Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Posthuman Studies Reader is not a textbook, nor a collection of research papers. My first impression on browsing through its contents is quickly confirmed by the Introduction: It is an attempt to name a field, map it, and negotiate its canon. “Naming, not to mention mapping, an academic field is a tricky proposition” writes David Silver (2006), in his seminal paper that raised the question of “Internet studies,” my home discipline, as a discipline. He uses a 1982 study suggesting that the growth of academic disciplines follows four stages. First is a pioneering stage, in which an intellectual movement is formed by a collection of “mavericks” who collect data and share ideas informally or through anecdotal publications. Next comes the elaboration stage, a period of growth marked by an increased number of scholars, and the establishing of an organization, an academic journal, as well as chapters in books, and college courses begin to appear. In the proliferation stage the community of scholars grows dramatically and becomes international and multilingual in scope, while more journals, conferences, monographs, and textbooks are published. At this stage, usually an undergraduate major is established. Finally comes the establishment stage, which is characterized by traditional markers of academic legitimacy, such as the introduction of academic departments and graduate dissertations. Publishers begin to devote series to the discipline, a proliferation of subfields occurs, and the community of scholars negotiates a canon.Silver deduced that “Internet studies” is quickly approaching disciplinary status, but other scholars disagree. Jonathan Sterne (2005), for example, invoked Foucault and Bourdieu to argue that digital media studies have not yet generated a truly novel scholarly discourse, and that the main reasons for disciplinizing are strategic. The young multidisciplinary field of digital studies still goes by too many names, it has swiftly expanded its boundaries in the last decade to include critical software/algorithm/AI/human–computer interactions, and to the best of my knowledge, no one has dared suggest a canon as of yet.Against this backdrop, the Posthuman Studies Reader, which names, maps, and negotiates canon for an even younger field, is a very bold, ambitious, and perhaps a tad premature attempt—even more so, given the fact that posthumanism poses a challenge to the very concept of boundaries and disciplines. It is more often understood as a perspective on any disciplinary knowledge, or as Andy Miah (2008) puts it, “the detritus of perspectives.” A closer reading of the Reader reveals a focus on the discourse associated with the human prefixes rather than a posthumanist approach to knowledge at large, which indeed would be impossible to chart, although some of Part One (out of four) of the book could be read as part of such an attempt.The book is composed of four parts.In Part A, “ Pedigrees of Posthuman Studies as an Academic Discipline and Contemporary Posthuman Movements,” the editors look back on the history of ideas from Heraclitus to Habermas through a posthuman lens, on one hand, and on the foundational texts in cybernetics and forerunners of trans- and posthumanism, on the other. You might be wondering what Habermas has to do with posthumanism. One of the unique and interesting characteristics of posthumanism is the tendency to include its critique as part of its discourse. We see this tendency in the following parts as well, with the inclusion of Francis Fukuyama and Katherine Hayles as key texts.To my surprise, however, Ivan Callus and Stefan Herbrechter, who are leading writers of critical posthumanism, are not included. I personally view their text/thought experiment “The Invention of Posthumanism without Technology” (Callus and Herbrechter 2007) as worthy of canon or at least a mention among foundational writers such as Hauskeller, Roden, and Ferrando. Furthermore, I view Filippo Tommaso Marinetti and Italian futurism as an important trans-/posthuman forerunner. Marinetti’s fascination with the speed of technology and the cosmic perspective, as well as his proto-cyborg myth of the man–torpedo or new centaur, is worth mentioning.In addition, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin wrote about going beyond the biosphere and human individual life before Huxley (in fact Huxley wrote the preface to his main book. The Phenomenon of Man, de Chardin 1958), and he is worth mentioning as a forerunner too. Finally, the inclusion of Russian cybernetics and cosmonautics is of paramount importance to this discussion, and to the best of my knowledge they are presented in this context for the first time in this reader.Parts B and C are dedicated to transhumanism and posthumanism, respectively, each including ten seminal, carefully chosen texts. The transhumanism part is organized historically, beginning with Huxley and FM-2030 and ending with Bostrom and Sorgner. The part on posthumanism begins with Ihab Hassan and Donna Haraway and includes indisputably canonical texts by writers such as Neil Badmington, Elaine Graham, Cary Wolfe, Rosi Braidotti, and Karen Barad. I expected to see Bruno Latour here as well, as Wolfe (2010) himself argues that Latour stands alongside Haraway as a “parent” of posthumanism, although both Haraway and Latour refuse to be associated formally with the discourse. The editors choose wisely to include contextual and interpretive information about each text and author; however, I was disappointed to find only excerpts from the original texts rather than the full texts. I understand that the number of pages in a book is limited; however, one would expect access to the full texts of the canon of a discipline in such a book, especially if one planned to use it as a textbook.The last part of the book (D) is dedicated to metahumanism, a term suggested by Jaime del Val and Stefan Sorgner (2010) as an attempt to bridge between trans- and posthumanist discourses. These are often treated as opposing stances, although they have quite a lot in common, an argument Sorgner developed further in his 2014 text book with Robert Ranisch, Post- and Transhumanism: An Introduction. Could this be considered part of the canon and deserving of its own section in the book, perhaps at the expanse of including authors such as Fuller, Stiegler, or even Simondon?I do not remember much from my graduate studies in communications, but I do recall how one professor put an end to a heated theoretical debate about the definition of “news.” She told us that the legendary broadcaster, Walter Cronkite, was asked this same question about what counts as news, and he replied, “it is news because I say so.” Indeed, the people situated at the heart of a practice, the ones who build its foundation and become associated with it, are probably the ones who get to define it. Thus, the question of locating “posthuman studies” and its canon is not a theoretical one. It is about who has the authority to define it.One could indeed think of Stefan L. Sorgner, the editor of this book series and a contributor to this reader, as the Walter Cronkite of the posthuman field. If we return to the constructs that mark the growth stages of an academic discipline, it is Sorgner, along with the editors of this reader, Evi Sampanikou and Jan Stasienko, who founded and is leading the “Beyond Humanism” international network, which holds an annual conference on post- and transhumanism. It is also Sorgner who formed and edits several book series with leading publishers dedicated to post and transhumanism, as well as the Journal of Posthuman Studies, which you are now reading, and it is again Sorgner who established the first Western undergraduate program in posthuman studies at John Cabot University in Rome (the other program, at Ewha Women’s University in Seoul, is also led by a member of the “Beyond Humanism” network).If “posthuman studies” is indeed a discipline, it seems to be in its proliferation stage, which may suggest it is too soon to negotiate a canon. Nevertheless, since Sorgner, Sampanikou, Stasienko and their colleagues, almost singlehandedly, are crafting and advancing this discipline through its forming stages, when they publish a book with handpicked canonic texts, it should be treated as a landmark. While individual readers might wonder (as I do) about the existence or absence of this text or that, the real question is who is the authority on the matter? In light of their background and activity, these editors are the people who get to define what is “posthuman studies,” and ultimately, a text is canon mainly because THEY said so.Finally, the book opens with a short anti-prologue by the original artist–researcher Stelarc, whom the editors view as a personification of current debates and the horizon of the field. However, the book is missing an epilogue or concluding remarks building on the juxtaposition of all these texts, which feels extremely necessary. On the other hand, openness and incompleteness, leaving room for the thoughts of the reader, are part of the message in posthumanism. These were MY thoughts as a reader, or shall we call them an “anti-review”?
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carmel L. Vaisman (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: