Climate-Specific Performance of Textile Membrane Sports Halls: Energy Efficiency, Comfort, and Economic Assessment via EnergyPlus

Textile membrane systems are increasingly used in sports halls because of their low structural weight, rapid assembly, and ability to span large areas. Their operational performance, however, is strongly affected by local climate conditions, envelope configuration and the limited thermal inertia of membrane materials. This study presents a comparative EnergyPlus-based assessment of textile membrane sports halls in six representative climate contexts: Helsinki, Berlin, Niš, Barcelona, Dawadmi and Bangkok. A conventional masonry hall was used as the reference case and compared with a single-layer PVC-coated polyester membrane system and double-layer membrane systems with air gaps of 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6 m, including mechanically ventilated air-cavity variants. The assessment combines four performance indicators: annual operational energy demand, carbon emissions, indicative global cost and thermal comfort expressed through Fanger’s Predicted Percentage of Dissatisfied (PPD) index. The results show that the dominant energy demand is climate-dependent, with heating prevailing in cold climates and cooling becoming decisive in hot-arid and hot-humid climates. Double-layer cases usually show lower operational energy demand and lower associated carbon dioxide emissions than the single-layer membrane case. This improvement, however, is not uniform; it depends on the climatic setting and on the width of the air gap. The comfort results lead to a similar but more limited conclusion. Although PPD is reduced in the double-layer configurations, the values remain above conventional comfort acceptance levels in all tested cases. The double-layer membrane should therefore be understood as a measure that reduces thermal dissatisfaction, not as a complete comfort solution. The economic assessment indicates that membrane systems have substantially lower initial capital costs than masonry construction, while their long-term performance depends on operational energy costs, membrane replacement assumptions and the selected analysis horizon. The study provides a climate-specific comparative framework for early-stage envelope selection in textile membrane sports halls, emphasizing that energy demand, carbon emissions, cost and thermal comfort should be considered together rather than as separate outputs.