Key result
The authors identified the top 20 'game changer' publications in anesthesiology that have had a profound and lasting impact on clinical practice.
This article identifies and summarizes the 20 most transformative publications in the history of anesthesiology.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Provides a historical reference list for anesthesiology education; leaves open which papers warrant updated scrutiny today.
Of the thousands of published articles related to the specialty of anesthesiology, only an elite few can be considered seminal, landmark or, for the purposes of this article, a “game changer.” A clinical game changer is a publication that results in a revolutionary transformation that has been maintained in clinical practice since the article first appeared. Advancements and discoveries in anesthesiology did lead to transformative changes, not only in this specialty but also to related fields. These contributions have in common the unique ability of the creative mind to perceive connections where others see none. They follow Louis Pasteur’s dictum “In the fields of observation, chance favors only the well-prepared mind.” The modern version of this statement is “connecting the dots.” Deciding which of these writings has had the most profound effect on the practice of anesthesiology and medicine is a challenging task, albeit subjective. Various methods have been used to identify these papers, including number of citations, opinions of journal editors, and use of an “expert” board. Using specified criteria, we chose the top 20 publications that, in our opinion, are the clinical game changers for the specialty of anesthesiology. Three recent publications are recommended to the reader for further in-depth analysis.1–3 METHODS Initially, based on the authors’ experience, a large group of articles was selected (approximately 400). Additional bibliographic research and personal communication with physicians expert in a given knowledge area were also undertaken, and additional publications were identified. The academic rank of these 67 individuals include: 47 professors, 10 associate professors, 5 assistant professors, and 5 others; of which 10 were not faculty at U. S. medical centers. Our selection criteria included: (1) articles published in the medical literature regardless of age; (2) articles in English, or a publication where an English translation is available; (3) 4 types of publications were considered: original scientific publications, case reports, review articles, and abstracts; (4) publications were selected based on their lasting impact on clinical practice in anesthesiology. Exclusion criteria included: (1) reports involving animal studies and (2) a copy of the scientific publication was unavailable. Using the resources of the Wood Library-Museum of Anesthesiology, and the Cushing/Whitney Medical Library at Yale University, publications were gathered, read, and evaluated. Based on these factors and the authors’ judgment, this methodology resulted in a final list of the 20 most important publications. RESULTS The results demonstrate the wide contributions of the specialty of anesthesiology to the field of medicine. Although not selected for any “political” agenda, the chosen publications reflect major themes: (1) innovation and creativity, (2) combating prejudicial practices (gender, racial, and religious), (3) public health, (4) bioethics, (5) patient safety, and (6) reduction of medical costs. In many cases, these articles were published in premier, high-impact journals (both U.S. and international) and in both medical and surgical, as well as anesthesia, journals. The selected articles cover a range of publication dates from 1846 through 1987. Finally, although not chosen by anesthesia subspecialty, the major subspecialties are represented. Each article is ranked on the list in order of its importance, with those having the greatest impact listed first, by its original citation and a short paragraph concerning its uniqueness. A summary table is included (Table 1) which lists the Game Changers as well as the leading “contender article” that was not chosen for the primary list.Table 1: Game Changer Articles and Their “Contenders”1. Bigelow HJ. Insensibility during surgical operations produced by inhalation. Boston Med Surg J 1846;35:309–17 The greatest contribution of American medicine to mankind is the discovery and application of anesthesia. On the occasion of the 200th anniversary of the New England Journal of Medicine, Dr. Atul Gawande wrote, “the crucial spark of transformation – the moment that changed not just the future of surgery but medicine as a whole – was the publication on November 18, 1846, of Henry Jacob Bigelow’s groundbreaking report “Insensibility during Surgical Operations Produced by Inhalation.”4 Interestingly enough, compared to the most widely cited article (14,556) from the New England Journal of Medicine,5,a the Bigelow article may seem inconsequential (179 citations).b Yet the readership voted the Bigelow article as the most important article the New England Journal of Medicine ever published.c Even today, debate continues as to whom credit should be given for the discovery of anesthesia. The United States Congress awarded Georgia physician Dr. Crawford Long the honor, along with a postage stamp bearing his picture. The French scientific academy (Academie des Sciences) awarded both Dr. William Morton and Dr. Charles Jackson the recognition. However, the Medical Society of Paris gave Dr. Horace Wells the honor.6 Interestingly, The Ether Monument in the Boston Public Garden does not recognize any of the protagonists, rather it is to commemorate “… the greatest medical discovery of our time:” the first public demonstration of ether at the Massachusetts General Hospital.7 As an interesting sidebar to the entire saga, Dr. Frank Boland hypothesizes that Dr. Charles Jackson, a geologist as well as the physician who told Morton of ether’s properties, may have actually traveled to Jefferson, Georgia, on a mining survey.8 There, he may have observed Dr. Crawford Long administering ether anesthesia before giving the idea to Morton about its potential use as an anesthetic. Finally, perhaps none of these individuals should be given credit. Rather, William Edward Clarke, an upstate New York medical school student who had experience with ether from “ether frolics,” administered an anesthetic to a Miss Hobbie for a dental extraction in January 1842.1 This was 2 months before Crawford Long, who also attended ether frolics, gave an anesthetic to James Venable (March 1842) and 4½ years before Morton anesthetized Edward Abbott at the Massachusetts General Hospital (October 1846).1 These different dates of administration of ether (combined with Horace Wells’ use of nitrous oxide [December 1844]) are at the core of the debate as to which individual(s) merits priority for administering the first anesthetic. Dr. William Osler, the esteemed Johns Hopkins Professor of Medicine, addressed this problem by quoting Sir Francis Darwin: “…in science the credit goes to the man who convinces the world, not to the man to whom the idea first occurs.”9 2. Koller C. Ueber die verwendung des cocain zu anasthesirung am auge. Wien Med Wochensehr 1884;43:1276–8 Koller C. Ueber die verwendung des cocain zur anasthesirung am auge. Wien Med Wochensehr 1884; 44:1309–11 Koller C. On the use of cocaine for producing anaesthesia on the eye. Lancet 1884;124:990–2 Koller’s discovery of the anesthetic properties of cocaine is the classic example of connecting the dots. Well known by the Inca Indians for centuries, if not millennia, cocaine was successfully used for neurosurgical procedures (trepanation). Furthermore, the anesthetic properties of cocaine were also well known to contemporaries of Koller, including Sigmund Freud, but no one thought of using the compound as a local anesthetic for surgery. It took Koller, an ophthalmologic trainee, to realize the importance of the compound as an alternative to general anesthesia. Koller had a colleague present his findings at a scientific conference. It is unclear whether this was a result of his inability to secure funds for the meeting or antisemitism.10 This discovery completed the triad of techniques of contemporary anesthesia: inhaled, IV, and local anesthesia. The original report in German is cited, as well as the contemporaneous translation in Lancet by JN Bloom, MD. 3. Cushing H. On routine determinations of arterial tension in operating room and clinic. Boston Med Surg J 1903;148:250–6 As a result of investigation into anesthetic complications by fourth-year medical students Harvey Cushing and Ernest Codman, the anesthesia record was developed.11–13 Even modern electronic medical records and computerized displays of anesthesia machines and monitors rely on their pioneering graphic design. As originally devised, heart rate and respirations were recorded every 5 minutes. However, it was not until Cushing, on a tour of European medical centers, saw the use of the Riva-Rocci method of measuring arterial blood pressure that this variable was incorporated into the intraoperative measurements made on his patients. This was met with opposition from the Harvard faculty, who thought a “finger on the pulse” was more accurate and “natural.”11–13 4. Saklad M. Grading of patients for surgical procedures. Anesthesiology 1941;2:281–4 The use of the American Society of Anesthesiologists’ Physical Status (ASA PS) classification system is not only used in operating rooms around the world, but it has been adopted and refined by other specialties for their unique patient populations. It was originally designed as a method to collect and tabulate statistical data and allow investigators to compare various patient groups. Interestingly, the original ASA PS did not even use 1 patient to test this theory. However, with little modification it has evolved into the most widely used assessment of perioperative patient risk and compares favorably to other more complex systems of risk appraisal.14,15 5. MacEwen W. Clinical observations on the introduction of tracheal tubes by the mouth instead of performing tracheotomy or laryngotomy. Brit Med J 1880;2:163–5 Jackson C. The technique of insertion of intratracheal insufflation tubes. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1913;17:507–9 Guedel AE, Waters RM. A new intratracheal catheter. Anesth Analg 1928;7:238–9 Game changer #5 required 3 interrelated but separate publications to enhance the intrinsic value of advances in airway management. Each step was required to develop techniques of endotracheal intubation: (1) direct oral introduction of an endotracheal tube, (2) use laryngoscopy to place the endotracheal tube per os, and (3) the cuffed endotracheal tube to allow for an “airtight fit.” This is the only selection on the list that is by necessity composed of >1 article. Before MacEwen’s paper, patients’ tracheas were intubated via a tracheostomy or cricothyroidotomy, a procedure associated with its own intrinsic morbidity and mortality. Although laryngoscopes were in use, it was Chevalier Jackson who popularized a laryngoscope that forms the basis of the modern instrument and advanced the technique for endotracheal intubation. Subsequently, Guedel and Waters developed a technique to attach an inflatable cuff to the endotracheal tube. To demonstrate the successful isolation of the trachea, they used an anesthetized dog (Guedel’s family pet, Airway) submerged in a fish tank (the “dunked dog”), whose trachea was intubated with a cuffed endotracheal tube.1 The dog was included in the case series report along with data from 2 patients! 6. Wood A. On a new method of treating neuralgia by the direct application of opiates to the painful points. Edinb J Med Surg 1855;82:265–81 Three individuals have been given credit for the development of the hypodermic syringe-needle system. Irish physician Dr. Francis Rynd created the hollow needle to treat neuralgias (1845), and French physician Gabriel Pravaz developed the syringe for perineural injections (1853).1 However, historians give Alexander Wood the credit for perfecting this delivery system for clinical use. Using the syringe-needle system, Wood treated a patient with neuralgias. The hypodermic syringe-hollow needle system offered physicians an alternative to inhaled anesthesia. However, it was not until the next century that IV anesthesia evolved and anesthesiologists had a multitude of drugs from which to choose. 7. Simpson JY. Notes on the employment of the inhalation of sulphuric ether in the practice of midwifery. Monthly J Med Sci 1847;7:721–8 Reminiscent of religious and medical debates that continue today, Simpson’s actions in 19th century Scotland, in anesthetizing a parturient for cephalopelvic disproportion, unleashed a torrent of verbal abuse. The medical community’s arguments (pain is important in following labor; it was not natural to have childbirth anesthesia, etc.) were in some ways easier for Simpson to deflect. It was the religious orthodoxy that was more problematic. The issue focused on Genesis III: 16 Unto the woman He said: “I will greatly multiply thy pain and thy travail; in pain thou shalt bring forth children; and they desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee.” The concern for God’s admonition to women is based on the translation of the Hebrew word “Etsev,” which has a number of meanings depending on the context (mental anguish, travail, sorrow, pain, and work).16 Most modern biblical scholars do not use the word “pain” but rather “labor.” It took John Snow’s anesthetizing Queen Victoria, 6 years later for her delivery, for the use of anesthesia for childbirth to gain acceptance. 8. Anand KJ, Hickey PR. Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus. N Engl J Med 1987;317:1321–9 This review article shares important elements with another review article on the game changer list. Similar to Beecher’s bioethical concerns (Game Changer #9), Anand and Hickey set forth the idea, “that humane considerations should apply as forcefully to the care of neonates and young, nonverbal infants as they do to children and adults in similar painful and stressful situations.” This review changed perioperative care of the neonate more than any other scientific contribution. 9. Beecher HK. Ethics and clinical research. N Engl J Med 1966;274:1354–60 This article is considered the most important clinical bioethical research article published in the modern era. It came at a time when Nazi war crimes were too familiar and ethical issues were being raised as a result of clinical research in this country.17–20 These acts, coupled with a significant governmental clinical research initiative, led Beecher to outline the abuses seen in medical studies and a proposed solution to end them. He states, “Nonetheless, it is evident that in many of the examples presented, the investigators have risked the health or the life of their subjects.” His words are as prescient today as they were more than a half-century ago when he stated that 2 fundamental requirements for clinical research are informed consent and an “intelligent, informed, conscientious, compassionate responsible investigator.” For example, the current debate on the ethics of the multicenter, National Institutes of Health-funded Surfactant, Positive Pressure and Oxygenation, Randomized Trial (SUPPORT) involving premature infants exposed to differing levels of oxygen concentration hinges on the 2 issues Beecher enunciated.21 The Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Human Research Protections questioned both the quality of informed consent and the adequacy of the investigators’ explanation as to whether parents were fully informed as to the consequences of enrolling their children in the study. In response to these criticisms, both the editor of the New England Journal of Medicine and the Director of the National Institutes of Health questioned this report and were concerned about its negative effect on future clinical research in this population.22,23 10. Eichhorn JH, Cooper JB, Cullen DJ, Maier WR, Philip JH, Seeman RG. Standards for patient monitoring during anesthesia at Harvard Medical School. JAMA 1986;256:1017–20 Under the leadership of ASA President Ellison “Jeep” Pierce, organized anesthesia had to confront a burgeoning malpractice crisis, and thus began the modern patient safety movement. Although a number of articles from this era can be considered game changers, this article by Eichhorn and colleagues at Harvard Medical School brought together all the key elements of patient safety in the operating room. It was revolutionary to have a detailed standard, not a guideline, for clinical management that was practical, cost-effective, and within the technical/economic reach of practitioners. Even though significant resistance to the concept of patient safety and standards resulted, this paper is an extension of the concept that a single person (Pierce) with a vision can instigate change, affecting millions of people. These standards were eventually adapted in the United States, as well as numerous other countries. 11. Waters RM, Hathaway HR, Cassels WH. The relation of anesthesiology to medical education. JAMA 1939;112:1667–71 Dr. Ralph Waters made a number of seminal contributions to the specialty. His most important was the establishment of the first American academic anesthesia department at the University of Wisconsin. Not only did he organize the department, he was also responsible for producing more future chairs of major academic anesthesia departments than any other individual. Waters this article by a core value of academic anesthesia patient the of together with the department of anesthesia, a natural of many science and clinical of nitrous oxide and of on the concentration of required for anesthesia. Anesthesiology years in the concentration concept was by John Snow’s on the 5 of of In to a common that was a wide range of to an anesthetic this that inhaled anesthetic concentration both clinical research and clinical care in anesthesiology. It is also an important in patient safety by of patient of anesthesia. HR, The use of in general anesthesia. Anesthesiology The effects of were known to in patients during However, and were the first to use the as a to general anesthesia. Although administered in an operating room in by a German Dr. and in by an English Dr. Francis was by both physicians to of of the and research clinical experience, or administered the with to Interestingly, the “In none of our patients has been any effect on Furthermore, has not been to or in any of our These that an of was Pain by in Anesthesiology Based on animal studies with the first clinical use of in Using a the patients with pain of the being treated with Interestingly, 2 of patients had some of pain with thus the importance of measuring for the effect in This investigation set the for the investigation and use of and in clinical of of by the Med J This selection is a by the of this the 3 American in the field of and John produced no original research on the use of in clinical practice in the The contributions of and to this area from their on during Although they time to a number of are no scientific publications in this from any of these As a result of the with its for a of developed a and published a significant number of articles on his The is the original article, the in English, the for blood and J the major contributions of John is the and development of the first modern blood Based on the of and and colleagues these the and set the for the classic blood To of the as to the of the He has since is that all the credit for the but all did was and with in JAMA observed that successful both and For the A and of were known but not into a successful In this classic example of Pasteur’s dictum of connecting the the importance of the clinical results of the and it took a to these 3 into modern and response to large of in N Engl J Med Based on the experience of for patients surgical procedures for heart anesthetized with 2 of and patients with In to a unique anesthetic technique for patients the was also to patients having surgery. more this the use of other for example, the in the Anesthesiology Although used the popularized the and in this review article and developed the scientific of this specialty these with clinical They is unique in only one in the patient the the for the and later anesthetic and techniques may be used in can be based on the of the the of the and the experience of the The innovation in the delivery and of medical Med In the Dr. thought the of health care had to of an who stated that he to do to for his and his Dr. John developed the concept and the first Although surgical had been incorporated into none was from the These made both and medical contributions to health they of in medical It is that from to these the and its and over the next this is to be Furthermore, by and more as well as from the care surgery changed medical practices for and surgical patients. Dr. on the occasion of the at the meeting of the American Society of as did the that anesthesiology is at its when the observations it on the of patients we care for apply to all patients and to medicine at the articles chosen major contributions to of medical only to review the first 2 on this the discoveries of ether and to the required to important In the a number of historians have questioned the discovery of ether was by at In an even example, the local anesthetic effects of cocaine were well known for by the Inca Yet in both it took individuals as William Morton and Koller, to realize the important and clinical application of these As our list has it is the of the based on their of the contribution of a given The in the included in our compared with the list by and in their recent in the of these since was in only 3 of the articles these by not being in our we had to 2 or more for to the list and on the list. to this we have chosen not to some seminal articles involving animal although we are in 1846 public demonstration of and to the article published in we realize a number of articles have been published since this However, similar to of United States a of is required to fully the importance of an contribution. Finally, by our to articles in English translation we may have not included seminal publications in other in medicine or other these citation are also present in other 10 The of anesthesia by its important publications, the of and to the of anesthesia to and on articles, etc.) as well as etc.) to the of the of anesthesia and its importance to In the Game Changers list is of the of modern surgery not have the vision of in MD. This the the the and the the final This the the and the in this article in her personal The opinions in this article are her own and do not reflect the of the Wood Library-Museum of Anesthesiology or the American Society of the final This the the the and the the final This was MD.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barash et al. (2015) conducted a review in Anesthesiology. Historical literature review was evaluated on Identification of top 20 game changer publications. The authors identified the top 20 'game changer' publications in anesthesiology that have had a profound and lasting impact on clinical practice.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: