Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Government in the United States is deadlocked, so we are told, incapable of responding to domestic challenges or fulfilling international responsibilities. growing number of thoughtful commentators have described American government as gridlocked, stalled, incoherent, without resolve, bankrupt, rudderless, and in trouble. Divided government is the most frequently specified cause of this predicament. Constitutional reform, dedicated to bridging the separation of powers and revitalizing American political parties, is a frequently mentioned solution. ' What is the United States to do? What can it do? nation so firmly committed to the proposition that political institutions matter has little choice but to seriously consider the possibility of changing its political institutions. The failure of American political institutions to adapt to changing exigencies leads many a would-be reformer to commend the necessity of constitutional reform. A government is an organism with work to do, observed Donald Robinson (1986: 40). must be judged according to its fitness to perform the tasks we assign it. horse is fit to pull a carriage, but it cannot take a man to the moon. In other words, America is struggling to cope with late 20th century political and policy problems with antiquated, 18th century institutions. Given Robinson's analogy, we might say the Constitution has remained a horse, when what America needs is a rocket. The Constitution, so the reformers would have us believe, is at best outmoded and at worst irrelevant to most of the big problems we face as a nation (see Miller, 1978: 744). Even if accurate, the divided government critique of American politics is hardly unique. It has been made before, perhaps with the greatest authority and rigor by James Bryce in 1889. In The American Commonwealth, Bryce (1889: 293-95) provided the following assessment of interbranch relations (edited for brevity):
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mark P. Petracca (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: