Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Article reveals the importance of virtue education for personal flourishing and responsible freedom.
In the 2009 BBC film, An Education, the film’s lead character, 16-year-old Jenny Mellor, played by Carey Mulligan, is a student who seems to have it all together, including the requisite ability to be a successful student in a prestigious boarding school. Jenny has been groomed by her parents her whole life to attain an offer of admission to Oxford. However, when she meets David, a man almost twice her age who offers excitement, culture, travel, and even a proposal of marriage, both Jenny and her parents are charmed. With her parents’ permission, Jenny decides to drop out of school to marry him. In an encounter with the school’s headmistress, Mrs. Walters, played by Emma Thompson, we come to understand why Jenny finds nothing compelling in her educational experience at school.To be effective, educators must consider the validity of Jenny’s statement and how best to rise to her challenge: “It’s not enough to educate us anymore … You’ve got to tell us why you are doing it.”What young people need most is the “schooling of desire,” a schooling that inspires them to want to choose well among competing goods, an education that inspires them to use their freedom responsibly (Bohlin, 2005). The “argument worth rehearsing” is this: What constitutes flourishing? How will developing virtues, excellences of mind and character, help students to flourish and use their freedom well? In this article I will explore virtue education as the schooling of desire. I will discuss why virtue is the most salutary building block for human flourishing—becoming one’s best possible self—and how it guides motivation and civic engagement.Daniel Lapsley’s (this issue) “The Promise and Peril of Coming of Age in the 21st Century” aptly captures what I have come to appreciate in my work as the odyssey of adolescence—an epic adventure replete with battlefronts and opportunities for young people, parents and educators. Schools are well positioned to respond to students’ need to “develop competencies, surmount vulnerabilities, make adaptive changes and pursue options that contribute to thriving and well-being” (p. 20). These competencies include virtues such as the courage to overcome fears, the self-mastery to resist temptations and the habit of stopping to reflect on competing claims about what it means to thrive and lead a fully flourishing life. Young people need a strong moral compass, and they need to consult it often as they form their own identity and shape a life for themselves.The schooling of desire helps them to develop the competencies and virtues that constitute this compass. These internalized dispositions, in turn, empower them to navigate the storms of adolescence purposefully—to adjust the sails so they can catch the wind and redirect their course as needed. Good character needs to be made attractive and compelling to adolescents. Images of flourishing and degradation abound—as well as everything in between. White collar crime in the corporate world, sex scandals in the highest offices, and drug abuse among world-renowned athletes remind us that even the most educated and accomplished individuals can lack virtue and good judgment. In other words, young people need motivation to live virtuously—again, this is an argument worth rehearsing.In Book IV of Plato’s Republic, Socrates offers a pioneering analysis of human motivation. As an analogy for his discussion of how justice can be achieved in a city with conflicting interests, he invites his interlocutors to reflect on how justice can be achieved in the human psyche with its conflicting desires. The three seats of motivation in the human psyche or soul, he explains, are the appetite, the spirited part and the rational part. We can envision these three parts as the gut, the heart and the head. The appetite or gut blindly desires pleasure. It is the seat of hunger, thirst, and sexual instinct. The appetite wants to be fed, satisfied, delighted, and to have fun. The second seat of motivation, the spirited part or chest area, desires achievement, recognition, encouragement, and love. It wants to be moved and inspired. The third seat of motivation is the rational part or head. Reason desires inquiry and understanding. It wants to know, to discover, and to be informed. Left to pursue their own interests, these three seats of motivation can easily mislead or conflict a person.When the appetite dominates without the guidance of reason, we witness the tyranny of self-indulgence and even addiction. Think of Phil Connors in Columbia Pictures’ Groundhog Day (1993) or Dudley Dursley in the Harry Potter series. When a person makes choices based on blind impulse, his appetite calls the shots. It rallies emotion and ambition to pursue a given whim or fancy. The appetite can persuade a person to rationalize overeating, procrastination, or any indulgence. When the spirited part dominates without the wise counsel of reason, a person may pursue gain at any cost. Think of Macbeth or Whitey Bulger. Blind ambition or blind emotion can lead to infatuation, cheating, violence, bullying or abuse of power.Socrates argued that the justice or harmony among these three parts is necessary for a person to flourish. This harmony is not achieved when reason dominates, but rather when reason captains and aligns the spirited ambitions and appetites with what is good for the individual as a whole. By channeling and directing their desires to delight in and be inspired by the best possible good, people can freely direct their lives in positive and constructive ways. This tripartite psychology is instructive for educators on a number of fronts (Tigner, 1996). First of all, it reminds us that our students are motivated on all three levels—and sometimes conflicted. Their gut, heart and head are highly desirous, and good teachers understand the importance of feeding all three parts in ways that help them to desire, enjoy, and practice activities that lead a person to greater flourishing and freedom.Contemporary brain research is clear that the amygdala, which processes memory and emotion and is located in what has been called the “reptilian brain,” is the seat of our fight or flight response. The “new brain” or neocortex is what enables us to stop and think, to evaluate the merits of what we desire. It enables us to weigh consequences and consider the needs of others. We see risk-taking behaviors as well as fear and paralysis in adolescents precisely because the neocortex is not fully developed, and the amygdala is highly responsive. Exercising the neocortex is like exercising muscle, Deak (2011) explains. It is strengthened with practice. When we teach students to reflect on what motivates them and why, they begin to develop new neural pathways and patterns of mature deliberation. When we help them to develop a capacity to discern and desire what is true, good and noble, they develop the capacity to channel their appetites and ambitions constructively. Some people call this impulse control or will power, and Baumeister’s (2011) research offers instructive insight on how will power can be harnessed and developed. Yet young people are plugged in 24/7: texting under the dinner table; tweeting, posting, and iChatting while doing their homework; and sleeping with smartphones beneath their pillows. How do educators and parents compete? How can we provide a compelling educational experience that puts students in the driver’s seat of constructive learning and growth?Last spring I was copied on an e-mail a parent sent to one of the history teachers at Montrose School: “Thank you so much for a delightful ride home from school today. My daughter was telling me that history was a highlight. She spoke about the national debt, valuation of currency, the cost of war and more. We have a 45-minute ride home and were still talking about Czars Nicholas and Alexander, then about the war in Afghanistan, as we pulled into the garage. Thank you for awakening this passion and helping us raise a daughter who understands that learning about history will enable her to function more responsibly as a citizen.”How do we inspire this kind of reflection, discipline and diligence in a culture that celebrates immediacy, ease, and comfort? Great educators provide “the argument” Jenny Mellor was seeking by feeding students’ desires for lasting satisfaction. They teach self-mastery by cultivating students’ taste for what it means to engage life fully. Empowered with new habits of sustained engagement in purposeful work, students discover a new and deeper level of enjoyment in learning.During last period on a Friday afternoon before vacation, I visited a precalculus class. As students in small groups enthusiastically scribbled solutions, compared notes and started over, I was unable to capture the attention of the girl with whom I had hoped to speak. What was the secret to their rapt attention? They were learning how to solve systems of equations using matrices and the Gaussian elimination method. “It is a challenging process involving many steps,” the teacher explained. “What makes it particularly difficult is that there is no right way. It is sort of like a maze. You can start down one path and realize you aren’t going to get where you want to, so you have to retrace your steps and try another way. It can be quite frustrating but extremely rewarding when you get the right answer!”Cognitive science reminds us that our brains only develop and grow when faced with increasingly challenging tasks. And mistakes—a paper that missed the mark, an error in math, a conflict with a peer at lunchtime— provide particularly valuable learning opportunities. Virtue is nurtured by helping students to reflect on mistakes and learn from them. Trial and error and formative (rather than punitive) discipline foster students’ capacity to make amends and begin again.Dweck (2006) calls this approach cultivating a “growth mindset.” The end goal is not the highest GPA or public recognition for individual talent. The end goal is openness to learning and approaching problems in new ways. We are not “fixed” beings with a limited capacity for learning based on our native gifts and abilities, she argues. Rather, we possess a dynamic, open-ended capacity for growth. This capacity is sustained and strengthened by the schooling of desire. The goal of the schooling of desire is that each student sees herself as a work in progress who strives to develop the habits of mind and character that enable her to give her best to her work, to her relationships, and to society. To make virtue one’s own, to develop strength in new and challenging contexts requires personal effort each day. It doesn’t happen overnight. It’s not a fixed capacity. It is the exciting and unfinished work of a lifetime. Students—and adults for that matter—remain works in progress.The schooling of desire is highly personalized. Each student’s starting points and progress will be different. Certain conditions— family, health, social, educational, economic—and choices may limit students’ freedom to grow as quickly as we would like. These conditions, however, never remove their personal agency, their ability to make choices that define who they are and the person they can become. Educators can never lose hope in the promise and potential of their students.I was struck by the reflections of a graduating senior who told me that her highest aspiration in middle school was to find a boyfriend she could hang out with on weekends. She had already decided the look, music, and fashion she needed to adopt to attain her ideal of becoming a cool and happy teenager. It was a music teacher who helped her discover her love for a wider range of music and tapped into her talent as a vocalist. Once hooked, this student was motivated to study voice and spend her Saturdays at the conservatory. Her interest in other academic subjects grew as well. She came to appreciate her teachers as mentors, passionate about subjects that suddenly seemed new and compelling to her. She developed a disciplined study schedule to balance academics with her musical commitments outside of school. She gradually shed her former ideal of adolescent “happiness” and committed herself fully to school and her passion for music.Young people need inspiration and exemplars. They need to envision possibilities for their life. They need a taste of what it is like to have worked hard and to have learned something new to awaken their desire to become their best possible self. The National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (1997) highlighted among other variables the power of one caring adult, a mentor, to transform a young person’s life and aspirations.In the United States, freedom is among our highest ideals—the freedom to choose, freedom from oppression, freedom to vote, the freedom to bear arms, and the freedom to reinvent one’s self. We vigorously debate and defend the scope and limits of these freedoms. Education in virtue does not lead to conformity or rule following, but to responsible use of freedom, to conscientious objection when warranted, and to adherence to what is true and right regardless of the law.The American ideals of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness do not simply yield the license to do as we please, when we please. This is important for adolescents to understand. Freedom is hard. In choosing one thing we are necessarily renouncing another. This isthreatening to a teenager full of conflicting desires, moods and thoughts. They are afraid of missing out. Part of becoming a mature adult is realizing we live in a tense unity and will sometimes find making choices difficult. Yet to become mature we have to choose, we have to exercise our agency. Our fundamental desire is not merely freedom from something but freedom for something. Freedom is not an end in itself. We exercise our freedom by making worthwhile commitments. Part of growing up is understanding that our choices begin to define who we are and what we care about.Limitations—in the form of obligations to neighbors, colleagues, family, faith community, school, professional work, or social service—do in fact, give direction to our freedom. The more consciously we embrace and decide to accept the commitments that we have made, for example, the freer we are to live life fully, to be happy—as long as there is nothing intrinsically evil or harmful in these obligations. Education in virtue ultimately strengthens our agency and helps us use our freedom responsibly.All of us are called to respond to circumstances outside our control—a shortage of help at work, an accident, health problems, or job loss. How we respond reveals our character, our virtue in action. As Collins (2005) puts it, “Greatness is not a function of circumstance. Greatness, as it turns out, is largely a matter of conscious choice and discipline” (p. 31).Virtues are called into play in both ordinary and extraordinary situations, when we are under stress and when we have the leisure to do as we please. A large part of adolescence is learning how to respond well to what Tigner (1995) calls the daily “stress and of and kind when we like it, or in more up for one’s as by the girl who in out in of education was with a to the head. Montrose we a series. The goal of the is to help students come to envision the possibilities for their own lives by individuals from who have It helps them to see that a into a person who most of her in a who or a person from a ordinary can discover his or her and make a to the These personal the power of agency in one’s own and how the schooling of desire rise to new freedom and the ability to choose I want to a about a former I a of students on a and of and one of my her that our schedule would not her appetite for and was a but from She She only spoke up in the was to one of her the end of our had an on our to the of was fact, I how much this She for a to you that when I I never going to My to This was not a to school, the school’s she as of the She herself to work and a in her She a job to her educational to Her experience in new had only what she like she would have her leisure and in her I had from the because her and were not up to she may have a much to her she had not developed an for she would not have sustained the necessary to develop a she had not on the she had been using her and to this she may have never committed herself to the discipline to new is difficult to all of the and for this It practice and effort for to habits with new It and to inspire and her. It the schooling of desire, and the of her courage and were She the and enjoyment that hard and purposeful (this issue) to virtues in the American and to and the in liberty to for a to education in virtue is Yet he that the contexts and to it are How can Schools will never the of but they can become that for where students can contribute to something than and envision possibilities for their Montrose the student a for each academic This was to life in and activities that helped habits of They an in the where students and teachers could notes of or for and The by example, you notes to and who them with When students are to and shape the culture, they become in something than their or They become in building a that for while public they can and the of young people and the and to which they The hard freedom we in the United is not freedom from but freedom of It is important that public and educators in an effort to do not students of faith or make the discussion of When people as a that to war and they to faith for and young people who their faith As part of their for adolescents to be not only to explore and study but to give an of their own faith it is in the of or there are and for a discussion of in the public our we encounter a range of and We have on social the and and are by our study and When we and in however, we the of more than than or can virtues such as courage and good that our in liberty need virtue in the public to each other to each person regardless of his or her or to a We need the habit of to to one another and engage in inquiry and We need virtue to in when they are We need virtue to to learning from one to the and to our and when we are in virtue is because it freedom and to a young person’s desire to a fully flourishing life. Virtue strengthens personal agency and reminds young people that they can shape their lives with their choices and commitments. It helps them to navigate the and ordinary of life with to choose well among competing The argument worth is why virtue is the best building block for personal flourishing and society.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Karen E. Bohlin (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: