Key result
A novel deep neural network using PPG and acceleration power spectra estimated heart rate during intensive exercise with an average absolute error of 1.46 bpm on the test dataset.
Why the study?
Wearable reflectance-type photoplethysmography sensors are sensitive to motion artifacts, leading to inaccurate heart rate estimation during intensive exercise.
Does the proposed deep learning model improve the accuracy of heart rate estimation from PPG signals during intensive exercise compared to existing methods?
Does the proposed deep learning model improve the accuracy of heart rate estimation from PPG signals during intensive exercise compared to existing methods?
The proposed deep learning model accurately estimates heart rate from wearable PPG sensors even during intensive physical exercise with severe motion artifacts.
Supports PPG-based HR monitoring during exercise; hypothesis-generating pending prospective clinical validation.
Objective: A wearable reflectance-type photoplethysmography (PPG) sensor can be incorporated in a watch or band to provide instantaneous heart rates (HRs) with minimum inconvenience to users. However, the sensor is sensitive to motion artifacts (MAs), which results in inaccurate HR estimation. To address this problem, we propose a new neural network for deep learning to ensure accurate HR estimation even during intensive exercise. Methods: We propose a new deep neural network based on multiclass and non-uniform multilabel classification for HR estimation. It comprises of two convolutional layers, two long short-term memory (LSTM) layers, one concatenation layer, and three fully connected layers including a softmax. The proposed model feeds the power spectra from the PPG and acceleration signals along with the acceleration intensity to the input layer. We also present a new scheme to evaluate the loss value by modifying the true HR value into a Gaussian distribution. Results: We used 48 training datasets and evaluated 23 isolated testing datasets. The proposed model exhibited average absolute error of less than 1.5 bpm for all the training and test datasets - 1.09 bpm for the training dataset and 1.46 bpm for the test dataset. Conclusion: The proposed model outperforms the state-of-the-art methods for accurate estimation of HR. Significance: It precisely estimates the HRs with robustness even during intensive physical exercise, as evidenced by the accuracy when PPG signals are severely corrupted by MAs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chung et al. (2020) studied Heart rate estimation during intensive physical exercise (n=71). Deep neural network (CNN + LSTM) using PPG and acceleration power spectra and acceleration intensity vs. State-of-the-art signal processing and deep learning methods was evaluated on Average absolute error (AAE) in heart rate estimation on the test dataset. A novel deep neural network using PPG and acceleration power spectra estimated heart rate during intensive exercise with an average absolute error of 1.46 bpm on the test dataset.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: