Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Regional exploratory study examines soil carbon in relation to fertilizer N/P ratios across cropping systems, suggesting management implications.
Fertilizer nitrogen-to-phosphorus (N/P) stoichiometry diverges between soil test recommendations and conventional farmer practices in tropical Asia; however, its associations with labile soil carbon fractions remain poorly characterized. This regional exploratory study quantified N/P input divergence and examined co-occurring soil carbon patterns across four cropping systems in northern Thailand. A fertilizer management dataset of 138 field records was combined with a complementary soil property dataset of 303 topsoil samples (101 plots × 3 management groups: App (soil test-based fertilizer recommendation), Farmer (conventional practice), and NF (No-Fertilizer control)). The two datasets were drawn from the same regional agroecosystem context but were not paired plot-by-plot; therefore, the results are interpreted as associations rather than direct cause–effect linkages. Soil properties included pH, macronutrients, total soil organic carbon (SOC), permanganate-oxidizable carbon (POXC), and oxidizable fractions (labile, less labile, and non-labile) quantified by wet oxidation. The App N/P mass ratios (kg N kg−1 P) exceeded Farmer in all systems, with the greatest divergence in Rice (9.14 vs. 1.83) and Vegetables (7.62 vs. 2.24). Total SOC did not differ among management groups (p = 0.828), but labile carbon (LC) was significantly higher under Farmer (13.59 g kg−1) than under App (7.46) and NF (3.34; p < 0.001), while POXC was elevated under NF and pH under App (both p < 0.001). Management associations were consistent across the soil orders and crop groups. LC and POXC appeared to be more sensitive short-term indicators than bulk SOC in this dataset. Because the soil property dataset is not paired plot-by-plot with the fertilizer dataset, and because management contrasts are also confounded with co-occurring differences in total fertilizer input, organic matter management, residue management, and environmental conditions, the observed associations cannot establish a direct causal role for the N/P ratio per se. The results suggest a possible association between low-N/P farmer fertilization and higher labile carbon in smallholder systems in northern Thailand; confirmation of causal mechanisms requires paired within-plot longitudinal studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Aumtong et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: