This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
In the early part of this paper, conflicting perspectives of mathematics education are discussed. An argument is made for more systematic analysis of students’ handicaps in the performance of basic arithmetic operations. Such analysis is viewed as an important basis for more focused prescriptive remedial instruction. Specific information regarding functional handicaps in basic arithmetic and mathematic computation is not available from traditional school test scores from either norm or criterion referenced tests. Similarly, the developmentally orientated assumptions of the United States’ National Council of Teachers of Mathematics Curriculum Standards, aimed as they are toward initial instruction in mathematics, are not seen as particularly fruitful for the remedial mathematics instruction of young adults. Specific deficit information was seen as extremely valuable in designing appropriate analytic teaching methods and materials for remedial mathematics instruction. In the latter portions of this report a new procedure for the identification of systematic errors, based on foil response analysis, is described. A large scale, cross‐replicated, base‐rate error survey is conducted. Common functional handicaps (algorithm errors) are identified and focused remedial efforts, based on the analytic teaching model, are implemented. The value of the findings lies not only in the corroboration of the very rapid atrophy of unused mathematics skills, even among students actively involved in their high school studies; but, more particularly, in the identification of specific areas of computational difficulty of American [1] high school youth and in the exploration of new innovative assessment procedures for the generation of remedial instructional efforts. It is argued that high school or adult basic skills teachers may profitably devote a portion of their effort to the identification of students’ specific procedural deficits in order to use that information to formulate remedial instruction strategies.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James A. Dunn (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: