Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the past decades, the traditional western approach to ethics has been questioned, challenged, and criticized.The focal point of the critique is that western ethics is built on the notion of an independent, even autonomous, self.Critics note, "Kantian and consequentialist moral theories focus primarily on the rational decisions of agents taken as independent and autonomous individuals.Even virtue theory focuses on individuals and their dispositions." 1Such ethics focus on "issues of fairness, equality, and individual rights, seeking impartial and abstract principles that can be applied consistently to particular cases." 2 In such ethics, individuals, "as instances of the general and timeless conception of person," are privileged as the center of consideration, and ethical actions become meaningful only when they are seen as the originators of the actions. 3 The problem with such an approach is that when the self is positioned as an independent agent and privileged as the originator, it has the power to see the other, to define the other, and to know the other.With or without good intentions for the other, this power is already an act of violence to the other.For Emmanuel Levinas, this philosophy of totalizing absorbs, identifies the other, and makes the other the same.In Sharon Todd's words, the "very otherness" is "at the heart of hideous inequity and social violence." 4 ethics that apparently fails so terribly in its regard for the other raises the question whether it can still legitimately be called ethics.Thus a new movement occurred that aims at grounding ethics on a related and embedded notion of the self.This movement draws on our phenomenological experiences as related to and always being with others.It attends to the other as the center of concern.This new movement has been taken up in education, mostly to re-envision teachers' relations and responsibilities to students.The questions often asked are "How do we act toward our students?How do we come to their calling?What is it in the pedagogical relation that compels us, as teachers, to continue to 'reach out'?" 5 I argue in this essay that we should not forget the other part of our job: not only are there ethical elements in the way we act toward students, but we are also educating students who are emergent and will be full-fledged moral and ethical citizens.We teach ethics, expect them to act ethically, and provide rationalization, conceptualization, and motivation for ethical behaviors.How are we to do this job in the current atmosphere of ethical discourse?Is the new ethical approach relevant here?This essay attempts to answer these questions by looking at two prominent theories of the new ethics: Nel Noddings's ethics of caring and Levinas's ethics as the first philosophy.Noddings's ethics of caring is not typically characterized by her ontological analysis of a relational self.Only through scattered statements does it become clear that she defines humans as ontologically related to others."Relation will be taken as ontologically basic." 6"I am not naturally alone.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Guoping Zhao (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: