Key result
Combined exercise improves neuromuscular and cardiovascular fitness similarly in both obese and lean women.
Why the study?
Data regarding long-term adaptations to exercise between obese and lean individuals are limited with conflicting results.
Does a 3-month combined exercise program improve neuromuscular and cardiovascular adaptations similarly in obese and lean untrained premenopausal middle-aged women?
RCT (n=72)
Computer-generated list of random numbers
No
Does a 3-month combined exercise program improve neuromuscular and cardiovascular adaptations similarly in obese and lean untrained premenopausal middle-aged women?
A 3-month combined aerobic and strength training program is equally effective in improving functional capacity and physical fitness in both obese and lean untrained premenopausal middle-aged women.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support combined exercise for fitness gains in untrained middle-aged women regardless of obesity status; leaves open confirmation in larger randomized trials.
Previous studies indicated different acute adaptations between obese and lean individuals, while there is limited information with conflicting results regarding long-term adaptations. The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of a 3-month integrated combined training between obese and lean middle-aged untrained premenopausal women. In total, 72 women (36 obese/36 lean) were divided into four groups: (a) obese exercise (OB-EG), (b) obese control (OB-CG), (c) lean exercise (L-EG), and (d) lean control (L-CG). The exercise groups followed a 3-month (3 times/week) integrated combined aerobic and strength training program. Health indices (body composition, body circumferences, blood pressure, respiratory function), functional capacity (flexibility, balance), and physical fitness (strength, aerobic capacity) were measured before and after the 3-month time period. Participants’ enjoyment was also assessed following the program. OB-EG and L-EG significantly improved (p < 0.05) similarly across all functional capacity and physical fitness indices (10–76%; depending on the evaluation index), except balance and strength indices of the non-preferred limb where OB-EG showed greater improvement (reducing the existing pre-training strength/balance asymmetries) than L-EG. Furthermore, both obese and lean individuals showed similarly high levels of enjoyment. This program could be effectively used in fitness settings causing similar neuromuscular and cardiovascular adaptations in obese and lean women.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Καρατράντου et al. (2023) conducted an RCT in Obesity (n=72). Integrated combined aerobic and strength training program vs. No exercise (control group) was evaluated on Health, functional capacity, and physical fitness indices (body composition, blood pressure, respiratory function, flexibility, balance, strength, aerobic capacity) (p=<0.05). A 3-month integrated combined exercise program caused similar, significant improvements in neuromuscular and cardiovascular adaptations in both obese and lean untrained middle-aged women.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: