Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tobacco Control 1993; 2: 103-113 ORIGINAL ARTICLES Tobacco industry response to a risk assessment of environmental tobacco smoke L i s a A Bero, Stanton A Glantz Institute for Health Policy Studies, School of Medicine and Division of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmacy, University of California, San Francisco, California, USA L A Bero Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine and Institute for Health Policy Studies, School of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, California, USA SA Glantz Correspondence to: Lisa A Bero, Institute for Health Policy Studies, University of California, San Francisco, 1388 Sutter Street, 11th Floor, San Francisco, C A 94109, U S A i cigarette smoke is an air pollutant. T h e industry's response has been multi-faceted, consisting of advertising, political advocacy, funding research, and smokers' rights campaigns. Despite these efforts by the industry, there has been an increasing aware- ness of the health effects of tobacco, including the effects of tobacco smoke on non-smokers. Restrictions on where people can smoke have led to decreases i n the amount of tobacco people consume. Recently, the public and the tobacco i n - dustry have been offered the opportunity to respond with scientific comments to a risk assessment of environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) conducted by the U S Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) entitled Health effects of passive smoking: assessment of lung cancer in adults and respiratory disorders i n children ( the draft risk assessment ). The draft risk assessment concluded that E T S causes lung cancer i n adults and respiratory problems in children. The draft had significant policy implications since its approval led to a decision to classify E T S as a Group A (known human) carcinogen and has accelerated the trend towards smoking restrictions in work- places and public places. The draft was open to technical comment from June 25 to October 1, 1990. T h e draft was also reviewed by the E P A ' s Science Advisory Board (SAB) to provide an outside, expert assessment of its scientific accuracy. A summary of the public comments was provided to the S A B . The E P A revised and updated the document following the public comment period and S A B review. This study compares the content of the comments submitted by persons affiliated with the tobacco industry to the comments by the SAB. (Tobacco Control 1993j 2: 103-113) The only study to evaluate the quality of scientific data presented by the tobacco i n - dustry in response to a government report on Introduction E T S was conducted by the New Zealand Public policies to regulate exposure to en- Department of Health. Its analysis of the vironmental hazards are generally based on New Zealand Tobacco Institute's submission formal risk assessments prepared through a in response to the New Zealand Department of process open to scrutiny and comment from Health's report on E T S , found that the the public and industries that might be affected Tobacco Institute submitted an incomplete, by regulation of their product. It is sometimes selective and distorted analysis of the scientific difficult to determine whether or not an data. Specifically, the New Zealand Depart- industry's response to a regulatory policy is a ment of Health concluded that the submission: valuable scientific contribution to the risk reviewed less than 40 % of the refereed scien- assessment or mere advocacy of the industry's tific literature published since the U S Surgeon economic interest. The tobacco industry has General's report on E T S ; cited mainly un- been subject to increasing restrictions of its refereed research for post-1986 studies; product because of growing evidence that ignored scientists' defence of their work, Abstract Objective - T o analyse the tobacco industry's response to the U S Environ- mental Protection Agency (EPA) draft risk assessment of environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) and compare it to the response of the EPA's Science Advisory Board. To examine the peer review status of the literature cited to support criticisms of the risk assessment. Method-A content analysis of all sub- missions received by the E P A , analysis of all literature cited in the submissions and classification by topic and whether or not the literature was peer reviewed. Results - Sixty-four percent (69/107) of submissions received by the E P A claimed that the conclusions of the draft were invalid and, of these, 71 % (49/69) were submitted by tobacco industry-affiliated individuals. The specific arguments pre- sented by commentors affiliated with the industry differed qualitatively from those of the Science Advisory Board and were supported by the selective citation of non- peer reviewed literature. Compared to tobacco industry-affiliated reviewers, the risk assessment cited more references on E T S (32% vs. 15%) and fewer non- refereed publications (27 % vs. 37 %) (p < Conclusion - The majority of comments that were critical of the risk assessment were submitted by tobacco industry- affiliated reviewers. The critical com- ments differed in content from the Sci- ence Advisory Board Report and were more often (compared to the draft E P A report) supported by non-peer reviewed references.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bero et al. (1993) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: