N-Confused Metalloporphyrin-Based Electrocatalysts for Oxygen Reduction

Inspired by natural porphyrin-containing enzymatic active sites, metalloporphyrins have become important platforms for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) catalysis because of their well-defined structures and tunable coordination environments. Recently, breaking the N4-coordination environment of cobalt porphyrins by inverting one pyrrolic unit to generate N3C1-site, i.e., N-confused porphyrin, has emerged as an effective strategy to promote their electro-catalyzing ORR capability. Herein, we reviewed recent progress in N-confused cobalt porphyrin in catalyzing ORR, with special emphasis on the influence of the catalyst’s architecture. We first summarized the general ORR mechanism on metalloporphyrins and the computational methods commonly used for mechanistic studies. Then, for comparison, the more common modification strategies like meso- and β-position substitution, axial coordination, and dinuclear design were reviewed for cobalt porphyrin-based catalysts. The main part reviewed the N-confused cobalt porphyrins with three different architectures, i.e., molecular, framework, and supported heterogeneous molecular form, highlighting their synthesis, characterization, electrocatalytic ORR behavior, and mechanistic interpretation from both experimental and theoretical perspectives. It summarizes the current understanding of why CoN3C1 systems outperform the original CoN4 porphyrin systems. The architecture of catalysts was found to affect the selectivity and mechanisms of ORR, along with the discussion of pH. The effects of N-confused strategy were compared to other modification strategies. Finally, we proposed possible directions for integrated catalyst design and mechanism studies.