Key result
A discontinuous graded exercise testing protocol did not significantly alter VO2peak compared to a continuous protocol in resistance-trained or endurance-trained males.
Why the study?
Traditional continuous graded exercise testing may poorly reflect VO2max in resistance-trained athletes due to unfamiliarity, whereas discontinuous protocols might provide a more valid assessment.
Does a discontinuous modified Bruce protocol improve VO2peak compared to a continuous Bruce protocol in resistance-trained and endurance-trained males?
RCT (n=19)
Randomized crossover
No
Does a discontinuous modified Bruce protocol improve VO2peak compared to a continuous Bruce protocol in resistance-trained and endurance-trained males?
A discontinuous graded exercise test protocol with 10-minute rest periods does not yield higher VO2peak values than a continuous protocol in either resistance-trained or endurance-trained males.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Discontinuous protocols yield equivalent VO2peak to continuous testing in trained males; leaves open optimal protocols for untrained or clinical populations.
International Journal of Exercise Science 15(4): 414-422, 2022. Traditional graded exercise testing to assess maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) may not well represent resistance-trained athletes due to their unfamiliarity with continuous exercise. For this reason, it is possible discontinuous exercise protocols may better represent the maximum capacity for aerobic metabolism in resistance-trained athletes, in order to provide a more valid assessment of VO2max and risk of developing cardiovascular disease. Purpose: The purpose of this experiment was to compare VO2peak during a continuous and discontinuous modified Bruce protocol in both highly resistance-trained and endurance-trained males. Methods: 19 college-aged males (age: 20.6 ± 1.9 yr, height: 176.5 ± 7.6 cm, weight: 85.0 ± 25.6 kg) of intermediate resistance- or endurance-trained status were recruited for this study. Participants completed a continuous and discontinuous modified Bruce protocol on two visits separated by seven days. Results: A 2x2 one-way ANOVA revealed a significant group main effect for VO2peak (p = 0.004) in which endurance athletes achieved significantly higher VO2peak values compared to resistance-trained athletes. A significant group main effect for RPE was found (p = 0.045) in which endurance-trained reported significantly higher RPE values than the resistance-trained. A significant main effect for protocol for heart rate (p = 0.033) was found in which individuals achieved higher heart rates during the continuous protocol compared to the discontinuous. Conclusion: Although a discontinuous protocol with rest periods between stages is comparable to the exercise mode familiar to resistance-trained athletes, it did not provide any additional benefit to VO2peak values.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shepherd et al. (2022) conducted an RCT in Healthy resistance-trained and endurance-trained males (n=19). Discontinuous modified Bruce protocol vs. Continuous Bruce protocol was evaluated on VO2peak (ml/kg/min) (p=0.748). A discontinuous graded exercise testing protocol did not significantly alter VO2peak compared to a continuous protocol in resistance-trained or endurance-trained males.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: