Key result
Among 262 complex non-vascular emergency surgical operations, 30% (78 cases) were managed by consultant surgeons working outside their elective subspecialty, mostly out of hours.
Why the study?
How often are complex emergency surgical cases treated by general surgeons working outside their own elective subspecialty?
Observational (n=1,554)
No
How often are complex emergency surgical cases treated by general surgeons working outside their own elective subspecialty?
Mismatch between subspecialist elective interests of consultant general surgeons and out-of-hours specialist major surgery occurs infrequently, mainly involving major lower gastrointestinal cases managed by upper gastrointestinal and breast surgeons.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May highlight emergency coverage gaps; leaves open effects on outcomes and optimal rostering.
BACKGROUND: The increasing subspecialization of general surgeons in their elective work may result in deskilling and create problems in providing expert care for emergency cases. To evaluate the size of the problem this study determined how often complex emergency surgical cases are treated by general surgeons working outside their own elective subspecialty. METHOD: In a district general hospital in the south of the UK serving a population of 550 000 where there is almost complete subspecialization within general surgery, 1554 patients having emergency general surgical operations were studied in a one-year review. The time an operation occurred, the seniority of the operating surgeon, the subspecialty interest of the consultant responsible for the case compared with the specialist nature of the operation was determined. RESULTS: Of 1554 patients having emergency general surgical operations, 23% (352/1554) were of a high category of complexity. Ninety were vascular procedures and were dealt with by specialist vascular surgeons on a separate rota. Of the remaining 262 operations, 78 (30%) did not match the subspecialty of the consultant surgeon responsible for their care; 56 (72%) of these occurred out of hours of which 14 (18%) had a consultant surgeon present and scrubbed in the theatre; one per month of the study. Seventy-three percent (57/78) of these were complex colorectal operations. CONCLUSION: The mismatch between the subspecialist elective interests of the consultant general surgeon and out of hours specialist major surgery needing consultant involvement occurred infrequently, and was mainly due to major lower gastrointestinal cases managed by upper gastrointestinal and breast surgeons. This has important implications for the future training of general surgeons and the provision of an emergency nonvascular general surgical service.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Garner et al. (2006) conducted an observational in Emergency general surgical operations (n=1,554). Complex emergency surgical cases treated outside the consultant's elective subspecialty was evaluated on Mismatch between the subspecialty of the consultant surgeon responsible for the case and the specialist nature of the operation among complex non-vascular cases. Among 262 complex non-vascular emergency surgical operations, 30% (78 cases) were managed by consultant surgeons working outside their elective subspecialty, mostly out of hours.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: