Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The murder of George Floyd at the hands of police served as a watershed moment in our nation's history and spurred a racial and ethnic diversity reckoning in the United States and abroad. This long-needed undertaking occurred simultaneously across nearly every industry, with health care being one of the most visible participants in this effort. The field of medicine had particular difficulties at the start of this movement because of a pre-existing lack of diversity in its workforce and concurrent coping with increasing socioeconomic and racial healthcare disparities exacerbated by the pandemic. Neurosurgery had an even steeper hill to climb than other medical specialties, because of its historically poor track record on diversity, which is worse than medicine as a whole. We will provide context for the current state of racial diversity in neurosurgery, identify challenges and areas of progress, and discuss multilevel implementation strategies to improve racial diversity in our field. IMPORTANCE OF DIVERSITY AND CHALLENGES Recent investigations across disciplines have demonstrated the beneficial impact of diversity on innovation,1,2 creativity,3 collaboration,4 and overall performance.5 Diverse academic collaborations are associated with higher journal impact publications than homogenous groups, likely secondary to increased research quality and influence of broader networks that increase citations.6,7 Racial minorities suffer from greater health disparities because of poorer access to health care, lower prevalence of medical insurance, and lesser use of preventative measures.8 Communities with large percentages of Black and Latinx residents are significantly more likely to have a shortage of doctors.9 Studies demonstrate that Black doctors are more likely to treat Black patients10 and those who are uninsured or without private insurance, irrespective of their racial or ethnic background.9,11 When making complex medical decisions, patients who receive care from racially and culturally competent doctors report improved communication, adherence to treatment, and increased satisfaction.12 As a result, the Association of American Medical Colleges has affirmed that increasing diversity in academic medical centers is critical to the goal of reducing healthcare disparities in the United States.13 Under-represented in medicine (URiM) individuals remain poorly represented in the neurosurgical workforce including academia. As of 2019, less than 4% of all neurosurgeons in the United States are Black and 5% are Latinx.14 The immediate pipeline does not appear particularly promising because only 5% of neurosurgery residents are Black and 7% are Latinx.15 One third of neurosurgery programs in the United States do not have a single faculty member who are from an URiM group.15 A diverse workforce is essential for us to reach our potential across all our missions and provide better care for patients from all communities. Thus, increasing racial diversity in neurosurgery should be one of the top priorities in our field. Race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status are associated social categories that can capture differential exposure to educational access. These disparities in education commonly begin in elementary and junior high schools, which leave these students on a trajectory that makes a career in medicine, let alone neurosurgery, very difficult. This is supported by studies that suggest that the underlying disparities may be in part due to the inaccessibility of the medical profession to low-income students, who, owing to powerful historical and contemporary forces (eg, structural racism and lower family incomes), are disproportionately students who identify with URiM communities.16 Unfortunately, data suggest that these disparities are actually getting worse. For instance, over the past 40 years, the percentage of women medical students has steadily increased from 24.4% to 50.6%, yet the percentage of Black male medical students is less than what it was 40 years ago, 3.1%–2.9%.17 Not surprisingly, because of the somewhat stagnant pipeline, the number of URiM neurosurgery residents has not significantly increased in the past decade, in comparison with the significant increase in the number of female residents during the same period.18,19 Once a URiM student decides to enter medical school, a number of barriers to neurosurgery exist. First, not all medical schools provide equal access and exposure to neurosurgery. A recent study by Antar et al20 found that from 2014 to 2020, approximately 85% of neurosurgery residents attended neurosurgery feeder medical schools, which shared key characteristics that increased students' early interest in neurosurgery, such as neurosurgery interest groups, a home neurosurgery training program, and large faculty size. By contrast, Black student representation is increased compared with the national average at nonfeeder medical schools, further widening the racial disparity gap in neurosurgery.21 In addition, with the economic burden of applying into neurosurgery continuing to be one of the highest (eg away rotations, research, etc) and having the longest residency training lengths, diverse students from low socioeconomic status can easily become overwhelmed by the prospects of the field because they frequently do not have the same financial support as their peers from higher-income households to spend thousands of dollars rotating at away institutions, interviewing, and often applying to many more programs. Therefore, URiM medical students may not only be disadvantaged by having fewer academic opportunities to match but also financially constrained to apply more broadly.16,22 Effective mentorship is essential to achieving a diversified neurosurgical workforce. There is ample evidence that mentors and role models play a critical role in the training and retention of diverse faculty within academic medicine,23 yet paradoxically URiM junior faculty commonly receive less mentorship than their non-URiM colleagues.24-26 Even in institutions where academic mentorship is available to early stage URiM faculty, critical cultural mentorship and guidance may be lacking, such as how to deal with the minority tax or other structural barriers. The consistently low numbers of URiM in neurosurgery training programs and in the workplace result in a dearth of URM role models for the mentoring of medical students, residents, and junior faculty practitioners.27,28 In a cyclical effect, the absence of a critical mass of URiM neurosurgeons in academic medicine may also serve as a deterrent to URiM medical students deciding whether to pursue careers in neurosurgery.15,29 This is supported by studies that demonstrate that URiM medical students are more likely to lose interest in the surgical subspecialties between matriculation and graduation.30 The dismantling of structures of systemic racism promotes equity in the workplace. At each stage of a neurosurgical trainees' career, structural racism, implicit bias, and other systemic inequities create "leaky pipelines" that impede the advancement of individuals from URiM groups.31 Implicit bias is particularly problematic because these negative associations are commonly made subconsciously, yet have a strong influence on overall perceptions and decision-making. One of the most salient examples of implicit bias involves the determination of clerkship grades in medical school, where non-White race is independently associated with lower grades in all clerkships.32 Clerkship grades are frequently tied to other honors and awards such as the Alpha Omega Alpha (AOA) Society, which in turn makes these recipients appear to be stronger neurosurgery residency applicants. Although AOA members are only 16% of medical school graduates, they compose 40% of residents within the most competitive specialties.33 In some ways, this phenomenon is reminiscent of the accumulative advantage described by Malcom Gladwell34 in his best-selling book Outliers. As sociological research has uncovered the previously hidden truth about implicit bias in US medical schools, a number of institutions have changed their grading to pass fail and/or removed the AOA designation altogether. These actions will likely decrease the effect of implicit bias in these particular domains, yet unfortunately will not address harm done to previous generations who were adversely affected by these structural inequities. While inequities in compensation and funding have improved in US public academic institutions when metrics of academic success are considered, there remain significant opportunities to address implicit prejudices that disadvantage under-represented groups in academic promotions, hiring for leadership positions, and institutional support for research.35-37 PROGRESS AND IMPLEMENTATIONS For the field of neurosurgery to reach its full potential, a multilevel approach is required to promote further racial and ethnic diversity. To ensure success, these actions need to be undertaken at the national, institutional, departmental, and individual levels.38 On a national level, organized neurosurgery has recently become engaged in a number of different initiatives to recognize and promote racial and ethnic diversity. In 2020, after the murder of George Floyd, the President of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons, Dr John Wilson, and the Congress of Neurological Surgeons (CNS), President Dr Steven Kalkanis, penned a letter in the Neurosurgery Blog that stated, "the American Association of Neurological Surgeons and CNS have joined the chorus speaking out against all forms of discrimination and acts of violence—particularly that which is driven by intolerance and hatred…we reaffirm our commitment to inclusion and diversity and we listen to our Black and Brown colleagues who provide a uniquely pertinent perspective on these issues, and we are thankful for their leadership and willingness to speak out." This unequivocal support from the leaders of our two national organizations was an important first step in acknowledging the importance of diversity in our field and greater society and helped others in neurosurgery to evaluate where they could contribute to this critical effort. Since that time, the CNS has hosted the Pathway to Neurosurgery Program at the annual meeting, where local high school students from disadvantaged communities are invited to attend the meeting and participate in an all-day introduction to neurosurgery session with neurosurgery faculty. This form of early outreach and exposure is required to improve the pipeline for URiM students in neurosurgery. Small group educational pipeline programs and student exclusive networking symposiums provide students with early familiarity with the field. Most neurosurgery applicants become committed to the field before entering the medical school.39 Consequently, efforts to preliminarily engage prospective URiM healthcare students help build self-confidence, provide exposure to the specialty, and reduce perceived barriers to a neurosurgical career.40 This was evidenced by the Future Leaders in Neurosurgery Symposium for Underrepresented Students, a seven-hour symposium hosted by Duke University for high school and college students, which featured presentations from preeminent neurosurgeons from across the country.40 Pre- and postsymposium surveys demonstrated increased participant familiarity with neurosurgery, increased confidence in their ability to become a neurosurgeon, and increased exposure to neurosurgeons from diverse groups. The American Society of Black Neurosurgeons has also made a significant impact since its inception in 2020,41 hosting a series of webinars and a mentorship program designed to increase the number of Black students entering the field of neurosurgery. Another national novel program to improve diversity in academic neurosurgery is the K12 Pipeline Accelerator Program for 3rd, 4th, and 5th year neurosurgery residents, which is sponsored by the National Institutes of Health and derived from the Neurosurgeon Research Career Development Program. The K12 Pipeline Accelerator is focused on increasing the pool of URiM and women to become successful neurosurgeon-scientists and to promote diversity of research. Eligible residents are nominated by their department or program director and participate in a two-day event designed to inspire the next generation of surgeon scientists and receive mentoring throughout the academic year. There has also been significant progress at the institutional and departmental levels throughout neurosurgery. The University of Miami started the Summer Research Scholarship in Neurosurgery for Black Students in 2020, a nine-week program where medical and graduate students are exposed to neuroscience research and clinical neurosurgery.21 Based on its initial success, the program was expanded in 2023 to include seven programs—Johns Hopkins, University of Miami, University of Nebraska, New York University Lagone Health, University of North Carolina, University of California Los Angeles, and Washington University. Each institution interviews each applicant, and student scholarship locations are determined from a match process using student and departmental rank lists. The participating neurosurgery department provides salary support and housing for the students. A significant percentage of these students attend nonfeeder medical schools for neurosurgery, and further expansion to additional neurosurgery departments is expected in 2024. University departmental efforts are vital to recruiting and sustaining URiM student interest in neurosurgery. The financial burden of applying to neurosurgery is considerably higher than other subspecialties. Establishing neurosurgery diversity scholarships aimed at reducing the cost of subinternships and interviews, along with investments to improve funding opportunities for research and academia for under-represented minority URiM students, may help equalize the academic playing field in an attempt to trivialize the advantages that higher-family income may provide.42,43 These financial scholarships also serve to improve the program's accessibility to subinterns and diversify the applicant pool.41 Holistic applicant rank metrics can improve workforce diversity by limiting implicit biases and mitigating the effects of structural barriers.21,44 As the mode of communication has moved increasingly virtual, using social media to build inclusivity encourages equal participation of members regardless of their background.21 Moreover, university departments may use their strategic position to establish national professional organization chapters to strengthen ties to the undergraduate and graduate URiM communities through the promotion of research and clinical outreach programs associated with building skills in academia and leadership.41 It is critical for each neurosurgery department to have an active Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Committee. Departmental DEI committees help to create a psychologically safe working and learning environment for a diverse body of learners, staff, and faculty, which ultimately positively affects patient experience and outcomes.45 An inclusive environment aids in the recruitment and retention of URiM trainees and faculty.46 The DEI committee should have annual goals and metrics focused on multiple domains such as departmental climate, community engagement, equitable patient care, and professional development. The committee chair should receive a Vice Chair or the equivalent title and receive salary support for this position, which is commensurate with the responsibilities of the role and importance to the department. Finally, there are tremendous opportunities for academic and community neurosurgeons to help improve racial diversity in neurosurgery at the individual level by serving as mentors to URiM students. This mentorship can take place anywhere along the pipeline, starting in elementary school. A single one-hour meeting with a surgeon can positively influence a medical student's career choice in surgery.47 Longitudinal mentoring pathway initiatives are even more effective and have been shown to be one of the most effective programs to increase the number of URiMs in the surgical specialties.28 Andrew Wang, MAS David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA Langston T.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wang et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: