that for the were compared with time for primary care Veterans barriers to LCS. a had a time year because was in and out of the The of the screening a more as a potential (eg, is not a fear of the scans, it is a fear of the results…I think it is probably a major The focused key interviews with LCS coordinators revealed barriers to adherence at the level was the sites. The first identified from coordinator discussion was adherence coordinator have no what our adherence I that would be to coordinator lack of a of regarding their I know our adherence I are I have to back that When further on the question of adherence, some coordinators the importance of is when you about your adherence rate and I I have a program if I know people are What if I am just screening is I know that is coordinators were with adherence have no for tracking adherence focused on veterans who had higher at baseline coordinators that if had the resources to focus on annual would focus more in this The second identified from the coordinators was lack of in patients are back for annual sites send others and still others on primary care to identify who is due for annual coordinator have to on care to know when is due for an annual This on primary care within the screening process from a lack of am about six weeks behind in initial consults just from the sheer amount of work that I have the resources to coordinators that primary care has in the about the to just lack of resources their to improve the for I have no I have the resources at to and patient follow-up is to achieve the mortality reduction from however, are lower than that in This study, which is the first to explore both patient and LCS coordinator to a of literature on and potential solutions to adherence and has several clear and personalized communication with those LCS using various for communication may be the to ensure adherence. in health implementing LCS in a or of the importance of adherence at the and coordinator level is system-level are that programs to adherence and provide for and The from analysis of veteran discussion is clear communication could to higher of adherence. was reported on the time of the screening including when to return and These themes are in with a study that found of identified their LCS follow-up M. S. et of lung cancer screening follow-up recommendations and the with 2022; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar The focus group the importance of increasing and of of communication (eg, text personalized as a of this This that of a study conducted in screening in which participants that are an of annual A. A. M. perspectives on adherence to lung cancer 2022; Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (3) Google Scholar Personalized communication an telephone reminder is an of that have shown to be in increasing repeat adherence by of and telephone on of repeat a randomized J Med. Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus Google Scholar A study of a to improve adherence to colorectal cancer screening in community health centers that reminder text and personalized adherence by T. D.R. et of a to improve adherence to annual colorectal cancer screening in community health a randomized Intern Med. 2014; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar communication the LCS process would the of fear the LCS process by veterans better understand the of lung cancer Notably, this cohort of patients had undergone at least one baseline LCS and this study could not for lack of in those not from LCS coordinator interviews revealed in of adherence adherence and in some a lack of regarding the importance of this The to and have data on LCS adherence is to the screening process because this what changes are to improve adherence the of the data by and results of screening should be and on in a The second identified from coordinator discussions was the of screening This lack of was by primary care into VA screening at despite that primary care lung screening results in lower C. J. N.T. lung cancer screening adherence is with a 2022; Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus Google Scholar The size of patient within screening programs and was as for the LCS and that primary care was not a to ensure adherence, were to all the to screening on their to annual screening is to achieve a mortality reduction from lung cancer and should be considered a for lung screening however, the has patients and LCS coordinators have identified barriers and for change at the and patient level to improve adherence. to are to adherence, ensure screening, and improve lung cancer The have reported to that no was for this
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Angotti et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: