Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This note downgrades the anti-correlation of fσ8 and S8 in modified gravity models, indicating further work is needed.
This short note synchronises the February 2026 Euclid prediction sheet (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18670573) with the scientific status established by the July 2026 Corrections Note (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21219761). The previously stated anti-correlated signature Δfσ8 > 0, ΔS8 < 0 is downgraded from a hard RMB prediction to a provisional phenomenological expectation. The downgrade is methodological and publication-level, NOT a physical refutation: the mapping from the RMB effective background sector to matter growth, the matter power spectrum, and observable lensing has not yet been derived from a complete perturbation and metric-coupling framework, and a percent-level S8 suppression is in any case not by itself a distinctive RMB signature (it is shared by f(Q) gravity, teleparallel gravity, and dynamical dark energy). Consequently, no distinctive joint fσ8/S8 signature is currently claimed. ΔS8 is withdrawn as a claimed signature; the fσ8 enhancement survives only as a non-distinctive consistency expectation. The note states the concrete derivation required before any S8 prediction can be reinstated: the modified-gravity response functions μ(a,k) and Σ(a,k) must be obtained from a consistent action or linear perturbation theory. Without a derived Σ(a,k) there is no RMB-specific lensing prediction; without a specific μ–Σ relation there is no distinctive anti-correlation. Part of the July 2026 RMB consolidation series.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Davide Dellomonaco (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: