Key result
In patients with ARDS, the mean VD/VT measured by carbon dioxide excretion was considerably higher than when measured with the multiple inert gas elimination technique.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Assessment of dead-space fraction based on carbon dioxide excretion in ARDS overestimates true dead space due to its sensitivity to ventilation-perfusion imbalances.
To the Editor: Nuckton and associates (April 25 issue) 1 report an abnormally high dead-space fraction (the ratio of dead-space ventilation to tidal volume, or V D /V T ) early in the clinical course of the acute respiratory distress syndrome. Their inference of a heretofore unrecognized functional abnormality is unwarranted, because V D /V T was assessed on the basis of carbon dioxide excretion with the usual Bohr-Enghoff equation. By definition, the patients had refractory hypoxemia, which reflects a severe imbalance between alveolar ventilation (V A ) and perfusion (Q), leading to a reduction in the efficiency of intrapulmonary gas transfer for both oxygen and carbon dioxide. 2 Thus, assessment of V D /V T on the basis of carbon dioxide excretion is sensitive to any imbalance in V A /Q -notably, in the midrange of values for V A /Q -and even shunt, although to a lesser extent. 3,4 This fact depends on the carbon dioxide bloodair partition coefficient's being relatively close to the normal range of V A /Q. 4 Specific assessment of high V A /Q areas and "true" dead space is possible, although practical only in small numbers of subjects, with the multiple inert gas elimination technique. We found that in eight patients with the acute respiratory distress syndrome, the mean (SD) value for V D /V T as measured on the basis of carbon dioxide excretion was considerably higher (0.640.03) than the value as measured with the multiple inert gas elimination technique (0.370.04). 5 In only one of these subjects did we detect areas with high values for V A /Q (range, 10 to 100). That V D /V T was more closely correlated with the outcome than was the ratio of the partial pressure of oxygen (PaO 2 ) to the fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO 2 ) remains a novel and highly relevant finding of the study by Nuckton et al. that may be due to the greater influence on the latter index of factors not intrinsic to the lung -notably, FiO 2 and mixed venous oxygen content.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Warkentin et al. (2002) conducted a letter in Acute respiratory distress syndrome (n=8). Measurement of VD/VT based on carbon dioxide excretion vs. Multiple inert gas elimination technique was evaluated on VD/VT value. In patients with ARDS, the mean VD/VT measured by carbon dioxide excretion was considerably higher than when measured with the multiple inert gas elimination technique.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: