Key result
Delphi consensus identifies four main risk factor areas for poor prognosis in youth.
Why the study?
Existing reviews of risk factors have limited value due to incompleteness and lack of clinical utility for decision-making.
A Delphi consensus identified four main areas of risk factors for poor prognosis in youth with emerging psychopathology, expanding beyond existing reviews to include contextual factors and treatment attitudes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Expert-informed transdiagnostic profiles may refine prognosis estimates; leaves open added value for treatment decisions beyond standard classifications.
Objective Identifying transdiagnostic risk profiles can complement traditional diagnostic classification systems by highlighting risk factors that offer additional insights for predicting prognosis and guiding treatment planning. Existing reviews of risk factors may have limited value due to their incompleteness and lack of clinical utility for decision-making. This study aimed to address these limitations by incorporating the perspectives of experts in the field. Our objective was to reach a consensus among specialists from various disciplines in mental health care on risk factors associated with poor prognosis and (accelerated) stage progression in youth across different diagnostic categories. Additionally, we aimed to develop an easy-to-use tool for assessing individual risk profiles in young people with emerging psychopathology.Method To achieve this, we conducted two focus groups with 11 experts who were specifically selected from different areas of mental healthcare. We then conducted a Delphi procedure with 12 experts to validate the expert consensus. We predetermined a threshold of two-thirds (67%) consensus, which required two Delphi rounds to achieve.Results The results highlight four main areas of risk factors: 1) child factors, 2) context factors, 3) characteristics of the symptoms and 4) treatment attitude. A user-friendly tool designed for clinical and research use was derived from these findings to facilitate the assessment of individual risk profiles.Conclusions Our findings partly overlap with existing review data but also expand their scope by highlighting the significance of contextual risk factors, specific symptom features, and the family’s attitude towards treatment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Clarke et al. (2026) studied Emerging psychopathology in youth (n=23). Delphi consensus on risk factors was evaluated on Consensus on risk factors associated with poor prognosis and stage progression. A Delphi consensus among mental health experts identified four main areas of risk factors for poor prognosis in youth: child factors, context factors, symptom characteristics, and treatment attitude.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: