Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While the field has amassed a sizeable literature related to sentencing decisions, there is considerable disagreement regarding magnitude and robustness of race-gender effects on sentencing outcomes. With focal concerns theory as a frame for shifting sentencing persuasions, we explore the nature and robustness of the relationships between race, gender and sentencing across different time periods, considering both individual legal factors and time-varying county-level factors. Using State Court Processing Statistics across thirty years, we employ a series of multilevel models to assess whether extra-legal factors influence non-custodial, jail, and prison decisions similarly across time periods. We further explore sentence severity as measured by sentence length within probation, jail, and prison populations. Race-gender effects show volatility across time, and differ by the decision examined (i.e. custody decisions and the length of any sentenced supervision). Female discounts sometimes emerge in the form of preference for non-custodial sentences, but these wane while other decision points such as prison length emerge. For men, differences consistently appear between Black and White males, although again, the particular outcome differs. The fluctuation and location of race-gender effects over time suggests further attention to the historical sensibilities that shape sentencing decisions and inequality.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thompson et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: