Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In 5 experiments, male and female undergraduates viewed gestures and tried to select the words that originally accompanied them; read interpretations of gestures* meanings and tried to select the words that originally had accompanied them; tried to recognize gestures they previously had seen, presented either with or without the accompanying speech; and assigned gestures and the accompanying speech to semantic categories.On all 4 tasks, performance was better than chance but markedly inferior to performance when words were used as stimuli.Judgments of a gesture's semantic category were determined principally by the accompanying speech rather than gestural form.It is concluded that although gestures can convey some information, they are not richly informative, and the information they convey is largely redundant with speech Although spontaneous hand gestures' are ubiquitous accompaniments to conversational speech, neither the process by which they are generated nor the functions they serve for speaker and addressee are well understood.Such gestures are usually assumed to be communicative.However, among researchers and writers who have addressed the subject, there is no clear consensus about the amount and kind of information they convey.Historically, gestures have been endowed with extraordinary communicative powers.Some of the claims seem fanciful at best.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Krauss et al. (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: