Why the study?
How do selective versus nonselective beta-blockers affect catecholamine and cardiovascular responses to hypoglycemia in hyperthyroid patients?
How do selective versus nonselective beta-blockers affect catecholamine and cardiovascular responses to hypoglycemia in hyperthyroid patients?
Nonselective beta-blockade with propranolol, unlike selective beta-1 blockade with metoprolol, blocks hypoglycemia-induced tachycardia and increases blood pressure in hyperthyroid patients due to unopposed alpha-adrenergic tone.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Nonselective beta-blockade may blunt tachycardia and raise BP during hypoglycemia in hyperthyroid patients; leaves open selective preference pending randomized data.
Hypoglycemia normally promotes increases in plasma epinephrine (E) and norepinephrine (NE), tachycardia, and a widened pulse pressure; these responses can be modified by β-adrenoceptor-blocking agents. We assessed the catechola-mine and cardiovascular responses to a standard insulin tolerance test in 18 hyperthyroid patients before and during treatment with selective β-l (metoprolol; n = 9) or nonselective (propranolol; n = 9) β-blocking agents. During hypoglycemia, metoprolol as well as propranolol treatment caused an augmented increase in plasma E, while the increase in NE remained unaltered during β-blockade compared to pretreatment changes. Treatment with metoprolol reduced the supine basal heart rate (HR), although the HR rose significantly during hypoglycemia. Blood pressure (BP) changes were similar to pretreatment values. Propranolol not only lowered basal HR but also totally blocked hypoglycemia-induced tachycardia. Compared to pre-treatment, an increase in diastolic BP and a further rise in systolic BP were recorded. Eleven subjects were reexamined when they were made eu-thyroid by conventional antithyroid therapy. During hypogly-cemia, NE concentrations reached a similar maximum value in the hyperthyroid and euthyroid states, although basal concentrations were lower during hyperthyroidism. No differences were seen between plasma levels of E, and the cardiovascular changes were similar in hyper- and euthyroidism, except for lower basal diastolic BP in hyperthyroidism. Our data demonstrate that stress-induced increases in plasma catecholamines are not suppressed in hyperthyroidism. During β-adrenoceptor blockade, hypoglycemia provokes an enhanced response in plasma E. This increment in plasma E induces changes in the cardiovascular response which are quite different during selective β-l or nonselective β-blockade. The difference is probably due to a coexisting and unopposed change in the a-adrenergic tone during nonselective β-blockade. (J Clin Endo-crinol Metab50: 906, 1980)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nilsson et al. (1980) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: