Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Qualitative analysis explores how religious identity drives nonviolent movements to adopt violence, suggesting deep socio-political implications.
What drives a nonviolent movement to adopt violent strategies? The paper examines this question through a Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) of the Saffron Revolution in Myanmar and the movement led by Hefazat-e-Islam (HI) in Bangladesh. Utilizing a similar system design, it explores how actors, including monks and lay people in Myanmar and religious leaders in Bangladesh, shaped agency and strategic choices within otherwise comparable movements. Theoretically, the study emphasizes micro-foundational dynamics, highlighting individual agency, emotional motivations, and ultranationalist ideologies as key factors driving the transition from nonviolent to violent action. By focusing on religious mobilization, it demonstrates how religious identity and cultural anxieties propelled activists and leaders toward violence, even in the absence of severe state repression. The findings also show that ultranationalist narratives and the prioritization of religious identity over other affiliations were instrumental in fostering violence in both cases. In addition, shifting the movement’s target also contributed to its transition from nonviolent to violent action by emphasizing the supremacy of their religious identity. By unpacking these processes, the paper contributes to the literature on social movements and nonviolence, offering a nuanced understanding of how micro-level mechanisms such as identity, preferences, and agency interact with broader socio-political contexts to produce strategic shifts. This analysis advances scholarly debates by specifying the conditions under which nonviolent resistance can transform into violent mobilization and by highlighting the central role of religious actors in shaping these trajectories.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Al-Amin et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: