Key result
Single-molecule and muscle mechanics data align on cross-bridge force but conflict on elasticity mechanisms.
While single-molecule mechanics and muscle mechanics data largely agree on basic cross-bridge parameters, they conflict on specific mechanistic details like whether force generation has sub-strokes and if elasticity is Hookean.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports single-molecule models for muscle mechanics; leaves open elasticity and force-generation mechanisms for resolution.
In muscle, but not in single-molecule mechanics studies, actin, myosin and accessory proteins are incorporated into a highly ordered myofilament lattice. In view of this difference we compare results from single-molecule studies and muscle mechanics and analyze to what degree data from the two types of studies agree with each other. There is reasonable correspondence in estimates of the cross-bridge power-stroke distance (7⁻13 nm), cross-bridge stiffness (~2 pN/nm) and average isometric force per cross-bridge (6⁻9 pN). Furthermore, models defined on the basis of single-molecule mechanics and solution biochemistry give good fits to experimental data from muscle. This suggests that the ordered myofilament lattice, accessory proteins and emergent effects of the sarcomere organization have only minor modulatory roles. However, such factors may be of greater importance under e.g., disease conditions. We also identify areas where single-molecule and muscle data are conflicting: (1) whether force generation is an Eyring or Kramers process with just one major power-stroke or several sub-strokes; (2) whether the myofilaments and the cross-bridges have Hookean or non-linear elasticity; (3) if individual myosin heads slip between actin sites under certain conditions, e.g., in lengthening; or (4) if the two heads of myosin cooperate.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Månsson et al. (2018) conducted a review in Muscle contraction (basic science). Single-molecule mechanics studies vs. Muscle mechanics studies was evaluated on Cross-bridge parameters (power-stroke distance, stiffness, isometric force). Single-molecule studies and muscle mechanics show reasonable correspondence in cross-bridge power-stroke distance (7-13 nm), stiffness (~2 pN/nm), and isometric force (6-9 pN), but conflict on elasticity and force generation processes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: