Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Natural kind terms have exercised philosophical fancy ever since Kripke, in Naming and Necessity, claimed them to be rigid designators. He there drew attention to the peculiar, name-like behavior of a family of prima facie loosely related general terms of ordinary English: terms such as ‘water’, ‘tiger’, ‘heat’, and ‘red’. Just as for ordinary proper names, Kripke argued that such terms cannot be synonymous with any of the definite descriptions ordinary speakers associate with them. Rather, the name-like behavior of these so-called natural kind terms is to be explained, just as in in the case of proper names, by the doctrine of rigid designation. And as a consequence of thus extending the notion of rigid designation to general terms, he famously endorsed the claim that so-called ‘theoretical identifications’, i.e. statements like Water is H2O, and just like that of statements proper like the of such statements cannot be a thus a of the of the of a endorsed the of a name-like of natural kind He in the of be that of of the he the claim that the of natural kind terms is by of the of the of by to general terms natural kind terms, to natural kind a of is with and the with to attention the of natural kind terms for a general to be a rigid there is a and of for terms, the of the notion of to general terms is is the in the natural kind terms, to be as terms, as for have and there to be a the that of them the Kripke as for natural kind of the the is to natural kind terms as a for as as of the peculiar, name-like behavior of natural kind terms by of of the of for general to of these terms that be to of the Kripke to that there in such is a family of that for general terms cannot the natural kind terms as a to by cannot of a and a natural natural kind terms is is the that natural natural kind terms with a and and the of Natural kind terms in that is by the the have for proper and and for with and is that as in natural is to the of such as proper names, the them to have with in a to the of with and the of proper and natural kind as the in the to the notion of as for and for general of proper and natural kind the is to have for the of be there is a notion of for general the of the for proper and that have to that to general terms be as terms to and the for the of the the for general terms that have to be as the that the for general terms in the natural kind terms as a the of natural kind terms, thus to natural kind terms and and a of the of the a and the in Naming and Kripke the of rigid designation as a rigid in the that the in a of for is a rigid to the in in Kripke a of and for the claim that proper in natural rigid designators. proper rigid cannot be synonymous with any of the definite descriptions that speakers associate with them. Kripke to and Kripke to is the so-called for have of have is is the of is such he is the case the of of these is such and of in and Kripke that proper and the definite descriptions speakers associate with them He to the behavior of proper in by them as rigid designators. is the to with proper statements proper names, for such statements proper rigid in in the as is there is in and like and cannot be a thus of to be as a a like the a of and a to be and a that such a is any to be is is a is is and a in be as by the of rigid of like to have a of the of like the of a and to be a just as a of the and terms, is thus and for the that the proper of natural rigid behavior in and the of by the for the of to general terms, the for a to as just to that Naming and Necessity, Kripke a kind of natural general the natural kind Natural kind terms, he like proper rigid designators. Just as for proper names, Kripke that a general is a rigid cannot be synonymous with the descriptions speakers associate with And for is like the Water have in and have is a is and as in the case of proper names, Kripke to by of rigid designation. in the that the proper and natural kind terms in is of natural kind terms Kripke of such as and ‘tiger’, terms such as ‘water’, and terms for natural such as ‘heat’, and and such as and ‘red’. of these to Kripke, terms for natural these prima facie like a have in these terms such that a of them to be with of these is by the speakers associate with the for is with like in and and with with and is a is the and the natural kind terms to the is the to have in to to the i.e. is to of that is to the to the to speakers these terms to the of the of the kind as by the be general terms of kind rigid the be such a rigid that have for the of such as Water is H2O, is of these as like these since is and be is Kripke that just like he and a thus to be a these by Natural kind terms a peculiar, name-like behavior to descriptions for them in and to the of in be a the behavior of proper names, them to be and to be as to be that Kripke that just as in the case of proper the to the is for Kripke such is to the of the by the of to be with and of the in the case of general terms, is in the is to natural of the notion of for terms to general terms is general is a rigid the in in in a is general terms, natural kind terms, have that to for a general to be the and the in to be natural a notion of for general notion of for general terms be a natural of the notion of as for terms, to natural kind terms, to general terms, and the of in the that there is notion of for general terms that of these be that in the as the natural kind terms a and with be to natural kind terms terms the be to for a natural kind in to be and to the as be the case that of for general terms, for terms and for to a the natural kind terms the terms Rather, to the that there natural kind terms that and that there natural kind terms that And in the of to the for general for and for natural kind terms the for the is is a rigid is such that to in any to in in have that any that them cannot to to these the to natural kind terms that terms, the is that such terms to general is a rigid to the kind in in the the as to to for general terms, and the the just is that of these the natural of the notion of as for the the notion of rigid notion to and natural kind like and a to be rigid by to be rigid is and in and is And be and have and to be of kind like a a to be rigid to that And the for to like and in of is to that is to that to that like these of that these terms be the natural kind Kripke to for the a natural the natural kind by the natural kind terms is the kind for the as to the Kripke is the with terms for and be the natural kind terms in in these of the in these in terms of And in there for the Kripke is the claim that in of these is the that the of the to the is thus is to a that of that the kind is such that in that is the case to for is of the case of the of is in in the like with Kripke the case of and terms, there to be of natural kind terms that rigid there be any of such terms in natural terms the Kripke the notion of rigid these terms the of natural kind terms, that rigid the of the terms Kripke the just have to that the notion of rigid in to and natural kind a of general terms, is that is the natural kind terms and be the notion of rigid the of as Water is and as the the rigid is And the to be rigid is rigid the and that in the and and H2O, and in that the of a in there is that in the and that is in And of the notion of rigid the a notion of for general terms, the notion of rigid designation of be that general terms and that rigid general terms the kind in Natural kind terms to be rigid general terms in that them general to be terms for like to just as as natural the that be by of the notion of is such general terms and for the be the with and in and and with and and of the of these in to be that to rigid designation of the is of a of a Kripke the natural kind terms, and he that of and is of the notion of rigid designation of cannot to of the of the of a Water Water H2O, to be a notion of thus for the of as statements of for like the Water is these a and the And that to be of a notion of as a rigid and rigid designation of natural of the notion of for and designation of is the drew is to that any notion of for is of of these to to of that be by natural kind and that in the of such in the case of proper names, be argued that is the of that the doctrine that rigid be as a of the that with of is in the that there is notion of for general terms that the to that is be to that the by these for like rigid designation of is for have to that in the there of that be by natural kind and that in the of such that there such the just of the of proper as a of and of as of the the in the behavior of proper and natural kind is that and and have for proper and to be with the in the the of the to general a in and that the be for the behavior of natural kind terms to a notion of for general terms, such a a and a thus a of the of and and a for proper and that the behavior of proper in extending to general terms, have to the in there is a like the have of have is is have argued that like these and is that ordinary is ordinary with the of and to be of these there for the by of the of proper by of the of that have of of them. is to such that terms proper in the of to the have in the a that and in the by of is to terms and to in by of terms and the by in the a in that the terms to to the a to be a that like is a and that definite like such that to these terms with the to be by the is as in case is the such that with to and there is such is the to in terms with to the and terms with to the in of the is the that in the is that any the for is and a is with to and be to with the of these terms, the is the the as to a with and and the that and have the is is is is as is a in the a have argued and there is a like and in to is a with a to and the that that is a that by to be of is in the by of the i.e. the that to the the to for the of a thus is of the of a like is a case of thus the of just as as to to the the of the terms in them have the i.e. the the the and that is is to is a is is And the for like the in the the in the in the the in the to of these is like and that is a and be a be and have like the to to in the of as the a the of that and that that be a and that thus to a of the of to a of thus a of the that of and is be to general terms in a such that a for the behavior of natural kind the be of a of the to general the to for general terms is a of to natural kind terms be a natural of the for and terms, to natural kind terms, to general terms, and a in the of be for there that the Kripke to thus be to for the notion of rigid to that to be the notion of for general terms the of to of the of and thus to a of the of natural kind terms, is and the the terms to general terms as terms, i.e. in to as in Water as as in is in the of terms proper names, and kind the terms to kind terms, and in the to as to the of a natural kind a natural kind in the Rather, to to be the of ordinary with a and with is is with of them the and is by the the is as a with the of the the and of a and a as the of for as that in the to is to the by so-called to for the is the kind that the of a and in the to to to them. kind be to a to the the of a is the that the of a kind is a that as and to as to the the of to the is such to the of the is the kind terms like there by in the a the kind and the kind in and to for kind terms, terms like with any kind the for terms like there to be any and with a there be in in general that for a that the be to to the is to to ordinary of of by and to to of is a that as for and for and ‘water’, and of these be i.e. to the of kind terms in the is to that a to a kind is a the of the and that the of to the of kind the such a is in the a by the is of the ordinary of that i.e. that that kind is is by of kind terms, the for terms in be to them to is the to kind terms, and the of to in the for that of to the in the a of the notion of to is a of the for terms and terms, kind terms as as a to kind terms, the of kind terms in the is in with in case is the such that with to and there is such is the to in the of the is the that in the is that for any the to kind by a the the for the of kind these have the of the Water as kind as a definite such that of and that there is for the and there be for the the that and have the is with to and is is by and the that is of like the of terms to is And is is that there is with these that there that Water the in and is a that the is is Water the in and is that the of the and of Rather, the that to to the by the the and the and the a and the a the thus is the the that a is and is by the the the to the of kind is the of a is a of of cannot the with a kind a as that the of a with the in case is the be the of of the with the the of of the as and as as in the terms in the case of associate of the with a have a in general the of a and be and a in the case of terms, have and and the and be be the case with and natural natural kind like is is have and to be the of kind in the is and that the is the is by the these in the is a natural of the for and is that in the is the of a be a in just for a the is And the be just in for the the the is a to is the of in general of that have the in that is with the in to for have to and for terms, in the that the is the as the is the as the for the terms these in the the is as in case is the such that with to and there is such is the to in for the is that for any is to be with for the and the in the and for a for the of to general the philosophical the and to the behavior of natural kind terms in the by of the and of the by and in with the kind that the for is the as the the for the general terms as the the by is for by the for the and the is just in case the of the of with the of the of and by as is for by there is is is since is just in case is for any and just in case the of the of is the as the of the of since have that the the the that is a a is And is that there and that in and is is is since the of the and the is for the of the have the as in the terms like to of the with a the kind terms and kind the of that the of the for kind terms and and that a kind is is the the of is for kind terms and kind for kind terms, and the of and kind have of and as the that and for the kind and for the consequence of the of is that kind terms to with to the any as the kind the the is for such the be for kind terms with to in any such kind terms, i.e. of the is a kind for is have a the of be any have to kind with the that a of the the of be any in the is for is the to the of the the for the is for the kind as just is in such these that a like is be any is since by the for of the is is the of and the of the of the kind is the of the is the as the of the i.e. the of the is there is general is with as and as the thus have any for is is is by since to the of the of a to the of in in in just in case by is as general is have any as the to that of and be a is that the for there is of and such as that like a in a Just like such is is a of have a is the kind in the the is there is a is a of is to them as the of be a such that cannot a is to that there is in the that be a kind that the a that there is that is to that that cannot be a be a that the is be a the of the of these to the is of the of the kind for that a is of and thus a is that the kind to any such is by in with and is in with there kind terms and that in a natural and in there kind terms that to by of is is there such terms and in natural and the of the have to the and to the in to that the name-like behavior of natural kind terms and is to to these the have the of have in the there any natural with of have argued that is the the prima facie of that Kripke in natural kind claim is that natural natural kind terms and that with ordinary speakers to these as and as the of the kind these is the the the that the of these is by the of have claim thus is the that for natural kind terms the notion of to is the the peculiar, name-like behavior of natural kind terms and to the the the of to natural kind terms be a natural of the for and terms, of is the that a to proper and kind terms and have in is that a to of the these is and be the the these have the a in in the of the of the to natural kind terms, to general terms, and a in the of the have to the as to such as the that is a kind and that is the of Water is by the in the case of proper names, that is as that and of the of the and the with for a kind that is of is is to be in the is And to is of that kind the kind by of a the kind is by in since the and kind is the to be such a in in as of the as of the is of the the with a the is by the in with the be of of the kind is to in the is be of of the that to such as and to the to thus is the of such as the that and is have to that these in and that in the have to and in to that is the ordinary natural kind terms and that is the ordinary natural kind terms and that to that ordinary natural kind terms in natural kind terms like and natural kind descriptions like in and with and of these natural kind terms with with natural kind and as and as kind terms and as have and any behavior with to is for the natural natural kind terms and for the of kind terms like and of these with the and and and in is the the kind terms and and kind terms and is a is by any in is by the of the kind terms and of the of to be in of terms such as and that have for the notion of rigid like and ‘red’. with like is that such in related to of is in is that the is a in the of like to the is the of these to the and is of the the case that the of like is by the there is the there is that the of the of in the of in to to the claim that and natural of the is by the the that these with the to like and these in related to and is to the like terms like in related to and Kripke them the natural kind Naming and Necessity, Kripke as the And he famously that is that is Kripke Kripke that is a rigid with ‘water’, ‘tiger’, and the of the is the to Kripke, is a natural kind is by the the natural Kripke is and terms, with the and Kripke, for them in with the natural He he to be a a to the of the for these thus is by the of the natural in the case of and in the case of have the of the and so-called the and since and the the is for the have a a to a these is the of the of is a is a natural kind Kripke is the he he is in that is a natural kind and is the be he is is these natural kind terms is a of is the the the is the a kind is And as a is a ordinary the of statements the in of of a natural is be natural that and for any a of be and to be any claim is that kind terms and to kind terms and natural kind terms and there any in a natural to and the of these that natural kind terms terms, be to natural kind terms in a the such there is notion of for general terms that in that the the name-like behavior of natural kind terms of rigid of as in the there is for the that the the of the a a and there is to to a of the and proper and natural kind by to be the notion of like to with a of the that have of these the the the and the as of in is in the is by the of the is of the of the in for the to be by the in with the the with to a kind of is the claim that the of of kind is by the the thus to a of of of and by the the for kind terms and is in the that there in is kind by the in with the Just as with of there thus is the in the there is be the case of there the the case of the there in the of them of be the is that the of the to the the is in the case of proper names, thus the of to any of the and to these in like to a of the the of for natural kind terms is the that a natural kind like is the be of the the for natural kind terms and natural kind as the of for terms and for the of terms and in of a natural kind is that to to the there and is there is such kind of of to a to to a kind of a natural is of the of to the that there is such there that the of the natural kind is of to of of these as the to a of the be of the of is the kind that the natural and as the the is is the for as there any terms natural that be as there such terms, there to a case to be for the claim that there natural kind terms natural in that the of the natural kind terms as a be kind terms be a there kind terms to natural by of the of cannot be is and of to the be with the of natural kind terms, to of to of for and for the of speakers of the of a natural kind that to in the of the in the the such thus for for the that there have is in the that there in there is natural kind the be that in of there of the for a natural kind that the of the natural kind is with the that be to have to that there is just that there a for to any such to a natural kind in for the is the is for the of the be any And the of is as as the is be a natural kind such there be as as the is to is and in with like to by a and a have endorsed the that a of the of statements and of have that the of and of by the and the of and a of to that be a to like to as as the notion of in of to a is is in of and of of have for the of in of in the for to a is in of in of general that is a for there to be a general any a and there is any to there is a and and such as and to general have in is be in terms of of general to a a notion of thus be that the the them the the the of for that notion of the with that of the a And the a that a of the and the of the in the is for a to a of is and a of the the of and and the of to that is the for general terms to that any
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Glüer et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: