Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The problem is simply stated, but resists solution. We begin with the classical historiographic images of Old Regime societies of South Asia and suggest that beneath the surface of abstract formulations for and against these images, unrecognised difficulties of assumption and method allow them to persist in the contemporary imagination. This not only hampers understanding of historic societies, taken individually, but prevents proper assessment of their comparative significance on an international plane. The relationship between these images of discontinuity and similar sociological images of European peasantry is not coincidental. The errors of the latter are demonstrable through an abundant historiography; the burden of this essay is directed towards a solution to the former. We provide an empirically‐based structural study of social relationships in the countryside of Maharashtra in the 150 years preceding European occupation: a) to begin the accumulation of examples that contradict the received images; b) to provide an analysis of one Old Regime society for its own comparative sake. By examining the social distribution of certain types of right and of access to control of land, we demonstrate the existence of powerful forms of social dominance transcending the frontiers of the village, and strongly influencing the organisation of social, economic and political life in the countryside. Whilst we focus on a specific structural problem (namely, the conception of social totality and its internal ordering), the conclusion and footnotes permit the actual dynamism of the forms of relationship studied to emerge in incipient statement on social change under the old order.† Notes University of Leiden The research behind the material presented in this paper is based on local vernacular sources described in the appropriate appendix, and the paper deals with one aspect of this research. The area covered by it, is what we might call the heartland of the eighteenth‐century Maratha state, emerging within and then straddling the old marcher frontiers of the Adil Shahi and Nijam Shahi states, and now contained within the Pune and Satara districts of modern Maharashtra. A limited amount of support work was also done on other areas which came under full Maratha control only later —especially on parts of the modern Ahmednagar district. Because of the oft‐mentioned historiographical problem, the work was dominated by a concern to rediscover the empirical character of different types of relationship, and to investigate the minutiae of process, underlying their idealisation, and thus to penetrate in depth the most local units of documentation: the village on the one hand, and the family archive on the other. Further, I allowed my direction to be dictated by the progression of my findings rather than by the application of a rigid, predetermined framework on material, the content of which was in essential respects unsuspected. The result is a series of well‐borings, so to speak, into the territories of these districts—the penetration, firstly, of some handfuls of villages among the manifold, supplemented by a certain amount of subsidiary statistical checking into the documents of relevant administrative sub‐districts; and secondly, a fairly extensive assay of the family archives (no more than that because of their uncatalogued state), which, while covering larger areas than the village, are selective in that they deal only with those separated items of income and administration directly or indirectly involved in the life of that household. This summary may explain why the thesis of this paper is an unexpected derivative of this essentially pragmatic programme. It must also partly explain the piecemeal form of the evidence (other reasons derive from the nature of the relationships they describe, as suggested below), which prevents me from prosecuting my argument by providing the type of statistical cover appropriate to the study of later times. Even when problems began to clarify, my task as a researcher (with too little time at his disposal), in verifying previously unestablished types of relationship, seemed to require a progressive penetration deeper into the structures of the socio‐agrarian units of production (such as the village), in order to explore their nature and to derive their form. Now that the material is being collated and a new level of interpretive hypothesis emerging, a fresh cycle of research becomes relevant, in order to gather a further range of empirical data, and to determine the spatial incidence and qualitative variation of such relationships. Since a local historiography of the medieval Deccan does not yet exist in any meaningful modern terms (excepting the historical chapters provided in Mann's valuable studies [1917 and 1921]; we look forward to the publication of Professor A. R. Kulkarni's extensive examination of the documents of Indapur taluka, and, so far as the neighbouring Konkan is concerned, of Gill Yamin's study of Ratnagiri district), the researcher, after taking leave of a generally assumed orthodoxy, is very much a traveller in a landscape in which the difference between mirage and material object is always ambiguous. The range and extent of the relationships which we discuss below are thus in question ; but their existence is not. We should add that it is not merely the identification of a certain structure of social relationships that is in question—the concern of this paper—but also the potential movement in the socio‐economy which these relationships describe and effect. The answers may be hypothetical at this stage; the questions, bearing their own heuristic content, are not. Like Milsom, ‘I shall be content if it is agreed that the questions arise, and therefore that the world cannot have been quite as we have supposed’ [Milsom, 1976: vii]. The central location of the areas studied, within the eighteenth‐century Maratha state, is significant, for it provides a level of relative continuity and administrative stability, not necessarily provided by areas still contested for and subject to the special ‘military’ forms of administration provided for the latter. Findings for these central areas, therefore, ought to possess validity in testing the types of relationships and change that may occur under the cover of a mainstream of a period of rule. The term ‘medieval’ requires explanation for non‐Indianists (in the same way that ‘Old Regime’ will require explanation for Indianists). In this respect, I am simply operating the current usage of the Indianist historiography, and thus providing a chronological reference immediately accessible within the latter. If use of this term seems a little far‐fetched when applied to a period of time coterminous with that of the Early Modern epoch of European history and with the first phase of the Industrial Revolution in England (late fifteenth up to the end of the second decade of the nineteenth century), growing familiarity with a society in which there is so much parallelism of form with the much earlier societies of medieval Europe (despite very considerable differences), breeds an increasingly sympathetic tolerance for the implied degree of comparison it contains. Answers to the question of the comparative significance of the Old Regimes of Asia and Africa will require careful treatment in their own terms, at a later stage. By ‘late‐medieval’, I refer merely to the fact that the study in this essay is limited to the last of the ‘medieval’ centuries in this part of the world (i.e. that immediately preceding and leading to British rule). I must emphasise in the strongest terms that this paper is not an analysis of tenure, inam, credit, peasant rights, or patilki. It is an argument about certain selected kinds of social relationship, and socio‐economic operation, which express themselves in terms of the given institutional structures of the society concerned; evidence is thus of many kinds, but the exploration of certain relevant types, such as patilki, does not imply statements about the whole. This should explain the peculiar emphases in this paper. I stress the administrative and economic potential of patilki control, at the expense of its cultural meaning, because of the particular relevance of the former for my argument (it is also a neglected aspect in a literature that overstresses the interpretive significance of ritual and status). I neglect the question of religious inam because although indeed important in the life of the Deccan, there are certain types which I describe that seem to become dominant during the eighteenth century, and which have a loosening effect on the inherited system of rights. Sharecropping is indeed a subject with many important nuances for understanding the agrarian economy; but I am not providing, in this paper, an analysis of sharecropping—merely locating it as an important means of taking hold of the production of the countryside by more or less ‘superior’ classes of person, entailing an alteration in content of the social relations of husbandry.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Frank Perlin (1978) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: