Key result
Cardiac CT and exercise ECG stress testing both showed poor correlation with Diamond Forrester scores in patients with stable angina.
Why the study?
Does cardiac Computerized Tomography (CT) or exercise Electrocardiogram Stress Test (EST) correlate better with Diamond Forrester (DF) scores in patients with stable angina?
RCT
Does cardiac Computerized Tomography (CT) or exercise Electrocardiogram Stress Test (EST) correlate better with Diamond Forrester (DF) scores in patients with stable angina?
There is a poor correlation between Diamond Forrester scores and both anatomical (CT) and functional (EST) testing, calling into question the utility of using symptoms to drive investigations.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Symptoms poorly predict CT or EST results in stable angina; challenges reliance on Diamond-Forrester scores for test selection.
The presence of angina is a potential source of reduced quality of life and may be a predictor of adverse cardiovascular outcomes. Recent guidelines suggest that management of angina should revolve around the use of the Diamond Forrester (DF) score to determine which tests should be used for an individual patient. The choice of test can be broadly categorized into anatomical or function. Little is known about how either type of test correlates with the DF score. This study was part of a larger randomized Controlled Trial to compare the use of cardiac Computerized Tomography (CT) and exercise Electrocardiogram Stress Test (EST) in patients with stable angina. This analysis compared the results from EST and CT against the DF scores. Overall all results showed that there is a poor correlation between DF and both tests. R-squared value from the linear model showed correlation between EST and DF scores to be 0.315, with the correlation between CT and DF scores 0.415. This calls into question the useful of symptoms to drive investigations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peter McKavanagh (2016) conducted an RCT in stable angina. Cardiac Computerized Tomography (CT) vs. Exercise Electrocardiogram Stress Test (EST) was evaluated on Correlation between test results and Diamond Forrester (DF) scores. Cardiac CT and exercise ECG stress testing both showed poor correlation with Diamond Forrester scores in patients with stable angina.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: