Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Evaluates how macroporosity and database quality affect k s models in soils, indicating potential improvements.
Saturated hydraulic conductivity ( k s ) is a key hydrological property influenced by the size and topology of soil pores, particularly macropores. This study assessed eight ( N = 8) published k s models that derive pore size distributions (PSD) from water retention (WR) functions, with either exponential (Brooks-Corey function, BC) or sigmoidal (van Genuchten function, VG) shapes. The models are semi-empirical ( N = 3) or based on integration of WR-derived PSD ( N = 5). Since measurements of k s are conflated by both natural variability and the method used to determine its values, models were evaluated with hydraulic properties from 378 samples collected using uniform methodology (HYP-UNI), and separately, with data from 1,734 soils measured by multiple institutions using a range of methods (HYPRES). Macroporosity, defined as the fraction of total porosity that is air-filled at −10 kPa (relative air capacity, RAC ), was used to detect soil structure signatures on k s predictions. For HYP-UNI, integral-based models, particularly those using the BC function, performed best in soils with RAC ≥ 5%, but tended to underpredict k s when RAC < 5%. Overprediction was less frequent and mainly associated with low total porosity (∼ 40% or lower). Compared to HYP-UNI, model predictions worsened with HYPRES data and semi-empirical models outperformed integral-based approaches. Underprediction in soils with RAC < 5% persisted with HYPRES data but overprediction was not significantly related to porosity. Underprediction in soils with RAC < 5% was pervasive, indicating a limitation in current models that warrants further investigation. Moreover, this study highlights the advantages of using methodologically uniform databases along with high-quality WR-derived PSDs for development/testing of k s models.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Qin et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: