Key result
Auscultation of heart murmurs generally correlates poorly with the severity of heart valve disease determined by echocardiography, particularly for diastolic murmurs.
Why the study?
The correlation between murmurs by auscultation and heart valve disease severity by echocardiography is generally poor, particularly for diastolic murmurs.
Does auscultation accurately predict echocardiographic findings in adults with heart murmurs?
Does auscultation accurately predict echocardiographic findings in adults with heart murmurs?
Auscultation correlates poorly with echocardiographic severity of heart valve disease, highlighting the importance of echocardiography in evaluating murmurs.
Echocardiography remains essential for murmur evaluation; supports hypothesis-generating role of auscultation training studies.
A heart murmur in adults is a common reason for referral for echocardiography at most general cardiology clinics in Europe. A murmur may indicate either a mild age-related valvular calcification or regurgitation, or represent a significant heart valve disease requiring valvular intervention. Generally, the correlation between murmurs by auscultation and severity of heart valve disease by echocardiography is poor. Particularly, the severity and characterization of diastolic murmurs by auscultation may poorly correlate with echocardiographic findings. This narrative review aims to summarize the differential diagnoses of physiological and pathological murmurs, describes the current referral practice of murmur patients for echocardiography, and presents a single-center experience on the correlation of auscultation and echocardiographic findings with a particular focus on aortic and mitral valve diseases. A careful auscultation of the heart prior to the echocardiogram is mandatory and may help to predict the echocardiographic findings and their interpretation in view of the clinical information. The correlation between clinical examination, point of care ultrasound and standard echocardiography is a matter of continued exploration.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Saeed et al. (2022) conducted a review in Heart murmur. Auscultation vs. Echocardiography was evaluated on Correlation between murmurs by auscultation and severity of heart valve disease by echocardiography. Auscultation of heart murmurs generally correlates poorly with the severity of heart valve disease determined by echocardiography, particularly for diastolic murmurs.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: