Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This randomized trial examines the impact of moral education in youth sports on character development for disadvantaged children, highlighting necessary actions for equality.
I came of age during the era of civil rights marches and antiwar protests. Michael Harrington’s (1962) classic, The Other America: Poverty in the United States, which influenced Kennedy and Johnson’s antipoverty programs in the 1960s, opened my eyes to the contradictions of poverty and inequality in the world’s most affluent nation. Harrington (1962) believed that if he could shed light on the concrete experience of the rural and urban poor, he could galvanize support for policies necessary to not only alleviate the pain of poverty but transform the structures that perpetuate it. Harrington assumed, perhaps naively, that once people understood the plight of the poor, they would commit themselves to being part of the solution. Fifty years later we find ourselves as a nation struggling to respond to that “other America.” Over 20% of our children live in poverty and a third of our citizens struggle to pay their bills. Economic hardship translates into reduced educational opportunity for growing numbers of children, who simply cannot keep pace with their more fortunate peers.The “other America” is growing at a frightening pace with profound implications for what Murray (this issue) calls our “civic culture.” Character educators have, I believe, an important role to play in awakening the public to the reality of our situation and in creating the conditions for a serious deliberation about the course of action needed to provide for our children’s future. Before leaping to generalizations about what kind of character education we need to transform our country, I will relate what I learned about the challenge of implementing character education programs from a recent research study of middle school varsity basketball teams funded by the LA84 Foundation. My colleagues and I began this study with a conventional pre/post research design and a simple question—can we prepare youth sport coaches to be effective moral educators? I use the term moral instead of character development because character development includes nonmoral, achievement-related virtues, like perseverance, or what Murray calls industriousness. Although sports participation may well foster nonmoral virtues, there had been no evidence that it fosters moral virtues, like justice. We found that participation in a 3-hour Play Like a Champion Today (PLC) clinic focused on teaching coaches to lead moral discussions in team meetings had major impact on the quality of athletes’ experience. The athletes on the PLC teams made significant gains in moral functioning compared to those in a control group (Power & Seroczynski, 2013). In addition, we found that the players on the PLC teams reported that they had more fun and learned more.As much as we were encouraged by these results, we were disheartened by the conditions we found in the urban public school system where we conducted our research. At that time the school system faced a $10 million deficit. The child poverty rate in the schools was over 25% and only 56% of the eighth-grade students had passed the No Child Left Behind expectation in reading (Federal Education Budget Project, 2011). A number of services had already been cut back and this included sports programs. The budget funded only one basketball coach per tem although team sizes varied from 15 to 20 players. The coaches of both the PLC and control teams made heroic efforts to keep their players involved. Recognizing the value of the relationships that they had with their players and the experience of being on a team, they refused to cut anyone. Their players were indeed fortunate just to be on a team because there simply are not many opportunities to play sports for children whose families cannot afford the fees charged by the growing number of clubs and travel teams. Coakley (2008) notes that since the 1980s, as publically funded programs have been reduced or eliminated altogether, there has been a marked privatization of youth sports programs throughout the United States.Any discussion about the future of character education must begin by confronting the stark truth that access to quality schools, sports teams, and other institutions that support and promote child development depends to a large extent on family income. In other words, the opportunities that teachers, coaches, and child care professionals have to do character education reflect the inequalities of wealth in the United States. Yet the problem goes much deeper than that of opportunity. Poverty does more than rob children of promise, poverty places children in peril. Summarizing the results of a 25-year study of “crack babies,” Hallam Hurt, the lead author and former chair of neonatology at Albert Einstein Medical Center and the study’s lead researcher, concluded: “Poverty is a more powerful influence on the outcome of inner-city children than gestational exposure to cocaine” (Fitzgerald, 2013). In an earlier study, Handzel, Brodsky, Betancourt, and Hurt (2012), looked at 8-and 10-year-old poor African American children’s perceptions of their future and life outcomes at ages 16 to 18. They found that while over 90% of the young children pictured their futures full of promise, only 8 years later 56% had experienced at least one trajectory-altering event, such as getting arrested, becoming a parent, and failing at school. TAEs are highly correlated with exposure to violence and troubled home environments.If our educational institutions are to meet the challenges of America’s future, we must guarantee that they serve the children in that “other America,” as well as those who benefit from the bounty of the fortunate upper class. Although not addressing educational institutions directly, the two “foundational” articles for this edition make clear that if our children are to flourish in the years ahead, those responsible for their upbringing must meet the needs of developing individuals while addressing the cultural context in which they are they are to be educated. Daniel Lapsley’s (this issue) psychological focus on the epigenetic process of “coming of age” and Murray’s (this issue) sociological focus on reuniting America’s cultural divide complement each other. They also lead to disturbing questions about whether we as a people have the will to invest in a character education capable of revitalizing America’s democracy.In my own work in moral education almost over four decades now, I have followed in the path of John Dewey and other developmental psychologists, like Piaget and Kohlberg, who see individuals and their social environments in dynamic interaction. In my research and practice, I have focused on the importance of nurturing individual moral development within just communities characterized by shared norms of social responsibility and democratic participation (Power, Higgins, & Kohlberg, 1989; Power & Power, 2012). My approach to moral education builds on Lapsley’s (this issue) psychological framework while responding to Murray’s (this issue) concern about the decline our civic culture and the widening gap between the upper and lower classes in America. Like Lapsley, I trust in the resilience of our youth and the capacity of the sciences of education and psychology to provide instructional strategies and environments sensitive enough to meet the needs of individual children from every kind of background. On the other hand, like Murray, I see a divided and paralyzed America very much in need of a Great Moral Awakening.As much as I appreciate Murray’s willingness to address our divided civic culture, I question whether his analysis deflects our attention from the heart of the problems that are tearing America asunder. Murray believes that the civic culture has “unraveled” over the last fifty years as the upper and lower classes split apart. The lower, working class abandoned the core virtues of industriousness, honesty, marriage, and religiosity while a smug upper class looked the other way. Murray exhorts the upper class to rescue themselves and the lower class from what he sees as a crisis of character: “The new upper class must mobilize its convictions and passion on behalf of traditional civic culture or it is doomed” (Murray, this issue, p. 3) Murray describes this upper class in various ways. They are the “upper middle class,” “the cognitively talented,” “the dominant minority,” and “those who are supposed to set the standard.” Although he also chides them for becoming a “hollow elite,” he, nevertheless, credits them for having held on to the core American virtues (with the exception of religiosity).In Murray’s (this issue) view, the problem with the upper class is that while they still “practice” the core virtues, they no longer “preach” them. Murray explains this refusal of the upper class to impose its values on the lower class as a lack of self-confidence, which is related to nonjudgmentalism and a relativistic acceptance of the vulgar mores of the lower class. Those in the upper class are secure in their own virtue but they have become uncertain and weak, settling for a norm of indifferent “niceness” rather than asserting the core virtues that led America to greatness. The failure of the upper class to accept the mantle of cultural leadership is not a failure to respond to the needs of the lower class as it is a failure exercise self-control and inner restraint. The upper class is not unjust; they are “unseemly.” They lack good taste and self-restraint. Murray cites as examples of unseemliness a television producer building a house with 123 rooms and a chief executive officer giving himself a $99 million golden parachute and an $82 million pension in economic hard times.Murray’s (this issue) complaint against the upper class seems more about aesthetics than morality. Although Murray criticizes the self-segregation and isolation of the upper class from the lower class, he notes that he is not advocating for government assistance or that the upper class should “sacrifice its self-interest.” On the other hand, Murray also calls for the upper class to “rediscover” what that self-interest really is. I would hope that those who have prospered the most in America would confront the consequences of the growing inequality of wealth and declining social mobility. It is in everyone’s interest that we address the scourge of the child poverty rate in the United States, which is now the second highest in the world among developed nations, according a recent United Nations Children’s Fund (2013) report. Poverty can hardly be overcome simply by exhorting children and their families to the virtues of industrious, honesty, marriage, and religiosity. Children who go to school hungry and or sick cannot learn. Children who do not have access to the linguistically and culturally enriching experiences that the upper class take for granted are behind their more advantaged peers before they ever set foot in school, and inequitable schooling further widens the achievement gap (Reardon, 2013). Children who come from neighborhoods where the odds are higher that they will end up in prison than find employment need social networks and educational services as well as character education.Although he does not focus specifically on poverty, Lapsley (this issue) challenges the status quo by pointing out that “the aspirations of youngsters” must be “matched with educational experiences that meet their developmental needs.” He notes sadly that a “distressing number of youngsters” will not have the “pathways” that will lead them to productive roles in adult society. It is pointless for the scholarly community of character educators to refine our strategies and models for promoting development of virtue without confronting the reality of our “other America.” We pledge to be a nation “with liberty and justice for all.” Poor and working class families need access to employment housing, health care, preschool education, recreational programs, and social services to ensure that their children share in the American promise. Over the last 2 decades debates over taxation, the distribution of wealth, and welfare programs have become increasingly contentious. Character educators themselves disagree over the proper balance between the principles of liberty and justice. Yet in spite of these disagreements, character educators have the responsibility to prepare future generations to pursue “liberty and justice for all.”As intractable as our political battles have become, the danger grows that we will become increasingly entrenched in our ideological enclaves more focused on the shortcomings of our opponents than on the common good. The future of our nation, I believe, depends upon our recommitment to the moral ideal of democracy. That ideal challenges all of us to an open and ongoing dialogue about who we are as a nation and how we can resolve our differences for the good of all. As character educators, we must help our children, no matter what their social class, to develop the sensibilities and skills to become engaged citizens who put the good of the country as a whole ahead of personal and class interests. Murray (2012) closes his book by calling upon members of the upper class to “start preaching what they practice.” His response to class division implies that there should be two kinds of character education, one for leaders and another for followers. Yet America’s democratic ideal demands that we educate all children as leaders. More fundamentally, our understanding of what it means to be fully human should challenge us to provide all children with an education that fosters their autonomy and sense of shared responsibility.Educating for democracy should do more than teach children about democratic institutions in a social studies or civics class. Educating for democracy demands a special kind of character education that provides what Horace Mann referred to as an “apprenticeship in democracy” (Cremin, 1957, p. 58). Children need to learn through practice how to deliberate about and resolve issues that arise in their life together. As we are finding in a Templeton funded study of a variety of group settings (schools, sports teams, and religious groups), adolescents receive multiple exhortations to virtue. Yet those that move them to moral responsibility appeal to their sense of moral responsibility. Unfortunately, outside of student government, most schools do not involve students in decision making. Many educators mistakenly believe that students, particularly those who struggle academically and behaviorally, are incapable of self-governance.In my experience, all young people, particularly the disadvantaged, benefit from experiences that foster their sense of agency and social responsibility. The most powerful example in my experience comes from the Y.E.S. (Your Educational Success) program, a school-within-a-school for at-risk high school students in South Bend. All of the students had at least one trajectory-altering event. I was asked by a couple of the teachers who had set up the program to consult with them about applying the just community approach. When I explained that would involve all of the students in direct participatory democracy and building a strong sense of community, they politely thanked me but declined their invitation, informing me they had already committed to a family oriented model, in which the teachers were to foster warm, parental relationships with their students. This model left no room for democracy as their parental role meant that they were to act as authorities in making up the disciplinary rules and enforcing them. From a convention perspective, the family model certainly made sense for the Y.E.S. student population, all of whom came from broken homes and two of whom lived at a homeless shelter. I assured the teachers that I would be happy to work with them should they ever wish to give the just community approach a try. A year later the teachers returned, and with great determination and some trepidation, we introduced the just community approach to the Y.E.S. community. Concretely, this meant that the students would participate in weekly democratic community meetings in which they made school rules and policies and in fairness committee meetings in which they would their rules and settle disputes.At first, the students had little idea of what democracy meant other than politicians posturing in commercials and televised debates.After several meetings, however, they began to see that they had real power and responsibility. For example, the teachers told them that could have a “student lounge” as long as they developed policies for keeping the area neat and orderly. The students eagerly accepted the challenge only to discover that “policing” the area was far more demanding than they had imagined. Eventually, the students and teachers developed and revised rules about attendance, lateness, homework, and cheating. Students, all of whom had been truant before coming to Y.E.S., now sat on the Fairness Committee adjudicating attendance violations. The teachers offered voluntary Saturday school for students who wanted extra help to catch up on their studies. Almost every student attended regularly. The students unanimously voted to engage in the community and everyone participated. New students entering the school often experienced an initial “culture shock” but quickly became assimilated. One new student, who was on the football team, began bullying a veteran community member only to be told, “Cut that out, I am taking you to the Fairness Committee.” Bystanders, who were also experienced members of the Y.E.S. Program, backed him up. The new student, bewildered by the confrontation, backed off, asking what in the world a Fairness Committee was.The just community approach succeeded beyond my expectations. Students’ moral judgment developed over one quarter of a stage; there were few disciplinary infractions and no incidents of cheating (including the copying of assignments), stealing, or fighting. Absences declined and from a of to a democratic community by two Y.E.S. students, the told me that he wanted to the just community approach to all of the high to our at the of its the the Y.E.S. because its to student was the it with a In spite of evidence to the many in the school system believed that at-risk students needed to teach them to character education often the class that in the of as well as individual political and moral All children a character education that to their and them a sense of and responsibility. an education is important for them to of age” as individuals and for us as a people to make good on our of “liberty and justice for all.”
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
F. Clark Power (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: