Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Survey reveals persistent gender disparity in advanced endoscopy, demanding urgent structural reforms.
10.1055/a-2839-7450 The paper by O’Reilly et al. provides the first international survey examining why women remain persistently underrepresented in advanced endoscopy [ 1 ]. Their findings are striking, yet entirely consistent with decades of evidence across interventional medicine – 61.3% of female respondents felt their gender had hindered career progression; access to complex procedural training remains unequal; and women were less likely to have partners or dependents. What is most disquieting is that, as the authors themselves note, little has changed in 20 years. These barriers are neither inevitable nor immutable – they are structural in origin, and they demand structural responses. Globally, women comprise the majority of medical graduates, yet their representation in procedural subspecialties remains startlingly low. Within gastroenterology, women represent only 30% of general gastroenterology fellows and, in 2019, only 12.8% of fellows who were matched to advanced endoscopy fellowship programs were women [ 2 ]. The phenomenon is cross-specialty and cross-continent, suggesting entrenched systemic causes rather than individual preferences are to blame. “The real question now is not whether gender disparity in advanced endoscopy still exists, it is how much longer the field is willing to accept it as normal.” These disparities do not disappear in well-resourced academic environments: the survey illustrated gender differences were persistent regardless of center type, training infrastructure, or research activity. The issue is not solely whether women get into advanced endoscopy programs, it is about what happens to them once they are there. Who receives encouragement and support? Who is offered interventional operating lists? Who is seen as leadership material? This points to what has been termed the illusion of diversity, where women are present only in modest numbers, yet appear disproportionately visible precisely because of their scarcity. It is perpetuated by perfunctory symbolic efforts – in the form of a token committee appointment, a single female panelist, or a diversity statement unaccompanied by any change to selection processes or power structures – amounting to a hollow substitute for substantive reform. If women are “already there” and the institution is visibly “doing something,” why is further change necessary? The procedural data from O’Reilly et al. offers a clear answer: women were less likely to have the opportunity to perform complex procedures. In advanced endoscopy, technical identity is built case by case, shaped not only by talent but by access to opportunities, mentors, and the kind of trust that turns exposure into expertise. O’Reilly et al. found that female endoscopists were more likely to report a delay in their career progression due to family commitments and, conversely, that career demands delayed their starting a family. The absence of flexible training options during these key years is a structural disincentive, disproportionately falling on women. Women are less likely to attain full professorship, even after controlling for research productivity and years in practice. One issue is the motherhood penalty, a well-documented phenomenon whereby parenthood penalizes women’s career trajectories, earnings, and perceived competence, while leaving men’s unaffected, or even enhanced (the fatherhood bonus) [ 3 ]. Parental leave is rarely fully accommodated in procedural training and early career positions, and “commitment” is routinely conflated with one’s availability. A penalty that begins at parental leave compounds over decades. It is worth emphasizing that greater flexibility and improved working conditions benefit all clinicians at every stage of their careers, not only those with caring responsibilities. A frequently overlooked barrier is the physical design of endoscopic equipment. Endoscopy-related musculoskeletal injuries are common, affecting half of surveyed endoscopists, with women reporting significantly higher rates than men. Female endoscopists are, on average, shorter, with smaller hand spans and lower grip strength, yet standard endoscopes and devices have been designed without these anatomical considerations. Equipment manufacturers bear responsibility for inclusive design; however, without institutional demand, there is little pressure to provide. A consistent deterrent for women considering fluoroscopy-guided interventional specialties are concerns about radiation exposure and perceived risks to their reproductive health and pregnancy [ 2 ]. However, the available evidence indicates that with appropriate shielding and dose-reduction techniques, radiation exposure can be maintained within established safety thresholds. Transparent, evidence-based education on radiation safety is urgently required to replace fear with fact. The most significant barrier for women in hierarchical organizations is often not the glass ceiling, it’s their very first step onto the leadership ladder, termed “the broken rung.” This is where women have restricted access to training positions, are handed limited or less complex operating lists, and have less support from the outset of their career. Over time this erodes development of technical expertise. When women are passed over at that initial promotion – often subtly, without explicit intent – the ranks thin before seniority is ever reached. The argument that women self-select away from advanced endoscopy because of its on-call demands or physical nature is not supported by the evidence. Obstetrics and gynecology, a specialty characterized by unpredictable 24-hour on-call, physically demanding operative work, and high procedural complexity, comprises over 80% female trainees in many countries [ 4 ]. This demonstrates clearly that women do not avoid technically challenging, call-heavy procedural specialties when cultural and structural conditions are equitable. Women are burdened disproportionately with non-promotable tasks – an inconspicuous phenomenon with significant consequences to career advancement. Tasks such as committee service and administrative coordination benefit the institution, but carry little weight in decisions on promotion. Research consistently shows that women are more often asked to perform these tasks, are less able to decline without social cost, and spend significantly more time on them [ 5 ]. This is time diverted from the case volume, publications, and high profile activities that lead to career progression. O’Reilly et al.’s finding that only 50.9% of women felt they were offered career development opportunities at the same time as colleagues of the opposite sex, versus 75.2% of men, speaks both to structural inequity and its normalization. This disparity in perception is not secondary to the problem, it is part of the problem. Those disadvantaged by the system experience it directly; those less affected are unaware of it, which is precisely how inequity persists while being dismissed as anecdotal or already solved. The absence of visible female role models and specialty-specific mentorship is a recurring and self-perpetuating barrier. This is quantifiable in advanced endoscopy: Yu et al. found the proportion of female advanced endoscopy faculty to be the strongest predictor of female fellow recruitment, with nearly half of US advanced endoscopy fellowship programs reporting no female faculty at all, and nearly one-third having never trained a single female fellow [ 2 ]. The inaugural Women in Endoscopy Mentorship Programme, from which O’Reilly et al.’s authorship group arose, is a promising model. Formal mentorship structures, sponsorship programs in which senior leaders actively advocate for junior women, and peer networks must be embedded within specialty training frameworks, not left to individuals to seek out. Addressing this requires commitment from professional societies, not just goodwill alone. Gender disparities are amplified in academic and leadership spheres. Across multiple interventional fields, women remain underrepresented as authors in high impact journals, as international conference presenters, on editorial boards, and in department chair roles. Women also receive a disproportionately small share of research funding relative to their representation in the workforce [ 6 ]. These compounding disadvantages – reduced visibility, funding inequity, and limited influence over training cultures – constitute the “leaky pipeline.” This is a workforce in which women are progressively filtered out at each stage of seniority, not through overt exclusion, but through an insufficiently reformed system that is unable to accommodate and support them. Encouragingly, practical frameworks for structural change have been implemented in other specialty groups. The Royal Australasian College of Surgeons has set gender equity targets across training and leadership, with flexible, less-than-full-time training pathways to assist these goals. The Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists’ national gender equity survey confirmed persistent barriers including an unexplained pay gap and unchanged harassment rates, supporting a Gender Equity Action Plan, the establishment of a Women’s Empowerment and Leadership Initiative, and commitment to annual public gender metrics reporting. Achieving equity requires institutions and professional societies to audit processes for gender bias, set transparent representation targets, and document disparities to drive accountability. These are proven solutions, which procedural gastroenterology should adopt. O’Reilly et al. are correct that disappointingly little has changed in two decades. Advanced endoscopy does not simply need more women entering the field, it needs systems that allow them to stay, progress, lead, and thrive on genuinely equal terms. The specialty owes it to its patients, and to the talented women it continues to lose, to move beyond the scope of good intentions. O’Reilly et al. have not uncovered a new problem. They have done something equally valuable: they have made it harder to look away from an old one. The real question now is not whether gender disparity in advanced endoscopy still exists, it is how much longer the field is willing to accept it as normal. Publication History Article published online: 15 June 2026 © 2026. Thieme. All rights reserved. Georg Thieme Verlag KG Oswald-Hesse-Straße 50, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany Refers to: Beyond the scope: a global perspective on gender disparity among advanced endoscopists Endoscopy eFirst DOI: 10.1055/a-2839-7450
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Holt et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: