Key result
Isometric and dynamic resistance exercise produce similar prefrontal oxygenation and blood volume changes.
Why the study?
It was unknown whether cerebral oxygenation differs between isometric and dynamic resistance exercise of similar characteristics, and whether cerebral oxygenation changes relate to cardiovascular adjustments during resistance exercise.
Does isometric resistance exercise compared to dynamic resistance exercise of equivalent workloads elicit different cerebral oxygenation responses in men?
RCT (n=14)
Randomized
Does isometric resistance exercise compared to dynamic resistance exercise of equivalent workloads elicit different cerebral oxygenation responses in men?
Isometric and dynamic resistance exercise of matched workloads elicit similar increases in prefrontal cerebral oxygenation and blood volume.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports equivalent cerebral oxygenation with matched isometric or dynamic resistance exercise; hypothesis-generating for clinical translation.
Brain function relies on sufficient blood flow and oxygen supply. Changes in cerebral oxygenation during exercise have been linked to brain activity and central command. Isometric- and dynamic-resistance exercise-(RE) may elicit differential responses in systemic circulation, neural function and metabolism; all important regulators of cerebral circulation. We examined whether (i) cerebral oxygenation differs between isometric- and dynamic-RE of similar exercise characteristics and (ii) cerebral oxygenation changes relate to cardiovascular adjustments occurring during RE. Fourteen men performed, randomly, an isometric-RE and a dynamic-RE of similar characteristics (bilateral-leg-press, 2-min×4-sets, 30% of maximal-voluntary-contraction, equivalent tension-time-index/workload). Cerebral-oxygenation (oxyhaemoglobin-O2Hb; total haemoglobin-tHb/blood-volume-index; deoxyhemoglobin-HHb) was assessed by NIRS and beat-by-beat haemodynamics via photoplethysmography. Cerebral-O2Hb and tHb progressively increased from the 1st to 4th set in both RE-protocols (p < 0.05); HHb slightly decreased (p < 0.05). Changes in NIRS-parameters were similar between RE-protocols within each exercise-set (p = 0.91–1.00) and during the entire protocol (including resting-phases) (p = 0.48–0.63). O2Hb and tHb changes were not correlated with changes in systemic haemodynamics. In conclusion, cerebral oxygenation/blood-volume steadily increased during multiple-set RE-protocols. Isometric- and dynamic-RE of matched exercise characteristics resulted in similar prefrontal oxygenation/blood volume changes, suggesting similar cerebral haemodynamic and possibly neuronal responses to maintain a predetermined force.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zafeiridis et al. (2022) reported an RCT. Isometric resistance exercise vs. Dynamic resistance exercise was evaluated on Changes in cerebral oxygenation (O2Hb, tHb, HHb) between protocols (p=0.48-0.63). Isometric and dynamic resistance exercise of matched characteristics resulted in similar prefrontal oxygenation and blood volume changes during the entire protocol (p=0.48-0.63).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: