Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A foundational question in social theory concerns the mechanisms of institutional stability and change, that is, how field-wide orders are reproduced and transformed through individual-level practices. For the sociology of science, this translates to a specific question: how do the persuasive practices of researchers aggregate to shape the epistemic values of a field? Yet, systematically connecting individual-level persuasive claims to field-wide value change has remained a methodological and theoretical challenge. This paper addresses this gap by introducing the Persuasive Positioning Model (PPM), a framework that classifies the logics of persuasion into four distinct types: Empirical Superiority, Niche Construction, Methodological Virtue, and Structural Contribution. The PPM is operationalized through a case study of Artificial Intelligence (AI), using a large-scale computational analysis of 17,756 conference papers from the pre-revolution (2010–2012) and mature deep learning (2022–2024) eras. The findings document a fundamental value reconfiguration in AI, revealing a significant decline in the logic of Methodological Virtue and a corresponding rise in the logics of Niche Construction and Structural Contribution, while the logic of Empirical Superiority persisted as the field’s dominant organizing principle. These results are synthesized into a conceptual model of value reconfiguration defined by three interlocking dynamics: the Persistence of the dominant logic, the Emergence of competing counter-logics, and the resulting Pluralization of the field’s epistemic values. By connecting individual-level persuasive claims to field-wide shifts in epistemic values, the framework and the computational pipeline developed to operationalize it offer a replicable approach for studying how the values of scientific fields are constructed and reconfigured over time.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tenzin Tamang (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: