Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Longitudinal analysis reveals slower growth in female neurosurgery faculty compared to male faculty, highlighting workforce disparities.
To the Editor: We thank the authors for their interest1 in our article, “Trends in the Academic Neurosurgical Workforce: A Longitudinal Analysis of Gender and Race/Ethnic Representation in the United States From 2012 to 2021”.2 We agree that both absolute and proportional growth of female faculty representation are important for characterizing progress toward workforce diversity. On revisiting our analysis, we identified an error in the originally reported annual growth rate for female neurosurgery faculty. We have corrected this error and reconducted linear regression modeling to ensure accurate assessment of gender-based trends in academic neurosurgery. Our corrected linear regression analysis demonstrates that the annual growth rate for female neurosurgery faculty is 23.0 per year (95% CI: 17.9-28.1; P < .001), while the annual growth rate for male faculty is 40.2 per year (95% CI: 35.1-45.4; P < .001). The interaction term shows a statistically significant difference of −17.2 (95% CI: −24.5 to −10.0; P < .001), confirming that female faculty are being added to the academic neurosurgery workforce at a slower rate than their male counterparts. Although the authors suggested presenting proportional changes between time points, regression modeling incorporates year-to-year variation across the study period and allows direct comparison of growth rates. These analyses demonstrate that although absolute numbers of female faculty have increased, the pace of growth remains slower than that observed among male faculty. To further evaluate whether increases in female faculty translated into representation at senior ranks, we stratified our analysis by academic position. For senior positions (associate and full professor), male faculty increased annually by 20.4 (95% CI: 17.5-23.4; P < .001), whereas female faculty increased by 11.8 (95% CI: 8.9-14.8; P < .001). For assistant professor positions, male faculty increased annually by 19.8 (95% CI: 16.8-22.8; P < .001), whereas female faculty increased by 11.2 (95% CI: 8.2-14.2; P < .001). These findings indicate that at both senior and nonsenior levels, male faculty were added at approximately twice the rate of female faculty. However, approximately half of the growth for both male and female faculty occurred at senior ranks, suggesting comparable advancement patterns once individuals enter academic neurosurgery. These findings indicate that disparities seem to be driven primarily by differential entry into the academic pipelines rather than promotion rates. Regarding commentary on attrition across earlier stages of the academic pipeline, our study was designed to evaluate longitudinal demographic trends within the academic neurosurgical workforce, primarily at the resident and faculty levels. Evaluation of medical student-level data was therefore outside the intended scope of this workforce-focused analysis. Nevertheless, we referenced physician-led initiatives targeting earlier pipeline stages to contextualize ongoing efforts to improve workforce diversity. Our findings at the resident and faculty levels complement rather than replace, investigations examining earlier points of attrition. We also acknowledge the authors' reference to Maqsood et al, whose findings regarding persistent gender disparities parallel trends observed in our analysis.3 In our study, the proportion of female neurosurgery residents increased from 15.1% to 20.5% between 2011 and 2020. We presented these trends alongside longitudinal changes in the male representation to evaluate whether patterns observed during training persist in the academic workforce. In addition, we discussed initiatives such as Women in Neurosurgery that aim to address disparities identified in prior studies. Our findings, together with those of Persad-Paisley et al and Maqsood et al, contribute to the ongoing discussion regarding workforce disparities across stages of neurosurgical training and practice.3,4 We agree with the authors regarding the importance of an intersectional lens when evaluating workforce diversity. Our study relied on aggregated national Data sets from the Association of American Medical Colleges and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, which do not permit individual-level linkage of race and gender. As such, intersectional stratification was beyond the scope of the Data set and represents a limitation. Similarly, institution variables such as departmental diversity initiatives and policy-level factors are not consistently captured in the national workforce databases. Future studies examining departmental policies and their relationship to workforce diversity would provide valuable insight. We also agree that qualitative factors such as mentorship, inclusion, and departmental culture are important components of workforce equity. Our analysis focused on longitudinal demographic trends derived from national Data sets that do not include measures of mentorship quality or workplace climate. Although numerical representation alone does not fully capture equity within academic neurosurgery, our findings demonstrate continued disparities in representation, particularly among underrepresented racial and ethnic groups. These observations suggest that structural and cultural factors beyond pipeline expansion may influence recruitment and retention. Future investigations incorporating qualitative methodologies, such as surveys and institutional assessments may further clarify the role of mentorship structures and departmental culture in shaping workforce diversity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Akinwunmi-Williams et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: