This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Improving cycling infrastructure for safety, comfort, and experience enables cycling as a sustainable alternative to short car trips and last-mile public transport. However, policy interventions in spatially constrained areas face active and passive resistance to reprioritising active mobility. This study examines barriers to improving The Plain Roundabout in Oxford, UK, a ‘safety hot spot’ and cyclist deterrent, highlighting how material, institutional, political, and discursive resistance prevent substantial change towards a cycling-friendly redesign. Based on thematic and discourse analysis of stakeholder interviews, cyclist testimonials, and planning and policy materials, this study reveals that infrastructural resistance is embedded in existing governance practices. Four main themes with 11 sub-themes of resistance to experimentation were identified. Materiality concerns included physical layout, vehicle sizes, design details, and geographical constraints. Institutionalisation reflected on tools and data availability, built-in skillsets, and experimentation culture. Agency and interests shaped stakeholder involvement, resources and impact. Discourses reinforced norms of unfettered motorised movement, freedom of choice, and the perceived need for a compromise. Findings indicate that while experimentation is seen as a catalyst for sustainable mobility transitions, institutional inertia, a legacy of motorised transport planning, and the uneven agency of stakeholders limit transformation. Overall, safety, though touted as important, is insufficient to justify radical change without challenging modernist values of speed and motorised transport flows. While The Plain Roundabout remains controversial to this day, the proposed framework provides insights into how barriers to cycling infrastructure can be systematically identified and addressed, offering an analytical tool for policymakers and practitioners.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cornet et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: