Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Study applies the P-J-E-A Model for AI-assisted teaching preparation, suggesting practice implications.
The rapid adoption of generative artificial intelligence in teaching preparation has outpaced the development of practical frameworks for documenting how instructors evaluate and transform AI-generated materials. This paper proposes and applies the P-J-E-A Model - Prompt, Judgment, Ethics, and Artifact - as a reflective framework for AI-assisted teaching preparation. The study asks how professional judgment is exercised and documented when a higher education instructor uses generative AI to design teaching materials. Using self-study methodology, the framework is applied to nine unique teaching artifacts from design and engineering education, including visual exemplars, class activity materials, Excel templates, and engineering drawing resources. The methodological evidence trail links each episode's prompt record, observable output-to-artifact changes, instructor rationale, ethical considerations, and retained final artifact. Because these evidence types are not commensurable, they are analyzed qualitatively rather than aggregated into stage totals or percentages. Cross-episode analysis developed five candidate professional-judgment patterns: contextual adaptation, student-oriented scaffolding, affective and ethical design, Saudi localization corrections, and assessment integrity risk. Additional findings concerned document-structure omissions, iterative prompting, and the development of disclosure practice. Within this single-practitioner dataset, AI outputs functioned as provisional material requiring disciplinary, contextual, and ethical transformation. The model is offered as a reflective heuristic rather than a validated measurement instrument, with implications for teaching practice, professional development, and future multi-practitioner research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lena Darweesh (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: