Does a restrictive left ventricular filling pattern predict worse clinical outcomes in very old patients with congestive heart failure?
A restrictive diastolic filling pattern on echocardiography identifies very old CHF patients at higher risk for symptomatic recurrences.
OBJECTIVES: In certain younger patients with congestive heart failure (CHF), Doppler/echocardiography has identified a "restrictive" pattern of early diastolic ventricular filling characterized by very rapid early filling and a steep deceleration slope. We asked whether a similar restrictive pattern can be identified in very old patients with CHF, and if so, what are its clinical correlates and prognostic implications. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort with prospective follow-up. SETTING: Academic long-term care facility. PARTICIPANTS: Thirty-nine residents with clinical CHF (age 89 +/- 5 (SD) years) MEASUREMENTS: Transmitral Doppler flow, clinical characteristics, recurrent CHF episodes, hospitalizations, and mortality were measured. RESULTS: Fifteen (38%) of the subjects had restrictive filling patterns, characterized by a ratio of early to late flow (E/A) > 1.00 and 24 (62%) had nonrestrictive patterns. The restrictive pattern was associated with a longer duration of CHF, more angina, and higher rate of symptomatic recurrences of CHF. CONCLUSION: A restrictive diastolic filling pattern may represent a late stage in the evolution of congestive heart failure when left ventricular filling pressure is markedly increased. The treatment of CHF in older patients may need to account for different patterns of diastolic filling.
Lipsitz et al. (1996) studied this question.