Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
24 Field Trip Prakash Kumar, Projit Bihari Mukharji, and Amit Prasad Decolonizing Science in Asia The Summer Institute on “Decolonizing Science in Asia” (June 13– 17, 2016) at the Pennsylvania State University engaged substantive concerns about the place of Asia- focused works within science and technology studies (STS), which has its primary moorings in the so- called West. Contesting the claims of science as universal knowledge, the participants extended the project of decentering the studies of Asian science, technology, and medicine (STM) through multiple exercises in empirical experimentation. From interrogating “objects” to unraveling the “making of subjects,” or through examining the geopolitics and biopolitics in diverse areas of research, the institute gave representation to a new wave of scholarship that is no longer satisfied by adorning soft multiculturalism or by simplistically acknowledging the West-centrism of STS analyses that are tethered to European intellectual traditions. Rather, these scholars showcased the relevance of intellectual traditions in Asia toward revisionist purposes, applied new methods that area studies scholars have perfected over the last several decades, and showed a sensitivity to incorporating Asia-centered concerns in scholarly examinations of science and technology. Our main concern at the Summer Institute was to critically interrogate the very categories that imbue historiographic and sociological meaning to the phrase that constituted the title and focus of the institute. If the meaning(s) and reference(s) of the terms decolonizing, science, and Asia are not carefully deconstructed, then, advertently or inadvertently, our concerns can remain circumscribed by the very Euro/West- centric categories that we seek to transgress and move beyond. In that regard, our aim was also not to simplistically reverse the dominant categories and Field Trip 25 thereby celebrate the resurgence of the “other.” The institute, thus, could be seen as challenging notions of scientific frontiers, contesting the most ubiquitous way frontiers are invoked today: as promoting a false binary of core European knowledge and marginal Asian borderlands into which triumphant civilization advanced. To do so, the institute took up the task of deconstructing and unraveling the genealogies of the categories through which we understand knowledge transmission and the way science is practiced on the “margins” of science history. Two counterhistoriographical positions have dominated the approach of Asian STM scholars— one that highlights the cultural contributions of Asian knowledges to modern science and another that showcases the supremely active process of appropriation of Western science in Asia (Raj 2013). The institute reckoned both of these approaches as inadequate and the very acknowledgment of one modern science as an outcome alloyed with Europe’s world dominance. Then, calling for “decolonization” as a historiographical and methodological stand, the institute sought alternative Asian spaces and platforms for knowledge making and aligned the understanding of scientific knowledge and practice to the multiplicity of the Asian experience. The institute participants in their multiple works framed particular histories of STM as anything but simple, exemplifications of the “one” modern science. The Summer Institute opened by taking the theme of the workshop as its brief, even as the participants agreed that there was no predetermined closure on the terms of the debate or on definitional aspects of what is “decolonizing,” “science,” and “Asia.” Participants also acknowledged that presenting any kind of predetermined closure on these terms would reflect the same Orientalist and colonialist strategies that the institute was seeking to move beyond. We certainly did not wish to present another exclusive and universal definition of science, Asia, or, for that matter, the term colonial. Instead, we decided to put these terms under a critical spotlight and unravel their multilayered entanglements and articulations, including in the present context. After sorting out the problematic in all of its dimensions, the participants moved to consider the available and appropriate routes to resolve relevant theoretical and conceptual conundrums around the institute theme, asking, for instance, what is the project of decolonizing? What are the best ways to accomplish this goal in a geographically focused study of science? The latter two questions fundamentally served as the framing device for the institute’s proceedings. The framing and critical interrogation of these two questions led us to deconstruct the constitutive terms on which we focused, 26 Field Trip namely, decolonizing...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kumar et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: