Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article traces the analogy between Kamakura Buddhism and the Protestant Reformation, highlighting its historical development and implications.
Few comparative frameworks in the historiography of Japanese religion have proven more durable, or more contested, than the analogy between the “New Buddhism” of the Kamakura period and the Protestant Reformation. This article traces the construction and consolidation of this analogy from its first systematic articulation by the historian Hara Katsurō (1871–1924) in 1911 to its absorption into the scholarly mainstream in the work of Ienaga Saburō (1913–2002) in the 1940s. Situating this discourse within the broader history of modern Japanese Buddhist historiography, and in particular within the emergence of the “sect” as the fundamental unit of Buddhist historical writing, the article argues that the analogy's durability owes as much to institutional and ideological conditions as to its analytical value. Central to the argument is the claim that Hara, Matsumoto Hikojirō (1880–1958), and Ienaga shared a common narrative structure in which Kamakura‐era Buddhism signified not rupture but recovery: the reactivation of a spirit of Japaneseness or, in Ienaga's more universalistic formulation, a logic of negation that had always remained latent. The fact that Ienaga's work, now celebrated as a landmark of postwar liberal historiography, initially garnered approval from figures with close ties to wartime nationalist networks further illuminates the ambivalences at the heart of this tradition. The article concludes by situating these findings within the ongoing entanglement of Buddhist scholarship with the institutional interests of the schools whose history it narrates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Orion Klautau (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: