Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Raising America: Experts, Parents, and a Century of Advice About Children by Ann Hulbert New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2003, 450 pp, $27.50. Advice for parenting has never been a static process. Expansive shifts in cultural values, economic needs of families, and historical events change the way we raise children. The story behind expert advice about child rearing in the twentieth century is fascinating and revealing of the interactions among science, religion, cultural shifts, and the individual biographies of the men (mostly) who guided parenting in America. Ann Hulbert, an accomplished journalist and editor, has written an illuminating history about advice to parents in the past 100 years. Raising America: Experts, Parents, and a Century of Advice About Children is an in-depth study about child-advice experts. From the beginning of the Progressive Era to current times, we learn about the professionals who had the most influence on new parents. Biographical sketches about the childhood and professional development of those who affected parenting are set against the background of the intellectual and cultural movements of their times. The writing is superb, scholarly (with references stored in the back of the book), and witty. It should be a requirement for pediatricians in training and in practice. The story begins at the opening of the twentieth century when a Swedish reformer, Ellen Key, observed “at present a lax situation between all kinds of pedagogical methods and psychological opinions, in which the child is thrown about here and there like a ball, in the hands of grown people.” In fact, most of the “methods and opinions” about child rearing up to this time came from religious leaders with Victorian cultural influences. The optimism of the Progressive Era and the evolutionary science of Charles Darwin opened the way for G. Stanley Hall and L. Emmett Holt (America’s most prominent psychologist and pediatrician, respectively) to bring a scientific perspective to raising children. Hall, influenced by Darwin and Freud, explored the psychological aspects of puberty and tumultuous adolescence with explicit suggestions for worried parents. Holt, in Care and Feeding of Children, directed mothers in precise dietary prescriptions for milk formula and other foods while insisting on scheduling all activities and limiting play with babies. They were followed by John Watson who taught parents in his popular book, Psychological Care of Infant and Child, about the importance of environmental conditioning in shaping a child’s personality and warned against “kissing and cuddling children, scolding that mothers were rearing soft citizens ill suited to an impersonal, organized world.” In contrast with Watson’s behavioral emphasis, Arnold Gesell focused on maturational stages of development that were biologically based and, in Gesell’s opinion, not significantly influenced by the environment. Gesell encouraged more flexibility in handling children. The nature–nurture debate was warming up. Benjamin Spock, a pediatrician who graduated from Columbia Medical School and was influenced by the psychoanalytic community in New York City (and, in his own words, by his mother), combined Gesell’s developmental stages and Freudian psychology by writing the Common Sense Book of Baby and Child Care in 1946. For 25 cents, three quarters of a million copies were sold in the first year to mothers (mostly middle class to be sure, and later to fathers) who found relief and reassurance in the first sentence of the book, “You know more than you think you do.” Hulbert points to Dr. Spock’s less-rigid approach to child rearing as attractive to a generation living with the anxieties of affluence and possible nuclear apocalypse after World War II. The last section of the book is consumed with many writers who reflect emerging scientific discoveries about attachment theory, temperament, early brain development, multiple intelligence, and cognitive psychology. The most popular writers discussed are the pediatrician T. Berry Brazelton and the British child psychologist Penelope Leach. Although their books sold millions, other purveyors of advice to parents brought stiff competition. Stanley Greenspan found allies in Brazelton and Leach to talk about a “child-centered” program that required institutional change to fine-tune developing brains, to nurture empathy, and “to give the nation’s overstressed families more time for studiously attentive (not just intuitive) bonding with babies and children.” In contrast, a “parent-centered” movement with a Judeo-Christian religious foundation countered with a belief that parental authority and morality had been undermined by society and the popular purveyors of parent advice. The psychologist James Dodson led this movement through books and a “radio ministry.” From my perspective, Hulbert makes the discussion about child-rearing experts interesting because she is careful to place each participant in their historical context. Just as history is rewritten by new generations of historians looking back at the same facts and events, advice to parents, as seen in this journey of 100 years, is a product of changing cultural values, assumptions, and historical events, as well as new scientific discoveries. Finally, readers will enjoy the personal biographies of many of the participants—especially Hall, Holt, Gesell, and Spock—as they discover how the experts’ personal childhood experiences influenced their perspectives on children and families.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Martin T. Stein (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: