Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Guang’an, China—Jiang Xin leaves school at 2:30 p.m. everyday. On his way home, the 8-year-old usually lingers by the rice fields with his friends for an hour or so, squatting on the edge of a dirt road, where trucks loaded with coal roar by. They play with pebbles, exchange school gossip, or punch the buttons of Jiang’s video game player, which he wrapped in tape to prevent from falling apart. Their cattle stand together in a nearby field, grazing on grass stalks.Around 3:30, the children fetch their cattle and head home. Jiang lives in a two-story shack on a small hill with his brother and grandparents. Soon after he leads the cattle into the pen and latches the gate, his grandparents return from a long day working in the fields, sometimes carrying large bundles of wood to add to their stock that already fills the upper floor of their house. Around 4 p.m., his 11-year-old brother, Jiang Heng, who goes to school in the town, trudges up the hill. The brothers are usually glued to the television until dinnertime, ignoring their grandparents’ call for them to finish their homework. “With the farm work and all, sometimes I really can’t manage them,” says Xiao Chuntao, the brothers’ 58-year-old grandmother, as she peels peanuts while watching over her grandsons, who are engrossed in the Japanese TV series “Ultraman.”Like many others in Guang’an, which means the village of “Brightness and Peace,” the Jiang family consists of empty-nest elders and left-behind children. Perched atop a mountain near the southwest boundary of the central province of Hunan, the village has a population of around 1,400. Since the early 1990s, more than half of the villagers have decamped to the cities to make a better living. When the young and able-bodied leave, their children usually remain in the care of their paternal grandparents, in many cases only months after they are born.The most recent survey from the All-China Women’s Federation found some 61 million “left-behind children” across China, who are growing up without one or both parents—a population larger than California and New York combined. Close to 33 percent are raised by their grandparents, another 10.7 percent by other villagers or relatives, and at least 2.06 million, according to the survey, are forced to fend for themselves. It is one of the darker side effects of China’s manufacturing and construction-fueled economic boom, which has created a vast number of low-skill jobs in coastal provinces, luring hundreds of millions of laborers away from their impoverished hometowns.These young migrants, who are parents of pre-school or school-aged children, face a difficult decision after relocating. If they decide to bring their children with them into the cities, urban living costs could prove debilitating given the parents’ paltry salary. A range of social and institutional hurdles prevent the children from becoming fully integrated urban citizens. At the same time, if the parents choose to leave their children in their rural hometowns, the family will have to bear years of painful separation, which often takes a physical as well as psychological toll on the young generation.Despite their backbreaking work in cities, migrants earn considerably less than urban natives. A 2011 survey by the Ministry of Human Resources shows that the average monthly salary for migrant workers was slightly over 2,000 RMB ($323), compared to the national average of 3,200 RMB ($510). These amounts already represent a significant increase from just half a decade earlier, but have been largely offset by several rounds of nationwide post-financial-crisis inflation. In cities like Shanghai and Shenzhen, where the average cost of living approaches New York City’s, migrants try to scrap by while saving every extra yuan to send home. Raising their children in such an environment, which entails extra costs for food, clothing, schooling, and other expenses, is beyond the means of many parents.Another major hurdle that discourages migrant parents from bringing their children into cities is China’s hukou, or household registration, system. Sometimes likened to China’s “internal passport,” the system ties social benefits such as health care and free education to each person’s hometown. Migrant children can only receive government subsidies on their education if they go to school near where they were born, and they have to pay prohibitively high tuition if they hope to enroll in urban schools. Furthermore, in many crowded Chinese metropolises, where a large number of local students vie for limited educational resources, some public schools simply refuse to take migrant children. Others make the enrollment standards so stringent—by demanding, for example, official documents and certificates rarely granted to migrants—that it’s virtually impossible for migrants to meet them. In Beijing alone, more than 140,000 migrant children are shut out of the public education system, according to government statistics that likely vastly underestimate the number. Some of these students find their way to private schools set up for migrants, which usually charge hefty tuition due to their lack of government subsidies, and offer only subpar education.Facing economic hardship and the hurdles posed by the hukou system, many migrant parents find migrating with their children an unrealistic option. They are left only with the difficult alternative of leaving their children behind as they depart for distant cities. These boys and girls, the so-called “left-behind children,” are thus separated from their parents in many cases from birth, and must stumble through their childhood and early teenage years without proper physical care or emotional guidance.The issue of left-behind children surged to the forefront of public attention at the end of last year when five boys, cousins aged nine to 13, were found dead in a rolling trash bin in the southwestern province of Guizhou. The likely cause of death was carbon monoxide poisoning. The children had climbed into the bin to take shelter from the cold and lit a fire inside. With their parents seeking work in the coastal regions, the youths received little adult oversight during their lives and were left to wander the streets.While the tragedy in Guizhou was an extreme case, it sparked a national discussion among Chinese citizens on the plight of migrant children, the major obstacles they face, and the long-term effects created for both these children and the society. The challenges and damaging effects of growing up as left-behind children are mostly manifested in their daily lives, as demonstrated by the experience of children in Guang’an village.In the long run, the fate of these children is increasingly uncertain. The implications of their incomplete upbringing, compounded by larger social woes such as uneven educational opportunities and widening income disparities, allow little upward social mobility, even through hard work. A slowing and transforming economy means they will less likely be able to reap the benefit of the nation’s manufacturing boom by performing low-skill jobs as their parents did. Whether China can create a caring, supportive environment for these children and help them develop into productive participants of society could test China’s ability to carry out its grand national scheme of urbanization and keep its economy thriving in the years ahead.In Guang’an it is so common for children to grow up without their parents around that both the children and their grandparents take it as a fact of life. “Kids in the countryside are not the same as those city children,” says Fan Renshu, principal of the village elementary school. “City children are too reliant on their parents. Rural kids are more independent. They are used to not having parents around.”It certainly seems to be the case with the Jiang brothers. Their parents, like most migrant workers in the village, toil in factories in nearby Guangdong province. Both work for a foreign handbag manufacturer in Shenzhen, whose brand neither of Jiang’s grandparents can name. Due to the high transportation cost—around 2,000 RMB ($318) round trip for the both of them, only slightly less than their combined monthly salaries—and their tight work schedule, the parents usually return home only once a year during the Chinese New Year, bearing bags of toys and new clothes for their sons.Last year, however, the couple made an exception. They rushed home in October, when news arrived that the grandparents were attacked by wild bees while cutting wood in the mountains. Xiao, the grandmother, with multiple stings on her head, was in critical condition. The medical bills took a huge bite out of the family’s meager savings. Fortunately, both grandparents recovered quickly. The parents didn’t stay long before they had to get back to work, but as result of the trip, they did not come home for the Chinese New Year in February. “They’ve come back twice last year already,” Jiang Heng, the elder grandson, explains matter-of-factly. “That’s too many times. It has exceeded their quota.”During the rest of the year, Jiang’s parents call home about once a month. On the phone, the brothers answer their questions in monosyllables, and spend the rest of the time reciting to them passages from their school textbooks. Asked if they remember their parents’ faces, both brothers only flash a shy smile. “My grandchildren have spent the longest time with us, so they are the closest to us,” says Jiang Zhonghan, the grandfather, with a proud smile.Most adults in Guang’an, such as Fan, do not fully realize the potential damage the experience of growing up as left-behind children can impose on the village’s next generation. After all, under Chinese family tradition, it is not uncommon for grandparents to assist parents in childrearing. Most grandparents here, like the Jiangs, look after their grandchildren with great attentiveness and love. Circumstances, however, often require them to become the primary caregivers to children, stretching the boundaries of their capacity. In many cases, such unconventional family arrangements can damage the children’s physical and psychological well-being.Despite their frailness, the grandparents in Guang’an typically take care of their grandchildren while supporting the family financially by carrying out heavy farm work. Backbreaking jobs on the village’s rice paddies or cornfields often claim the majority of grandparents’ attention during planting and harvesting seasons. As much as they hope to carry out their childrearing duties conscientiously, they find the task difficult to accomplish, and in such cases, accidents proliferate.Jiang Mi, a quiet, skinny 8-year-old girl in Guang’an, suffers from a partial hearing loss in her left ear. It was caused by an infection a few years ago, when her grandmother washed her hair and didn’t notice the water that entered her ears. Fan, the elementary school principal, recalls an accident from a neighboring village in 2009. A boy and girl fell down a well and drowned when their grandparents failed to keep a proper eye on them. In another tragedy, a boy left at home with his grandfather in a nearby county died after eating rat poison by mistake. His grandfather, overwhelmed by guilt, committed suicide soon afterward.Given the frequency of such incidents nationwide, only a small number are ever reported by the state media. When they are, like the five deaths in Guizhou, they are chilling reminders of the precarious condition in which some left-behind children live, due to lack of adult care. Even less visible to the Chinese public than the physical damage of left-behind children may be the damage on their psychological stability and character.“Grandparents usually pay more attention to the grandchildren’s physical health, making sure they have enough to eat and wear, and less to their character and morality,” says Jiang Nengjie, 27, a Guang’an resident making a documentary about left-behind children. (Most of the village members share the same family name, Jiang, but are not closely related.) “When the children reach puberty, many will suddenly turn rebellious, and then it is too late for their grandparents to try to rein them in.”Juvenile delinquency among left-behind children has become an issue of major concern. Chinese legal statistics reveal that in 2010 left-behind children comprise 70 percent of juvenile offenders. Without effective adult supervision, many turn to alcohol and drugs, while others squander their days in gambling parlors and Internet cafes. In the book Wounded Villages, Nie Mao, a professor of humanities at Central South University and an expert on left-behind children, documents several cases of such children who fell between the cracks in Chinese society. One 15-year-old boy from Hunan province broke into an apartment and murdered the owner for 300 RMB ($48) to pay for his hours in an Internet café, while his father toiled at low-paying jobs in Guangdong.“The problems in the lives of left-behind children are widespread and deep-rooted. They have the potential to lead to severe consequences through an insidious process,” writes Nie. “They don’t manifest themselves in every child, but when they do, it shows the seriousness of the situation.”Jiang Nengjie, the documentary filmmaker, has been tracking three families in Guang’an since 2009 to record their ways of coping with the absence of the middle generation in their households. During her Chinese New Year visit in 2011, Jiang Heng’s mother, Ye Haiping, confessed to Nengjie her concerns about her in-laws’ ability to supervise her sons’ education. “I’m not at home, so nobody will discipline the boys except their grandparents,” she sighed. “But the grandparents don’t understand [my sons’ schoolwork], and they get fooled every time when the boys lie to them saying they’ve finished their homework.”Xiao, the grandmother, bemoans the thin filial bond her grandsons feel toward their parents. “Nowadays, children don’t feel attached to their parents, because, well, [the parents] didn’t raise them. … There is a song called ‘Mother is the Best Person on Earth.’ I think it should in fact be ‘Grandmother is the Best Person on Earth,’” she says without a smile. Though dissatisfied with the present arrangement, neither the parents nor the grandparents see an alternative. The stark income disparity between rural and urban China makes the parents’ choice between leaving home or staying no choice at all. With their jobs in the handbag factory in Shenzhen, the parents have a combined net income of 30,000 RMB ($4,780) per year—meager given the jobs’ strict schedule and physical demands. But it still dwarfs the 8,000 RMB ($1,275) the grandparents collect annually through farming. The parents send back 500 RMB ($80) per month to support the family.Nationwide, the income gap between rural and urban China has widened to a staggering level. Incomes in urban China are more than five times the level in rural regions. This income ratio has increased 26 percent from 1997 and 68 percent since 1985. Such a disparity is driving new waves of younger migrants like Jiang’s parents into the cities every year, accelerating the urban economic engine while leaving the rural areas trailing further behind.Some parents from Guang’an have brought their children along on their migrant journey. But Jiang Zhonghan and Xiao Chuntao agree it was not an option the parents had considered. Registered under the system as rural residents in Hunan province, if Jiang Xin and Jiang Heng were to move with their parents to Shenzhen, in Guangdong province, they would be barred from attending local public elementary schools and shunted to private schools set up for migrants. The tuition for these schools, which could reach 2,000 RMB ($320) per semester, would deal a heavy blow to the parents’ modest living in the second most expensive city in mainland China, where their combined salary is only 2,500 RMB ($400) per month.One summer, Jiang Heng recalls, he and his brother visited their parents in Shenzhen during school vacation. It was the longest period of time in their memory that they had spent with their parents, but the reunion was not a peaceful one. Without time to watch over their sons and worrying about their potential misbehavior, the parents had no choice but to lock them in their tiny apartment while they toiled on the assembly lines. The brothers remember spending most of the summer crying to themselves behind a locked door.“From then on, whenever they cry, I for another send to they says Xin and Jiang Heng local schools and are in second and Jiang the village, from pre-school through second The number of students is a of over 300 in late to the result of a in that large of and young to cities. The school was a few years in a of rural elementary school and by the central The village head, Jiang to keep it It is by three Fan, the principal, is to next year, and with the salary and the school is to find a Heng goes to in a larger town, an hour and a half by from his It is the school to the Jiang family that education beyond second and where of the village elementary school are to with their education. Heng’s were when he to the but he he in his of but further if he to a in a county high school. children in Guang’an high school. Even go to The vast majority head to factories in coastal like Guangdong and after from high school at the of to the Jiang Nengjie, the filmmaker, says on a along the dirt around the rice paddies in the is one of the few in the go to school in a like is the of in a educational system, with a on in the is a social that every an to In recent most have out a number of but the schools have largely their With an number of students to the to get into the schools, has the urban parents to their children’s by private their with Most children in rural areas receive virtually no from parents, who work away and have little income to in their education. of their at school do not have themselves. The gap in the of educational between rural and urban China left-behind children with rural from educational one of the nation’s schools, around percent of its students from rural areas from to but that number has to percent in recent At as China’s rural students only percent its in while percent of the students the national that year were of rural for those rural students who their way into it’s if their will lead to a upward in their China’s in the million a As a a is its among is the case for from the less and where students to be from or rural to China’s education last year percent of students at such were the in their families to receive of these schools charge up to twice as much tuition as due to the limited subsidies they receive from the of they offer in and are often with large A large number of students find themselves to these factories work they could have without Such have an number of rural students to education. that than to high school and which it makes much more to become a migrant and making says the Jiang family is their for the brothers on education. them to well and go to high school. don’t even them to share the work in the and on the says “When and come home for Chinese New Year, them if they are from Heng in with the of a if seems less about his have to see when I grow he Though for he his is to a a among his friends that through and At Heng will face the decision about his in Most in the village have already to the on the Some the same factories where their parents have for to them through with the hope that they would have a After years of separation, the families are at long the assembly issue of left-behind children is both a of and a national concern. The Chinese economy is at a critical where the manufacturing and is while the government has its hope to turn into the nation’s next In a decade or the million left-behind children will have finished their time in the education system and will to the cities. Some will factories and But due to a number of such jobs or their will look Some among them, by their family and by may on the by drugs, and the or turn to a worrying the society is already to children of migrant workers into the city them with in China’s economic and turn them from potential social to will be among the challenges on the in the years the Chinese government has that one of its citizens will in cities. means million rural residents in the next on of the nation’s urban population of children will a significant of that the that them and their parents from in cities are the social free to them as a result of the hukou system. is where will have to and where are already recent major cities across China to their that migrant children from attending local schools. In cities such as and over percent of migrant children have been to public schools in the according to government In cities like Beijing and where the large number of migrant students makes the task of them more local have been the number of public schools that migrant children, while with a of to manage their for example, migrant children to state schools if their parents can five documents their local and Both Beijing and Shanghai are that will migrant children who middle schools to take the test for local schools. China’s manufacturing to allow students without local hukou to take the by if they have local high schools and if their parents are residents with over three years of social to the students who hope to take the will have to do so in the province where their hukou of Chinese urban about social benefits like education from hukou is the the new city population would create on urban In for local students elementary schools will from the to around in the government more migrant students on of of local students will be and it’s a that in other like Shanghai or such a more that would the education of left-behind children in the long to the economic gap between coastal areas and has been the primary for the of however, migrant are to The of cities such as and millions of migrants to find jobs without leaving their Since 2011 in the province of more workers have found jobs the province than in large cities, the of their to their means more migrants will be able to bring their children with them, and the less will be more able to them. these cities have local schools, and as a result are able to more than the way for migrant children to enroll in the local education to its economic and increase urbanization will if it’s not for its citizens to and mountain like As of millions of become urban residents each that will for to to the issue of left-behind children is to the hukou system, the central to health care and public and create more urban Such are for migrant workers to down their in of hukou and social benefits is a to but the will to be to Chinese government the cost of each migrant into an urban from long-term at around RMB urban living for of millions of migrant children and their parents will lead to a more than most local can pay out of their If China is about its urbanization the central government will have to its to bear in the years The children of migrant laborers will be to their urban until they can to go to the same schools, take the same in the same cities, and of the same
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Helen X. Gao (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: